Skip to content Skip to main navigation

News

Sponsored by Chamberlains - complete legal services for business

Canberra is doomed

By 22Years - 29 July 2014 46

Have the changes brought about by a Federal Liberal Government and an increasingly broke and desperate Labor/Green Alliance, started to sink home to Canberrans yet?

I can remember so many years ago when the same sort of looney left Labor and Green Alliance took over in Tasmania, promising a change of culture (to the left) and increased economic security in the future from a ‘new way’ and renewavble energy and tourism.

And what did Tasmania become after 12 years of that rubbish? The economic basketcase of Australia that was almost destroyed in the GFC and an economy that will take another 10 years to recover – if they ever do.

The certainty of employment that the APS (and ACT PS) has provided to Canberra, will probably remain in the future, but it will be significantly reduced in its ability to shield Canberra anymore, like in did with the GFC.  The future of this town is very much at a nexus – it could go either way over the next 5-10 years.  To believe things will remain the same and that just like after Howard in 1996, this town will recover, is at best otpimistic and more realistically is delusional.

What Canberra needs is exactly what Tasmania failed to do, and that is to foster economic development through business ventures, and not to be totally biased against the benefits of a business sector, and to believe that Government money is a never ending magic pudding.

What’s Your opinion?


Please login to post your comments
46 Responses to
Canberra is doomed
1
davo101 9:45 am
29 Jul 14
#

We’re all doomed; it’s known as the second law of thermodynamics.

As to the more immediate issue in Canberra, I’m not sure that there really is anything to be done about it. Canberra is after all just Australia’s largest company town and if the company is planning to cut production then that’s that.

You need to remember that there is no natural reason why Canberra should be located where it is. It has no hinterland to support, no port, no access to natural resources. If it hadn’t been selected as the site for the seat of Government then it would now be just an interesting old church at a crossroad on the Queanbeyan-Yass road. This, in combination with the high salaries of the company workers, means that there is really not that much business opportunity in Canberra beyond servicing the needs of the company workers and the national institutions based here or providing a home for organisations that need to be close to the seat of government.

Report this comment

2
dungfungus 10:26 am
29 Jul 14
#

The nexus between the ACT Labor Minority government and the University of Canberra will save us.
Millions of dollars is being invested in “profile raising” through sponsorship of just about every sporting cause in the Territory.
It’s just like the good old days of ActewAGL throwing our money at everything.
Sadly, the flagship UC sponsorship failed to bring home the bacon on Saturday night but I am sure lots of students will be signing up for the Diploma in Profile Raising nevertheless.
Regarding government investment in business ventures, this can happen overnight at no cost to the taxpayer. All that needs to happen is for the ACT Government to bury the Canberra cringe and start buying from businesses that are domiciled in Canberra.

Report this comment

3
VYBerlinaV8_is_back 10:37 am
29 Jul 14
#

Doomed, yeah right. There are lots of jobs at the moment in the IT business in Canberra, it’s rarely this busy, in fact. There are some very big government projects coming up over the next couple of years (hundreds of millions each) that private companies are already recruiting for as well.

Report this comment

4
Holden Caulfield 11:11 am
29 Jul 14
#

Right now, Canberra is totally f#*ked. Businesses across a wide variety sectors seem to be struggling. Let’s hope the town comes back to life real soon.

Report this comment

5
Masquara 11:46 am
29 Jul 14
#

But you must be wrong! The new juice startup, “The Fix”, is certain that Canberrans will part with sixty bucks in their hardearned for a daily juice routine at nine bucks a 470ml bottle (not even organic)! They are confident of Canberra’s economic future!

Report this comment

6
pierce 12:00 pm
29 Jul 14
#

I don’t suppose anyone has any facts to back up these whiny partisan claims do they?

No? Just feelpinions.

Report this comment

7
HiddenDragon 12:45 pm
29 Jul 14
#

Doomed might be putting it a little strongly, but to use Ross Garnaut’s language, the salad days are over (and the sound of barking can be heard). All we need to do is stop spending money we haven’t got, trying to be something we aren’t, and things won’t be too bad. The analogy with Tasmania certainly has some relevance.

Report this comment

8
Mark of Sydney 1:40 pm
29 Jul 14
#

Well I bought my first Canberra property on the weekend. Was going to wait for a few more months to see if prices would fall significantly after the election but there is no sign of that and the property is centrally located and ideal from an investment or living perspective.

The OP says ‘To believe things will remain the same and that just like after Howard in 1996, this town will recover, is at best otpimistic and more realistically is delusional.’ Why, what evidence do you have?

I’m no great fan of the current Labor-Green style of territory government but to suggest it’s ‘broke and desperate’ is just silly. Had an acquaintance from Europe here to stay for the past few weeks and she was incredulous when talking about how the people she was working with in Canberra were complaining about how tough things are at the moment. If you think things are bad here, ask someone who knows what it’s like in a major European city, particularly in a public-sector dependent field.

Davo101 says ‘there is no natural reason why Canberra should be located where it is. It has no hinterland to support, no port, no access to natural resources.’ But you can say that about many prosperous cities the world over. Having a port, an agricultural hinterland or access to resources was once a pre-condition for a powerful urban economy. Now it’s about the availability of skills or cheap labour. Canberra has the first if not the second, but it does need to become more entrepreneurial.

