Skip to content Skip to main navigation

News

Sponsored by Chamberlains - complete legal services for business

Bail support

By johnboy - 28 October 2011 24

Some might think that a major problem for kids going off the rails has been a lack of boundaries.

Despite that Joy Burch has announced still more accommodating arrangements for the youth who have found themselves in the justice system (most often a problem of their own making).

“Remanding young people in custody should be one of the last resorts of any legal system,” Ms Burch said.

“Staff in the service will assist in identifying alternative accommodation for young people if required, and will also be able to assist young people to comply with their bail conditions.”

The after-hours bail service will support young people who are already on bail and those facing fresh charges outside of daytime business hours, where bail is being considered.

“The service will operate each evening and into the early hours of the morning to provide advice to police and young people about options to support young people who are going to be placed on bail or who already are on bail.

“We know that reduced exposure to a custodial environment has a significant impact on reducing recidivism amongst young offenders, and through this program we aim to reduce the likelihood of a young person being placed on remand for a short period until the necessary arrangements can be made to grant them bail.”

What’s Your opinion?


Please login to post your comments
24 Responses to
Bail support
1
JessP 1:06 pm
28 Oct 11
#

Our tax payer dollars at work……

Report this comment

2
Lookout Smithers 4:53 pm
28 Oct 11
#

I emphatically deny that you would be able to back with evidence the idea that the youth end up in court because: ” most often it is a problem of their own making’. However they end up there is not the issue written about here so I know not why you make a side note of speculation regarding youth offending. All judicial know that once you expose a young person to prison, and particularly adult prison, the quality of life and any hope of a turnaround is unlikely. I feel for the judge or magistrate who has no choice but to impose a custodial sentence on a young person, essentially ensuring their fate. And with life long ramifications snowballing in severity with time. Kids need tolerence and understanding even past 18 years. Using them as a source to lay blame is pathetic and cowardice. Picking on kids is the finest example of a decent human. For shame.

Report this comment

3
poetix 5:12 pm
28 Oct 11
#

I can’t help but think of the recent report into children at risk in the ACT. If one of those kids (say the six year old found wandering around a major shopping centre, still wearing nappies, whose mother denied he was her son) ends up committing crimes, could it really be said that it was of his own making? I know that eventually, everyone has to take responsibility for his or her own actions, but surely while they are still legally minors, we can afford to be compassionate and try everything to keep them out of custody?

Perhaps we need to balance that compassion with being harsher to young people from ‘good backgrounds’ who commit crimes? But they’re the ones who’ll get the best lawyers, of course.

Report this comment

4
cranky 6:56 pm
28 Oct 11
#

One would require the wisdom of Job to decide the bail path to be trodden by this young lad and his ilk.

http://the-riotact.com/slow-learning-richardson-teen/57605

Report this comment

5
mareva 6:56 pm
28 Oct 11
#

The OP makes little sense. If a “lack of boundaries” is a “major problem” for kids going “off the rails” (all the punctuation marks indicate that that sentence alone is loaded with meaningless cliches), then what is problematic about a service put in place to reinforce bail conditions, assist compliance, etc.? I am not understanding. You say there is a problem with lack of boundaries. This service is reinforcing boundaries.

“Our tax payer dollars at work…” Again, what exactly is the problem here?

Good to see people like Smithers and Poetix retaining some common sense.

Report this comment

6
Lookout Smithers 7:05 pm
28 Oct 11
#

cranky said :

One would require the wisdom of Job to decide the bail path to be trodden by this young lad and his ilk.

http://the-riotact.com/slow-learning-richardson-teen/57605

Immaturity with a car. Hardly worth a media release.

Report this comment

7
cranky 7:20 pm
28 Oct 11
#

Mr Smithers,

If this youth were to deliberately smash into your car 9 times, (probably causing damage), I think you would be correct in defining it as a little more serious than ‘immaturity with a car’.

An 18 year old acting in this manner is not what society expects.

Please give us your solution to these actions. I’d suggest this stupidity was emminently worthy of a media release.

I’m lucky. My kids have sold their Commodores :)

Report this comment

8
TheDancingDjinn 7:39 pm
28 Oct 11
#

poetix said :

I can’t help but think of the recent report into children at risk in the ACT. If one of those kids (say the six year old found wandering around a major shopping centre, still wearing nappies, whose mother denied he was her son) ends up committing crimes, could it really be said that it was of his own making? I know that eventually, everyone has to take responsibility for his or her own actions, but surely while they are still legally minors, we can afford to be compassionate and try everything to keep them out of custody?

