26 November 2024

No strategy: ACT Auditor-General slams Safer Families Levy

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
25
Marisa Paterson MLA

New Minister for the Prevention of Family and Domestic Violence, Dr Marisa Paterson, says almost all levy funds now go to frontline services. Photo: Thomas Lucraft.

The Safer Families Levy was introduced to help pay for initiatives to tackle domestic and family violence in the ACT, but after eight years and $46 million collected, a damning audit report has found it to be a scheme without a plan or way to measure its effectiveness.

The $50 levy is paid by ACT households through their rates.

ACT Auditor-General Michael Harris said the audit found that planning and development of domestic and family violence initiatives had been undermined by the lack of a Territory-specific strategy for responding to domestic and family violence and an up-to-date understanding of the ACT’s needs.

There has also been poor communication with the community and other stakeholders regarding how domestic and family violence initiatives are designed to respond to community needs, how they are funded and what their intended benefits are.

READ ALSO ANU bioethicist questions doctors’ right to conscientiously object to performing abortions

Prevention and recovery services remained underfunded. Although total levy funding had increased, these services had not been prioritised and their funding proportion had not significantly changed since 2016-17.

The audit also found that the Domestic, Family and Sexual Violence Office (DFSVO) within the Community Services Directorate had not developed a performance monitoring strategy or evaluation framework to measure the outcomes and impacts of domestic and family violence initiatives the levy had funded.

It did not effectively use existing monitoring and reporting arrangements to assess the performance of Safer Families initiatives.

“Public reporting of the Safer Families Levy is not transparent or effective in informing the community how the levy is being used or the performance of domestic and family violence initiatives, both individually and as a whole, in addressing domestic and family violence across the Territory,” Mr Harris said.

YWCA Canberra CEO Frances Crimmins

YWCA Canberra CEO Frances Crimmins said the Safer Family Levy needed to be urgently reformed. Photo: YWCA Canberra.

YWCA Canberra, which operates a Domestic Violence Support Service, said the organisation had been raising concerns about the operation of the Safer Families Levy for years as services struggled to keep up with demand.

CEO Frances Crimmins said the troubling report confirmed a lack of transparency and accountability in the allocation of funds from the levy.

“It’s no surprise that in anticipation of the findings of the Auditor-General, the ACT Government finally allocated the bulk of the levy towards frontline services in the 2024-2025 Budget,” she said.

“It took eight years of the sector pleading with their hands out for more support before a reality check by the Auditor-General delivered funding to these desperately under-resourced services.”

YWCA Canberra faced critical challenges, including suspending ACT Policing referrals to its Domestic Violence Support Service due to insufficient staffing.

Funding for two specialist workers was only secured in July 2023 despite years of escalating demand.

Ms Crimmins said urgent reforms were essential so every dollar went to directly supporting survivors and preventing domestic, family and sexual violence in the community.

The report made four recommendations for greater transparency, better communication, and proper monitoring and evaluation.

READ ALSO Gender pay gap narrowing, but more to be done

Minister for Women and Minister for the Prevention of Family and Domestic Violence Dr Marisa Paterson said the government was committed to reforming the levy, with all funds now almost entirely committed to frontline services, delivered to victim-survivors and their families by either community sector services or government.

Dr Paterson said the government would develop a comprehensive, evidence-based ACT Domestic, Family and Sexual Violence Strategy.

It would also address service gaps, including more money for men’s behaviour change programs and expanding innovative service responses, including for children and young people.

The recommendations of reports, including one published 15 years ago, would be implemented:

  • The Listen. Take Action to Prevent, Believe and Heal report on responses to sexual violence.
  • The Sexual Assault (Police) Review, aimed at improving justice responses to sexual violence for victim-survivors.
  • The 2009 We Don’t Shoot Our Wounded report, addressing the disproportionate rates of gendered violence perpetrated against Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women.

Dr Paterson also announced the ACT Women’s Safety Grant Program, which provides up to $20,000 for organisations supporting projects that work towards the goals of the National Plan to End Violence against Women and Children 2022-2032.

Join the conversation

25
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
Veronica Wensing9:50 pm 26 Nov 24

Back in 2011 when Yvette was the Minister for Women I was instrumental in developing the first ever ACT Strategy to Prevent Violence Against Women and their Children and I was chastised for wanting even 20k for interpreter services for DVCS. Then they came up with the levy but I was disappointed to learn it mainly funded the governmental office rather than frontline services. At least now with a new Minister there’s chance for improvement.

Where have the Canberra Liberals been since the Safer Families Levy was introduced just prior to the 2016 election holding the government to account?

Advocates have been demanding action for years but have been ignored by the government and particularly Yvette Berry the minister responsible. When will this minister ever be held to account for her many blunders?

Yvette Berry was not mentioned in this article but was the Minister for Women at the time the Safer Families Levy was introduced. She has been the Prevention of Domestic and Family Violence minister since that time. Ms Berry was in the news last year defending the program and the government spending public money from a tax levy from every household in the ACT to fund it, training public servants to tackle domestic and family violence. Ms Berry is currently unavailable thankful that she can fob media off to a new minister and directing questions to the government’s budget outlook papers. Budget funding that has only just become available thanks to a damning auditor report and 8 years of demands for more support from the sector. There are also outstanding questions on where the many millions of dollars of funding has ended up.

Like me people should be outraged and demanding answers. The findings of the Auditor-General are not surprising – services struggling to keep up with demand, lack of transparency and accountability in the allocation of funds, no performance monitoring strategy or evaluation framework to measure the outcomes and impacts of domestic and family violence initiatives, no effective use of existing monitoring and reporting arrangements to assess the performance of the plan and the list goes on.

Where is the accountability from this government and Ms Berry for such an outrageously scandalous and poorly implemented plan?

People should be outraged.

Don’t bring the Canberra Liberals into this. Not their circus. Canberrans keep voting for being stolen from.

The people hold the government to account not the opposition.
The people vote for individuals.
The AG raises concerns and says that the only solution is to make things public and get the people to vote.
The people ignore everything, vote the same party in and then complain, however justify their lack of decision by the other party would be worse.

I finally learn, and it is not surprising, that the Canberra Liberals and their supporters after two decades in opposition and their votes heading south, believe that winning government can only be achieved by default and by sitting on the sidelines doing nothing.

The Canberra Liberals, too lazy to do the hard yards of an effective opposition, unwilling and intellectually bereft to do what is necessary to gain the public’s confidence and trust through intellectual capacity, ideas and holding the government to account for any wrongdoings.

Not by sitting on the sidelines, sniping and constantly whingeing that it is their turn.

Another cash grab from the Barr government.

It should never have been a levy. We pay enough rates for this to come from the Barr’s slush fund.

A fine example of ideology triumphing (only superficially, of course) over reality; where it blows people’s socks off in terms of how it all sound in theory, but achieves absolutely nothing in the end – unless moving backwards, while thinking your moving forwards, was the goal.

If you don’t have a strong cultural basis to work from – which we don’t; all we have is a literal anti-culture – then any measures taken to fix the problems caused by the anti-culture will be like p-ing in the wind.

One example of how the navel-gazers need to come down off the clouds can be seen in the following line of this article: “It would also address service gaps, including more money for men’s behaviour change.”

As even blind Freddy can see, it’s not just men who are imperfect; and just the second others are able to catch up with this fellow, we’ll have made a small move towards improvement – for once.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.