Skip to content Skip to main navigation

Politics

Sponsored by Chamberlains - complete legal services for business

Andrew Leigh pushes for 5 x 5

By johnboy - 28 February 2013 32

Labor Member for Fraser Andrew Leigh has published his submission to the ACT Electoral Commission’s Expert Reference Group and it’s inquiry into the size of the ACT Legislative Assembly.

Like any smart observer he wants an expansion to a setup five five electorates each returning five members. (rather than the current nutso 5, 5, 7 arrangement).

As the population of Canberra continues to increase, the interests of the community could be disadvantaged by ongoing underrepresentation. Increasing the Assembly to 25 MLAs (consisting of five electorates, each returning five members) would provide the people of Canberra with a total of 29 elected representatives, or 1 per 12, 931 people. This would still be well below other states and territories (and less than half of what the cube root rule would suggest), but it would be a significant improvement on the current situation. A 25-member Assembly would provide Canberra with a level of representation per-person comparable to that in 1989, when the territory attained self-government.

In my view, a 25-member Assembly is the smallest that ought to be considered. If the Assembly is increased to 25 members, I believe that it should only be done with an indexation formula built in, which would (for example) allow an increase from 25 members to 35 members (seven electorates, each with five members) once the ACT population has increased by a certain amount (eg. 10 per cent) from today’s level. Legislating such an increase would provide a defensible and predictable default for future generations, who could always choose to vary it if they wished.

An increase of the Ministry would also be nice.

What’s Your opinion?


Please login to post your comments
32 Responses to
Andrew Leigh pushes for 5 x 5
1
Proboscus 12:48 pm
28 Feb 13
#

If this model gets the go ahead, then the ACT will perennially have a Labor government because the Greens will win a few more seats in the Legislative Assembly and then they will align themselves with the ALP.

Report this comment

2
johnboy 12:50 pm
28 Feb 13
#

How terrible that the numbers in the assembly should represent the community!

Libs took three of five in Brindabella last year. Your analysis doesn’t bear up to reality.

Report this comment

3
watto23 1:02 pm
28 Feb 13
#

Proboscus said :

If this model gets the go ahead, then the ACT will perennially have a Labor government because the Greens will win a few more seats in the Legislative Assembly and then they will align themselves with the ALP.

More of an issue of quality independents and other parties.
Admittedlly the greens get more support than the extreme conservative parties, but thats the nature of society at the moment.

Zed jumping probably does more harm to local liberals than a 5×5 system would do.

Report this comment

4
LegalNut 1:12 pm
28 Feb 13
#

@Proboscus – The only setup that wouldn’t guarantee Labor government would be to massively gerrymander the electorates. It doesn’t matter if the electorates have 5, 7 or 9 members, the chances are that a Labor/Greens combination will be elected.

Report this comment

5
Alderney 1:15 pm
28 Feb 13
#

I think the good Doctor has been a little muddled with his figures.

He states that a 25 member assembly would equate to a MLA per 12 931 persons, but there are only 256 702 electors on the roll at the last election therefore, a 25 member assembly will return 1 MLA to each 10 268 electors.

Personally, I’d go for 25 single member electorates and let the prospective MsLA have a closer, more personal affinity with the electors.

Report this comment

6
Chop71 1:42 pm
28 Feb 13
#

Andrew,

You have not mentioned the cost of the increase in MLA’s.
Also you have made no reference to the reduction of sitting days.

Report this comment

7
p1 1:49 pm
28 Feb 13
#

Alderney said :

Personally, I’d go for 25 single member electorates and let the prospective MsLA have a closer, more personal affinity with the electors.

Really? I was leaning the other way – 1000 twenty member electorates, and we hold the Assembly meeting in Bruce Stadium at half time during Brumbies matches.

Report this comment

8
Jim Jones 1:57 pm
28 Feb 13
#

johnboy said :

How terrible that the numbers in the assembly should represent the community!

Libs took three of five in Brindabella last year. Your analysis doesn’t bear up to reality.

Reality has a left-wing bias and should be ignored in favour of talkback radio.

Report this comment

9
damien haas 2:03 pm
28 Feb 13
#

I’d like 25 electorates and 25 members. There are occasionally some very lazy MLA’s that coast in on leader quota overflow. Some personal accountability would aid their motivation, resulting in a better outcome for constituents.

Report this comment

10
DrKoresh 2:10 pm
28 Feb 13
#

watto23 said :

Zed jumping probably does more harm to local liberals than a 5×5 system would do.

I dunno, I wouldn’t say that. I might vote for them now that Zed’s out of the picture.

Report this comment

11
johnboy 2:11 pm
28 Feb 13
#

The lazy ones rarely get re-elected when younger and hungrier candidates come forward.

Report this comment

12
c_c™ 2:15 pm
28 Feb 13
#

Proboscus said :

If this model gets the go ahead, then the ACT will perennially have a Labor government because the Greens will win a few more seats in the Legislative Assembly and then they will align themselves with the ALP.

No, not really.

Report this comment

13
Primal 2:23 pm
28 Feb 13
#

25 members, names to be drawn from the ACT electoral roll at random. Like jury duty, but for three years…

Report this comment

14
Ben_Dover 2:27 pm
28 Feb 13
#

It’s bad enough with 17 of the buggers spending our money hand over fist. Think of what carnage 25 could impose on us.

Report this comment

15
Tom Swann 2:43 pm
28 Feb 13
#

Mixed Proportional Representation!!!

As in NZ, Germany

Many small electorates, could be single member or multi member, and then an ‘overflow’ that is allocated to make sure the Assembly represents the Territory wide vote.

Best of both worlds.

Report this comment

1 2 3

Related Articles

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top
Copyright © 2016 Riot ACT Holdings Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.

Search across the site