Skip to content Skip to main navigation

Community

Sponsored by Ray White Tuggeranong - fresh, fun & professional approach to real estate

Dodgy Childcare centers in Canberra.

By Saria - 26 January 2012 51

I have recently withdrawn my child from a certain childcare center in Canberra. I have since discovered that this childcare center has featured in a past article of the Canberra Times in relation to its negligent standards and abusive staff.

I have made a formal complaint with the relevant government bodies and today received a letter that basically said “There is nothing we can do, we are working together with management to improve the center.”)

This center was a very dirty, very badly managed place, where there was NO security (The front door to the center was a standard house screen door.)

Worst of all, there was only 2 childrens toilets in the whole place (with 50 odd kids) and NO development program to speak of. I often asked what my child had done/learnt each day and was answered with an uninterested grunt.

I have since met with several past childcare workers of the center, as well as other disgruntled parents. We all agree that this center is the worst we have ever seen.

So how exactly does the government compliance system work in the A.C.T? How can such places exist, even after many complaints have been made?

Tags

What’s Your opinion?


Please login to post your comments
51 Responses to
Dodgy Childcare centers in Canberra.
1
johnboy 12:55 pm
26 Jan 12
#

I’ve said before and I’ll say it again, in 2012 childcare should be government provided just like primary school.

Allowing childcare operators to become a rentier class in the Australian economy was one of John Howard’s greatest failings but Labor doesn’t appear to be interested in fixing it either.

Private childcare offering a superior service for the extra money would of course be fine, just like private education.

Report this comment

2
Jethro 2:04 pm
26 Jan 12
#

I agree to a certain extent JB, as I have serious issues with the standards in place at the moment. Poor quality was one of the reasons Mrs Jethro and I opted against putting our little ones in childcare.

But once they become government provided how are they funded, how do we assess who has priority entry, what motivates parents to stay at home with their kids?

I often think that employer provided day-care, in which parents can salary sacrifice to pay for the day-care and it can operate either on-site or in co-operation with other nearby businesses might be an extra option. This wouldn’t take away from the private childcare currently available.

Report this comment

3
johnboy 2:16 pm
26 Jan 12
#

Same as primary school.

No priority, guaranteed places within catchment areas.

Not just government funded, government operated.

Report this comment

4
Jethro 2:29 pm
26 Jan 12
#

johnboy said :

Same as primary school.

No priority, guaranteed places within catchment areas.

Not just government funded, government operated.

So why would anyone choose to stay at home? There’s a fair bit of research which shows that children kept at home until at least age 3 have better outcomes than those who are put into care. A fully government funded system of childcare puts a pretty big incentive in place for people to choose a model of childcare that may not be the best for kids.

Report this comment

5
sepi 2:58 pm
26 Jan 12
#

I really want to know which centre this is.

We are lucky to have our kids at a fantastic centre, but this only happened because we got our eldest in there years ago when waiting lists were not quite as ridiculous.

Anyway – I totally agree that govt should organise and run childcare centres. They want parents in the workforce, they need to make it a bit easier. I also think that every new office block should have to be built with an onsite childcare as part of it. Co-location is so much better for everyone, and reduces travel time.

I really hate the current funding model where every single ‘working family’ that uses childcare has to register for several govt benefits in order to access childcare in order to work. This is really leading people to be constantly expecting the govt to hand out more and more money to families. It breeding a wierd entitlement mentality. It would be so much better if they just gave the money straight to the centres, and families on average-good wages had nothing to do with centrelink.

I really doubt that govt run childcare would encourage hordes of stay at home mums back to work. A lot of people choose to stay home cos they believe in the benefits, or want to. Anyway – they could still charge for childcare, but just a realistic amount, instead of charging 300 bucks a day (3 kids) and making us go to centrelink to get some back. This stupid income based system also means that there is a huge disincentive to get a better job or work more hours in the latter end of the tax year, as you suddenly owe money to centrelink due to childcare rebates.

There are other govt incentives to allow people to stay home anyway – such as two years of maternity leave (unpaid, but you get your job back at the end), so people can always choose to stay home if they wish.

The only concern I would have about govt run childcare with zones is the lack of choice in wanting to use a different centre, or a better one, or one closer to work or whatever.

But the system at the moment is a disaster. I would say the govt don’t want to close this bad centre as it will leave 50 families unable to go to work suddenly – then what? There is nowhere else to send these kids, all childcares are full to overflowing.

I am happy with our childcare, and there is research to show that good quality childcare is equally as good for childhood outcomes as staying at home. Each to their own – but the whole payment/rebate/waiting list nightmare needs to be sorted out.

Report this comment

6
poetix 3:08 pm
26 Jan 12
#

Leaving any child in child-care is hard enough without the additional worry of it being sub-standard. We were lucky enough to find an excellent community run centre that accepted children on a very part-time basis, but the whole process of finding a centre is so difficult.

