Skip to content Skip to main navigation

Firelighter and stalker Jeremy Dash-Greentree on a suspended sentence

By johnboy - 4 February 2013 30

Justice Penfold has made known her thoughts on Jeremy Dash-Greentree who despite terrifying crimes is having allowances made for his mental health:

The charges arise from two quite separate incidents. The first incident took place in June 2006, when Mr Dash-Greentree went to a flat in Griffith to see a man named Brett whom he had met through an acquaintance, Tim. Finding that Brett was not at home, Mr Dash-Greentree went away but returned several hours later. Brett was still not home, so Mr Dash?Greentree went to Manuka and obtained a jerry can containing petrol. He took the jerry can back to Brett’s flat and knocked again. When there was again no answer, he emptied the jerry can under the door of the flat and lit the petrol with a cigarette lighter. The petrol caught fire and Mr Dash?Greentree ran away. Smoke detectors were activated, the fire brigade arrived and the fire was put out, having caused $2,675 worth of damage to the door, security screen, walls and carpet of the flat.

The second incident occurred over several months in 2009. The complainant, who owned a florist’s shop in Belconnen, began receiving communications from Mr Dash-Greentree, whom she had never met and did not know of. A letter sent to the complainant in May expressed Mr Dash-Greentree’s wish to have a future with her, in which she would move to Western Australia to live with him and they would have children together. The sending of this letter is the basis for the second scheduled offence.

Between May and October 2009, Mr Dash-Greentree made at least 29 phone calls to the complainant’s shop. Some of the calls were threatening, either to the complainant or to her staff or her boyfriend. In one of them, Mr Dash-Greentree passed on detailed information about the complainant’s activities in the preceding days, and mentioned the names of her children, her car registration number and the score in her daughter’s soccer match. In mid-October, Mr Dash-Greentree rang the complainant at the florist shop and told her he was coming to Canberra. Several days later, the complainant was contacted by a person who then put Mr Dash-Greentree on the line to speak to the complainant. He told the complainant that he was in the psychiatric ward at The Canberra Hospital and asked her to visit him there, saying that if she did not, he would escape and find her. She said that she would visit. During the rest of that day Mr Dash-Greentree made many further phone calls to the complainant. The making of the phone calls constitutes the offence of using a carriage service to harass. The sending of the letter and the phone calls together constitute the first scheduled offence of stalking.

Despite significant form in ignoring bail conditions it is hoped he will do as he’s told this time.

What this order basically means, Mr Dash-Greentree, is that for the next eight months you must not commit any more offences, and you must do as you are told by your Corrections supervisor or your Mental Health supervisor, especially in relation to where you live and how your mental disorder is to be treated. If you do not do that, for instance if you try to leave town or if you commit another offence, I might have to send you back to prison to finish the rest of your sentence, which is nearly four more months.

What’s Your opinion?


Please login to post your comments
30 Responses to
Firelighter and stalker Jeremy Dash-Greentree on a suspended sentence
1
pezza 6:10 pm
04 Feb 13
#

Sure, he might try to burn down my house or terrorise my girlfriend but don’t worry – his human rights are being respected. You just can’t put a price on the peace of mind I get from knowing that.

Report this comment

2
LSWCHP 7:36 pm
04 Feb 13
#

Jewemy Dash-Gweentwee eh? Goodness gwacious me, what a fancy moniker.

Still, despite that, it sounds like he needs shooting.

Report this comment

3
pptvb 7:37 pm
04 Feb 13
#

Is Penfold the new Higgins?
Another swing & a miss…

Report this comment

4
IrishPete 8:10 pm
04 Feb 13
#

This is old news. It was extensively reported on in the Canberra Times last month. See http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/stalker-avoids-jail-time-20130109-2ch4z.html and http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/mental-health-unit-too-small-too-late-20130113-2cnuy.html

Shame on those of you who advocate executing the mentally ill.

He is hopefully being held in a psychiatric unit, probably indefinitely.

IP

Report this comment

5
Comic_and_Gamer_Nerd 8:51 pm
04 Feb 13
#

IrishPete said :

This is old news. It was extensively reported on in the Canberra Times last month. See http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/stalker-avoids-jail-time-20130109-2ch4z.html and http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/mental-health-unit-too-small-too-late-20130113-2cnuy.html

Shame on those of you who advocate executing the mentally ill.

He is hopefully being held in a psychiatric unit, probably indefinitely.

IP

Shame on you for defending someone who by the sounds of it has made a woman’s life a living hell.

Being mentally ill does not mean its ok to terrorise somebody.

Report this comment

6
LSWCHP 9:10 pm
04 Feb 13
#

IrishPete said :

This is old news. It was extensively reported on in the Canberra Times last month. See http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/stalker-avoids-jail-time-20130109-2ch4z.html and http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/mental-health-unit-too-small-too-late-20130113-2cnuy.html

Shame on those of you who advocate executing the mentally ill.

He is hopefully being held in a psychiatric unit, probably indefinitely.

IP

Sorry IP, but I’m not feeling any shame right now. Maybe I should, but I just can’t find it in me. This bloke made a deliberate and concerted effort to set fire to someone’s flat with a tin of petrol. By what seems like a miracle the fire was extinguished quickly, but it might’ve been otherwise, and it might’ve been very bad indeed for the owner of the flat and everybody else in the block.

In my book, anybody who’s organised enough to get around town, visit someone’s flat a couple of times, go away to purchase petrol and a lighter and go back and set their house on fire has enough of their wits about them to also know what they’re doing is wrong.

Yes, there are undoubtedly mentally ill people out there committing crimes, but it also appears to me that mental illness is being used as an excuse by people (like this individual) who are simply bad and dangerous, and who should be removed from society.