The answer probably isn’t in the kind of obsessively over-reaching — there’s not a human problem that can’t be fixed by rolling out a new law or program — approach to government that seems to characterise the current territory government, but nor is it in the populous whining and reactionary response of so many people who post on this site, who seem to think that unless something is produced on an assembly line or in a paddock it’s of no economic or social value.

Report this comment

9
davo101 2:01 pm
29 Jul 14
#

Mark of Sydney said :

But you can say that about many prosperous cities the world over.

Care to name one?

Mark of Sydney said :

Now it’s about the availability of skills or cheap labour.

Exactly, neither of which Canberra has. If you were setting up a new business in Australia (which didn’t need direct access to Canberra) why would you set up here? Sure, there is room for a number of niche industries in the ACT but they are not going to be significant.

HiddenDragon said :

Doomed might be putting it a little strongly, but to use Ross Garnaut’s language, the salad days are over (and the sound of barking can be heard). All we need to do is stop spending money we haven’t got, trying to be something we aren’t, and things won’t be too bad.

+1
Yes, this. I don’t understand what the need is to keep growing. We just need to learn to live within our current situation. The history of States chasing “economic development” is littered with failed projects and wasted money.

Report this comment

10
VYBerlinaV8_is_back 2:23 pm
29 Jul 14
#

davo101 said :

The history of States chasing “economic development” is littered with failed projects and wasted money.

Light rail being a good example.

Report this comment

11
chewy14 2:40 pm
29 Jul 14
#

davo101 said :

We’re all doomed; it’s known as the second law of thermodynamics.

As to the more immediate issue in Canberra, I’m not sure that there really is anything to be done about it. Canberra is after all just Australia’s largest company town and if the company is planning to cut production then that’s that.

You need to remember that there is no natural reason why Canberra should be located where it is. It has no hinterland to support, no port, no access to natural resources. If it hadn’t been selected as the site for the seat of Government then it would now be just an interesting old church at a crossroad on the Queanbeyan-Yass road. This, in combination with the high salaries of the company workers, means that there is really not that much business opportunity in Canberra beyond servicing the needs of the company workers and the national institutions based here or providing a home for organisations that need to be close to the seat of government.

I think you’re significantly underestimating the business opportunities for companies to be close to the seat of government. Sure we won’t be challenging Sydney or Melbourne but there is plenty of scope for growth. Obviously if the proposed federal cuts go through, we are in for a lean couple of years but I don’t buy into this doom and gloom stuff. We’ve been there before, we’ll be there again, the wheel turns.

Report this comment

12
arescarti42 2:42 pm
29 Jul 14
#

The bottom line is that as of June, unemployment in the ACT is still the lowest of any state or territory, and around half the national average.

From where I sit, it’s Australia more broadly that looks stuffed.

Report this comment

13
davo101 2:52 pm
29 Jul 14
#

VYBerlinaV8_is_back said :

davo101 said :

The history of States chasing “economic development” is littered with failed projects and wasted money.

Light rail being a good example.

You might enjoy Utopia, tag line “Nation Building – One white elephant at a time”

Report this comment

14
Mark of Sydney 2:52 pm
29 Jul 14
#

davo101 said :

Mark of Sydney said :

But you can say that about many prosperous cities the world over.

Care to name one?
Well, okay every medium to large city I can think of started out with one of those attributes, but their contemporary prosperity isn’t necessarily linked to any of them. Close to home, Sydney has a port but its economic significance is now probably of lesser importance than its airport, and its agricultural hinterland is relatively poor and constrained. Rome has no access to resources, no operating seaport and while its hinterland is historically important, that’s no longer the case. Ottawa is probably a better model for Canberra with 1800 companies employing approximately 80,000 people according to Wikipedia.

Mark of Sydney said :

Now it’s about the availability of skills or cheap labour.

Exactly, neither of which Canberra has. If you were setting up a new business in Australia (which didn’t need direct access to Canberra) why would you set up here? Sure, there is room for a number of niche industries in the ACT but they are not going to be significant.
You obviously don’t in the IT&T or scientific sectors.

HiddenDragon said :

Doomed might be putting it a little strongly, but to use Ross Garnaut’s language, the salad days are over (and the sound of barking can be heard). All we need to do is stop spending money we haven’t got, trying to be something we aren’t, and things won’t be too bad.

+1
Yes, this. I don’t understand what the need is to keep growing. We just need to learn to live within our current situation. The history of States chasing “economic development” is littered with failed projects and wasted money.

Report this comment

15
rommeldog56 6:08 pm
29 Jul 14
#

It is not the Feds that will “doom” Canberra but rather the doom will come from this ACT Labor/Greens Government that seems unable or incapable of reasonably living within its means. The up to tripling of Annual Rates (if anyone believes that will be the max pa increase for the next 20 years, then they are delusional !), increases in utility and other ACT Gov’t charges charges,repaying infrastructure debt including the Light Rail, will\ price labour based in the ACT too expensive to employ because of the cost of living in the ACT. Additionally, why would business want to set up in the ACT given that cost of living and Government and utility charges. If anything “dooms” Canberra, it will be the inept ACT Govt decisions (past and present), not so much the Feds.

Report this comment

1 2 3 4

Related Articles

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top
Copyright © 2016 Riot ACT Holdings Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.

Search across the site