Skip to content Skip to main navigation

News

Chamberlains - complete legal services for business

Joel Monaghan says goodbye

By johnboy - 10 November 2010 80

[First filed: Nov 9, 2010 @ 15:40]

Joel Monaghan mopo

Courtesy of ABC Radio here is the sound of Joel Monaghan breaking down while announcing his resignation, and that of Raiders’ Boss Don Furner blaming those who brought the photo to light while washing his hands of finding those other players who were in the room taking photos.

Thanks to Mathman for providing the mopo.

Bear in mind that almost every rugby league reporter you hear or see opining on this had the photo a week in advance but decided you didn’t need to know this is, for the men they present to you as heroes and role models, a good time.

What’s Your opinion?


Please login to post your comments
80 Responses to
Joel Monaghan says goodbye
1
clp 3:57 pm
09 Nov 10
#

Well done thats a genuine apology and really no other outcome would be possible. Not that I think his misdeamour is anywhere near as bad as some other NRL players drunken exploits especially in regards to behaviour towards women. But you can’t expect the Raiders to play with dog rooter taunts.

However I think whilst this player has behaved responsibly I would like to see the powers that be actually act themselves in a positive way. In short that means that contracted players are agree to not consume any alcohol. It seems an outrageous thing to ask of young men in Australia but if you are a paid professional you can have stringent criteria put into your contract. Enforcement is another issue but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t put this in contracts in the first place.

Report this comment

2
clp 3:58 pm
09 Nov 10
#

Also why is it always Labradors who get involved in these sort of pranks?

Report this comment

3
colourful sydney rac 4:03 pm
09 Nov 10
#

Don Furner is a disgrace.

Whilst he committed a disgusting act, Monaghan broke no law. Other players did. They electronically recorded the act and then used a carriage service to distribute it. These are both criminal acts.

Covering this up, as Furner seems happy to do is reprehensible.

Report this comment

4
johnboy 4:07 pm
09 Nov 10
#

clp said :

Well done thats a genuine apology and really no other outcome would be possible. Not that I think his misdeamour is anywhere near as bad as some other NRL players drunken exploits especially in regards to behaviour towards women. But you can’t expect the Raiders to play with dog rooter taunts.

However I think whilst this player has behaved responsibly I would like to see the powers that be actually act themselves in a positive way. In short that means that contracted players are agree to not consume any alcohol. It seems an outrageous thing to ask of young men in Australia but if you are a paid professional you can have stringent criteria put into your contract. Enforcement is another issue but that doesn’t mean you shouldn’t put this in contracts in the first place.

And yet most people who drink too much do nothing worse than make regrettable phone calls to their exes.

Report this comment

5
I-filed 4:10 pm
09 Nov 10
#

Are we all pleased with ourselves? I’m not. It’s a disgrace that footy players who endanger other people’s lives don’t get the sack, and this poor idiot gets the sack. Frankly, a moment’s consideration before on-circulating the image would have been a good thing, in hindsight.

Report this comment

6
Mysteryman 4:13 pm
09 Nov 10
#

colourful sydney racing identity said :

Don Furner is a disgrace.

Whilst he committed a disgusting act, Monaghan broke no law. Other players did. They electronically recorded the act and then used a carriage service to distribute it. These are both criminal acts…

Ahh… how do you figure? If what Monaghan did wasn’t illegal, how is recording it and distribute it illegal?

Report this comment

7
colourful sydney rac 4:15 pm
09 Nov 10
#

I-filed said :

Are we all pleased with ourselves? I’m not. It’s a disgrace that footy players who endanger other people’s lives don’t get the sack, and this poor idiot gets the sack. Frankly, a moment’s consideration before on-circulating the image would have been a good thing, in hindsight.

I will be pleased when we see some consistency in penalties that are handed down to players – see my post above.

Report this comment

8
clp 4:16 pm
09 Nov 10
#

I know but if you’re being paid vast sums of money to play a game then you can be expected to follow a strict regimen of diet and exercise I don’t see abstaining from alcohol as any more rigorous than having to go to training several nights a week.

Mind you they would also have to get rid of alcohol sponsorship as well.

Report this comment

9
Skidbladnir 4:18 pm
09 Nov 10
#

Mysteryman said :

If what Monaghan did wasn’t illegal, how is recording it and distribute it illegal?

Same as 16 year olds can have sex, but filming it & distributing the result is not.

Report this comment

10
Woody Mann-Caruso 4:20 pm
09 Nov 10
#

Frankly, a moment%u2019s consideration before on-circulating the image would have been a good thing, in hindsight.

Horse, gate, bolted.

Report this comment

11
PBO 4:20 pm
09 Nov 10
#

Hope that you can move on Joel, good luck in the UK. P.s. the dog stays here.

Report this comment

12
clp 4:20 pm
09 Nov 10
#

Canberra Milk just doesn’t want to be the drink of choice for dog rooters.

The only logical option for him was to resign – I personally think the actual incident itself doesn’t warrant losing your job over – but unfortunately I think thats what had to happen in this case.

Why am I even commenting – I don’t care I have never watched a NRL game in my life and the only time I ever heard another Raiders player give a press conference (Ok so he wasn’t playing at the time) was the Mal Meninga launch of political career one.

Report this comment

13
colourful sydney rac 4:21 pm
09 Nov 10
#

Skidbladnir said :

Mysteryman said :

If what Monaghan did wasn’t illegal, how is recording it and distribute it illegal?

Same as 16 year olds can have sex, but filming it & distributing the result is not.

spot on.

Report this comment

14
BerraBoy68 4:34 pm
09 Nov 10
#

In his comments, Mr Furner appears to typify pretty much everything that’s wrong with NRL (a player can do no wrong unless it’s reported in the media, and if it is reported in the media it’s someone else’s fault). If this is the attitude of their management then it’s no wonder the culture of the players won’t/can’t change.

If I was an NRL fan or official(I’m not but I used to buy a fair bit of Raiders merchandise for family overseas until this happened)I’d be particularly aggrieved by one NRL fans comments in the CT today.

This person says that nothing immoral happened between Monaghan and the dog as the dog has no concept of what was happening and, therefore, there was no victim. Which also implies that necrophilia is OK as long as one of the people involved is actually dead.

The writer of the letter goes on to say that he’s “had enough of philosophically ignorant NRL officials and sponsors who don’t understand that most fans don’t care about how players behave off the field… we just want to see a good footy”.

I wonder how Mr Remington of Gordon would feel if one of his family were sexually accosted in the early hours by an NRL player or if a player took a crap in his lounge room?! How do other NRL fans feel having this well adjusted person speak on their behalf?

Report this comment

15
Reprobate 4:35 pm
09 Nov 10
#

clp said :

Canberra Milk just doesn’t want to be the drink of choice for dog rooters.

Yes, a milk moustache isn’t a good look for Joel Monaghan.

Report this comment

1 2 3 6

Related Articles

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top
Copyright © 2016 Riot ACT Holdings Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.

Search across the site