Given that execution by firing squad isn’t an option in Australia, and given his evident prediliction for setting houses on fire, stalking, harassing strangers and threatening people, how do you think the owner of the flower shop might be feeling about her safety? How do you think she might be feeling about her daughter’s safety, knowing that this person has been to her daughter’s soccer matches?

This is not good.

Report this comment

7
Thumper 9:18 pm
04 Feb 13
#

Comic_and_Gamer_Nerd said :

IrishPete said :

This is old news. It was extensively reported on in the Canberra Times last month. See http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/stalker-avoids-jail-time-20130109-2ch4z.html and http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/mental-health-unit-too-small-too-late-20130113-2cnuy.html

Shame on those of you who advocate executing the mentally ill.

He is hopefully being held in a psychiatric unit, probably indefinitely.

IP

Shame on you for defending someone who by the sounds of it has made a woman’s life a living hell.

Being mentally ill does not mean its ok to terrorise somebody.

IP is correct. He is not defending him.

He should be put away in a mental institution forever, or at least until he is no longer a threat to society.

Who are we to take a life? It makes us no better than those who commit such henious crimes.

Report this comment

8
obamabinladen 9:20 pm
04 Feb 13
#

Mentally ill people like this guy need to be killed!!! I’d bet my left testicle he ends up committing a violent crime just hope im wrong.

Report this comment

9
ScienceRules 9:31 pm
04 Feb 13
#

Comic_and_Gamer_Nerd said :

IrishPete said :

This is old news. It was extensively reported on in the Canberra Times last month. See http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/stalker-avoids-jail-time-20130109-2ch4z.html and http://www.canberratimes.com.au/act-news/mental-health-unit-too-small-too-late-20130113-2cnuy.html

Shame on those of you who advocate executing the mentally ill.

He is hopefully being held in a psychiatric unit, probably indefinitely.

IP

Shame on you for defending someone who by the sounds of it has made a woman’s life a living hell.

Being mentally ill does not mean its ok to terrorise somebody.

It’s difficult to see how this “sentence” is either in his interest or that of the community. Still, I guess we don’t have all the details.

No, being mentally ill doesn’t mean it’s ok to terrorise someone, but for those of us who aren’t mentally ill it’s definately wrong to suggest their execution.

Report this comment

10
Comic_and_Gamer_Nerd 9:46 pm
04 Feb 13
#

I apologise. I’m not going to say kill anybody. He defo needs to be locked up though.

I did jump the gun, I am just sick of seeing people try to defend the mentally ill of serious crimes.

Report this comment

11
Jethro 10:13 pm
04 Feb 13
#

This guy clearly has a mental illness. Those who bay for blood should at least consider that some people simply do not have the mental faculties to make the rational and moral decisions that most of us do. I always find that the people who call for the harshest of penalties no matter the circumstances seem to be people who themselves demonstrate a slightly unhinged version of reality. Why hate on someone who is clearly ill?

That being said, this guy clearly shouldn’t be released into society. He needs to be secured in a mental health institution.

Report this comment

12
obamabinladen 11:00 pm
04 Feb 13
#

There are plenty of mentally ill people who DONT commit violent crimes or terrorise people and with the right meds can live a decent life. This guy however is a ticking time bomb and needs to be defused.

The way to judge someone is by their actions. Commit violent crimes and I think you deserve to die. If a vicious dog hurts a human we kill it. Can somebody tell me why humans who commit violent crimes don’t deserve the same treatment?

Report this comment

13
bundah 11:28 pm
04 Feb 13
#

Apparently one in five prisoners have a serious mental illness and one has to wonder how many of those are released back into the community prematurely given recidivism rates are similar to those who are not mentally ill.

It’s a bloody minefield that society cannot effectively address due to a myriad of reasons.

Report this comment

14
Jethro 6:33 am
05 Feb 13
#

obamabinladen said :

There are plenty of mentally ill people who DONT commit violent crimes or terrorise people and with the right meds can live a decent life. This guy however is a ticking time bomb and needs to be defused.

The way to judge someone is by their actions. Commit violent crimes and I think you deserve to die. If a vicious dog hurts a human we kill it. Can somebody tell me why humans who commit violent crimes don’t deserve the same treatment?

Because we are a civilised people and killing people is wrong?

Report this comment

15
IrishPete 8:21 am
05 Feb 13
#

Those criticising Mr D-G obviously have absolutely no knowledge of serious mental illnesses like Schizophrenia and Bipolar. So they should just shut up.

Every person’s mental illness is different, and that some don’t commit violent ctimes like arson and stalking is fortunate for them and for us, but says nothing about the person whose delusions and hallucinations cause them to commit offences.

Some are so unfortunate that their illness does not respond to medication.

If you read the edited transcript of proceeedings, it’s hard not to come to the conclusion that Mr Dash-Greentree, and his victim(s) have been failed by the mental health and criminal justice systems in three states/territories. Mr D-G may not be capable of feeling guilty about what he has done, but the authorities in ACT, Victoria and WA are capable of feeling guilty, and they should be feeling guilty, big time. They should also be apologising to his victim. The judgement even notes that he phoned the victim from Canberra Hospital’s psychiatric unit.

The ACT Supreme Court, in its infinite wisdom, has contributed to this lack of understanding by convicting and sentencing Mr D-G, instead of finding him not guilty by reason of his mental illness. His defence team has to take some responsibility for that, and I hope they can sleep soundly at night. Would anyone like to guess who his solicitor was?

IP

Report this comment

Related Articles

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top
Copyright © 2016 Riot ACT Holdings Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.

Search across the site