Perhaps we need to balance that compassion with being harsher to young people from ‘good backgrounds’ who commit crimes? But they’re the ones who’ll get the best lawyers, of course.

My family have now adopted that boy – i assure you he will be fine.

Report this comment

9
Jethro 8:23 pm
28 Oct 11
#

cranky said :

One would require the wisdom of Job to decide the bail path to be trodden by this young lad and his ilk.

Isn’t is the wisdom of Solomon? I thought Job was the guy whose life God completely destroyed in order to win a bet with the devil.

Report this comment

10
Tool 8:29 pm
28 Oct 11
#

U know sometimes kids are bad and it doesn’t matter what u try they are going to continue being bad. Once again spending money on something the money could be better spent on, like focusing in child protection, something Joy is so good at.

Report this comment

11
Udonoodle 10:22 pm
28 Oct 11
#

I work in a shopping centre. One of my colleagues was bashed in the interchange by a group of young girls who regularly steal from us and have been banned from the store. Despite being banned they returned the other night to steal from us where they chased us both around the store again in order to assult us. At the time they were both in breach of their bail conditions. They returned the next week to steal from us again (once again in breach of their bail conditions) the police came and arrested them and told us it was actually the second time that day they had arrested them for being in breach of their bail. In the interim they had also bashed another girl in the interchange in order to steal her phone…. remind me again why these people should not be put in remand???
I think we can make excuses all we like for these people. Im well aware their upbringing has alot to do with the decisions they make. but at the end of the day they are going out and making choices that they know are socially unacceptable, and people are being harmed. I should be able to go to work, confident that I wont be threatened or assaulted. And thats just not possible when a magistrate keeps releasing them on conditions that will certainly be breached

Report this comment

12
Henry82 10:56 pm
28 Oct 11
#

Can someone please explain what services “bail support” would provide? Is this a glorified taxi service? or do you call up to confirm bail conditions? “can i drink?” no “okay”

Report this comment

13
wildturkeycanoe 12:31 am
29 Oct 11
#

If a “young person” is in trouble with the law outside of business hours and cannot give his/her parent’s phone number or a way of contacting them, the legal system is operating to the extent of giving them the option of bail and the crime warrants bail or incarceration, why is there a service in place to give this person freedom when they have no way of paying back that cost of freedom. Why is there a service that gives a criminal or would be criminal, free room and board instead of what they deserve? The early hours of the morning are for adults to enjoy, not for young-uns.

Report this comment

14
Lookout Smithers 9:40 am
29 Oct 11
#

cranky said :

Mr Smithers,

If this youth were to deliberately smash into your car 9 times, (probably causing damage), I think you would be correct in defining it as a little more serious than ‘immaturity with a car’.

An 18 year old acting in this manner is not what society expects.

Please give us your solution to these actions. I’d suggest this stupidity was emminently worthy of a media release.

I’m lucky. My kids have sold their Commodores :)

I have no idea what society expects, I didn’t ask them and I am sure no one asked him either. I guess if the media is an international joke, then it might be a story the morons will buy. I am not even sure this is all the facts as I have only the information I received via mass media. Sure its stupid to be fool hardy with a car, but that is like pointing out a fat person and saying they are fat. I have no solution for and I frankly can’t see a need for attention on this matter. If this event is enough to strike fear into someone to the point that it becomes news worthy, then I would hate to see them with real problems. Don’t like teenagers with cars being hooligans? Then find something else for them to do that benefits all parties. You were a parent , its not hard to teach them if you can entertain (trick) them too.

Report this comment

15
fabforty 9:55 am
29 Oct 11
#

wildturkeycanoe said :

If a “young person” is in trouble with the law outside of business hours and cannot give his/her parent’s phone number or a way of contacting them, the legal system is operating to the extent of giving them the option of bail and the crime warrants bail or incarceration, why is there a service in place to give this person freedom when they have no way of paying back that cost of freedom. Why is there a service that gives a criminal or would be criminal, free room and board instead of what they deserve? The early hours of the morning are for adults to enjoy, not for young-uns.

You clearly don’t understand the legal system or this service.

Young people are not given the “option” of bail. It is for the courts and (in the early hours) the police to decide – not the young person. The bail service has been set up for young people who have been granted bail and who do not have any appropriate adults who can care for them or who don’t have anywhere to go. The service finds them a suitable place to stay.

I do not believe that young people should have to be locked up simply because they have become homeless, have useless parents and/or mental health issues and detention is the only option.

What is the “cost of freedom” by the way ?

Surely everyone deserves the right to have their case heard in court before anyone decides “what they deserve’.

Report this comment

Related Articles

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top
Copyright © 2016 Riot ACT Holdings Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.

Search across the site