It seems to have become more difficult, if anything.

Report this comment

7
dtc 3:53 pm
26 Jan 12
#

I dont understand why you can salary sacrifice only if your employer offers a child care centre on site. Why not just allow salary sacrifice and reduce CCB? And if that doesnt actually create any savings, at least it gets rid of the advantage that some people get while working for big companies (eg someone working at DFAT or Treasury or Finance gets to salary sacrifice for childcare and also gets CCB; someone working at DIAC or DEEWR gets CCB only)

Report this comment

8
isaidno 4:41 pm
26 Jan 12
#

Why are waiting lists so long? It seems to indicate that there just aren’t enough centres. But why is this? Does the government just not issue enough licenses? Or are there not enough people/companies applying for licenses to run child care centres?

Report this comment

9
Deref 5:16 pm
26 Jan 12
#

johnboy said :

I’ve said before and I’ll say it again, in 2012 childcare should be government provided just like primary school.

Allowing childcare operators to become a rentier class in the Australian economy was one of John Howard’s greatest failings but Labor doesn’t appear to be interested in fixing it either.

Private childcare offering a superior service for the extra money would of course be fine, just like private education.

+1

Well said, Johnboy.

Report this comment

10
Dilandach 6:07 pm
26 Jan 12
#

Mrs Dil has worked at a couple of child care centres in canberra (and in another city). While to some the centre might appear to be a place of harmony and friendship, nothing could be further from the truth. Typical in female dominated workplaces, they attack each other relentlessly mainly in forming little niches and bitching out those not included. Its not just limited to one centre, its happened in every single one that Mrs Dil has worked in.

I’ve seen and heard all sorts of things.

A kid walking out of the centre unaccompanied to go play in a nearby park by himself.
A staff member shoving a kid against a wall.
Feeding kids food that they can’t have, repeatedly.
Stealing amongst staff members.
A staff members loser ex-husband doing his alpha male thing in the centre when kids were around.
The very few male staff members I’ve seen treated like they’re kiddy fiddlers, both from staff and parents.

All female workplaces are vicious poisonous places.

Report this comment

11
stirred408 6:36 pm
26 Jan 12
#

It would be great if someone could post the article from the Canberra Times that was referred to. I often wonder if appropriate police checks etc.. are being done. Has anyone had a really bad or worrying experience in a childcare centre in the ACT? If you don’t want to name them, then maybe the suburb???

Report this comment

12
Jurls 7:27 pm
26 Jan 12
#

I too would like to know which childcare centre this is.

As I’m looking at returning to work this year and am about to embark on a hunt for a centre for my toddlers, reading this fills me with dismay and now I’m starting to worry about it :/

Report this comment

13
Tarala 7:30 pm
26 Jan 12
#

stirred408 said :

It would be great if someone could post the article from the Canberra Times that was referred to. I often wonder if appropriate police checks etc.. are being done. Has anyone had a really bad or worrying experience in a childcare centre in the ACT? If you don’t want to name them, then maybe the suburb???

I resigned from my job that was situated in Red Hill. It was a privately run center and was a very bad and sad place to work. It was not professionally cleaned once in the 7 months that I worked there.

I once found a child out in the yard, by herself, playing around in the shed. Her room leader had not realised she was missing. There were inadequate toilet facilities for the kids who were learning or going to the toilet on their own. Children with allergies were given the foods they were allergic to. The police once turned up to question a staff member on assault charges…. It was a horrible place to work.

Just google the words “toxic” and “childcare” on the Canberra times website. The place is a whole lot worse than the article suggests.

Report this comment

14
dtc 7:33 pm
26 Jan 12
#

isaidno said :

Why are waiting lists so long? It seems to indicate that there just aren’t enough centres. But why is this? Does the government just not issue enough licenses? Or are there not enough people/companies applying for licenses to run child care centres?

Its not that profitable (see ABC learning) and its very hard to find staff (partly because pay is so low, which is linked to profitablility)

Also, who wants to look after kids? Its fun for an hour or so

Report this comment

15
sankee 8:18 pm
26 Jan 12
#

poetix said :

Leaving any child in child-care is hard enough without the additional worry of it being sub-standard. We were lucky enough to find an excellent community run centre that accepted children on a very part-time basis, but the whole process of finding a centre is so difficult.

.

I recently posted on the RiotACT looking for a part time centre … so this is quite relevant! Are you referring to childcare through Communities at Work? Would be great to hear your comments on the centre you use :)

I would also be interested to know about the centre that is mentioned in this post … perhaps a suburb so I know to avoid that particular one. I am not keen on childcare after reading all of the comments – eek!

Report this comment

1 2 3 4

Related Articles

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top
Copyright © 2016 Riot ACT Holdings Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.

Search across the site