29 April 2011

ADFA cadets arrested over skype sex scandal

| johnboy
Join the conversation
25

Two men have been arrested early this morning by ACT Policing Criminal Investigations Detectives for the Australian Defence Force Academy (ADFA) incident in March.

The two men, aged 19 and 18, were arrested at ADFA about 7am and will face the ACT Magistrates Court later today.

Police will allege that on Tuesday, March 29, a female cadet was recorded without her consent engaging in consensual sexual intercourse.

The 19-year-old man has been charged with Use a Carriage Service to Cause Offence and Act of Indecency. The 18-year-old man has been charged with Use a Carriage Service to Cause Offence.

[Courtesy ACT Policing]

UPDATE: The SMH has named the pair as Daniel McDonald, 19 and Dylan de Blaquiere, 18.

Join the conversation

25
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Lookout Smithers said :

toriness said :

Faces.

I found it hilarious (not) to read in above linked article:

The lawyer for one of the men immediately moved to have the case heard in a closed court because of “national security concerns”.

Seriously? You’re a misogynist idiot 18/19 year old and you (via your lawyer) think your identity constitutes a national security concern? Come now tell the truth, you are bloody embarrassed at being revealed for being the pig that you are. Congratulations on your arrest and I hope you look forward to a lifetime of these articles showing up any time anyone googles your name.

Naming and shaming fan I take it? Too bad if the case is thrown out then. Wont you look like a prized turkey.

nah, pretty sure they are the ones which will still look like the tools whether the criminal charges stick or not 🙂

malbert said :

I’ve got one going off the fact they were in ADFA for only a few months:

the toxic high school system environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

I said that when it first happened. In ADFA a month or two, and defense gets the negative press… (and Minister uses it as a reason to talk tough?)

The Navy makes Midshipmen do a year before they actually start at ADFA, why don’t the RAAF or Army?

BerraBoy68 said :

Stevian said :

As I have said previously the toxic military environment creates perverts. Undeniable

Generalise Much?

Here’s a few more for you to be going on with:

the toxic environment in the Catholic Church creates perverts. Undeniable.

the toxic Summernats environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

the toxic Scouting environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

the toxic hospital environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

You’ll get no argument from me

Special G said :

Should have simply charged them under the Defence Force Disciplinary Act – they’d get far more impact under that than in the ACT Courts.

Mind you they can still be charged under the DFDA after the ACT Courts are finished with them for predjudicial conduct.

While prejudicial behaviour has typically been used as the stick for beating Defence staff with for miscellaneous offences, the charge cannot relate to any civil offence. The reverse double jeopardy does not apply (i.e. someone charged under DFDA can still be charged in a civil court) which is a topic for legal debate considering the ramifications under internationally recognised rights.

“the person is not liable to be tried by a service tribunal for the same offence or for an offence that is substantially the same offence.
(3) Where:
(a) a person has been acquitted or convicted by a civil court of a civil court offence; or
(b) a person has been acquitted or convicted by an overseas court of an overseas offence;

DFDA Sec 144
http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/cth/consol_act/dfda1982188/s144.html

Having said that, I think some time in Holsworthy would serve them right.

Lookout Smithers3:28 pm 30 Apr 11

toriness said :

Faces.

I found it hilarious (not) to read in above linked article:

The lawyer for one of the men immediately moved to have the case heard in a closed court because of “national security concerns”.

Seriously? You’re a misogynist idiot 18/19 year old and you (via your lawyer) think your identity constitutes a national security concern? Come now tell the truth, you are bloody embarrassed at being revealed for being the pig that you are. Congratulations on your arrest and I hope you look forward to a lifetime of these articles showing up any time anyone googles your name.

Naming and shaming fan I take it? Too bad if the case is thrown out then. Wont you look like a prized turkey.

Lookout Smithers3:26 pm 30 Apr 11

Joe Canberran said :

I’m wondering why they were arrested and not subject to a summons

http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/act/consol_act/ca190082/s212.html

Good point. Police grandstanding?

Should have simply charged them under the Defence Force Disciplinary Act – they’d get far more impact under that than in the ACT Courts.

Mind you they can still be charged under the DFDA after the ACT Courts are finished with them for predjudicial conduct.

BerraBoy68 said :

Here’s a few more for you to be going on with:

the toxic environment in the Catholic Church creates perverts. Undeniable.

the toxic Summernats environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

the toxic Scouting environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

the toxic hospital environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

Feel free to add to the list as you identify various perverted individuals across any number of careers and/or organisations….

You missed:

the toxic internet environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

BerraBoy68 said :

Feel free to add to the list as you identify various perverted individuals across any number of careers and/or organisations….

I’ve got one going off the fact they were in ADFA for only a few months:

the toxic high school system environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

Seriously though, does anyone expect an outcome other than “bad childhood, beaten/molested/yelled at/told to sit in the naughty chair in preschool, first offense, would impact their careers too much, slap on the wrist” ?

georgesgenitals said :

toriness said :

Faces.

I found it hilarious (not) to read in above linked article:

The lawyer for one of the men immediately moved to have the case heard in a closed court because of “national security concerns”.

Seriously? You’re a misogynist idiot 18/19 year old and you (via your lawyer) think your identity constitutes a national security concern? Come now tell the truth, you are bloody embarrassed at being revealed for being the pig that you are. Congratulations on your arrest and I hope you look forward to a lifetime of these articles showing up any time anyone googles your name.

Blatant legal maneuvring.

well of course it is but it is also blatantly ridiculous legal maneuvering. would have loved to have heard the attempt by the lawyer to argue the basis for it – would have been gold legal comedy.

Stevian said :

As I have said previously the toxic military environment creates perverts. Undeniable

Generalise Much?

Here’s a few more for you to be going on with:

the toxic environment in the Catholic Church creates perverts. Undeniable.

the toxic Summernats environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

the toxic Scouting environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

the toxic hospital environment creates perverts. Undeniable.

Feel free to add to the list as you identify various perverted individuals across any number of careers and/or organisations….

Tetranitrate10:20 am 30 Apr 11

Stevian said :

As I have said previously the toxic military environment creates perverts. Undeniable

It might accommodate them, but this sort of thing is rampant in other environments too.
John XXIII College at ANU had rampant problems of this sort until a couple of years back when new management kicked out all the returning residents deemed to be problematic in an attempt to change the culture. I’m not sure how successful that would be in the long term though.

Stevian said :

As I have said previously the toxic military environment creates perverts. Undeniable

I don’t think it creates them, but it certainly nurtures them.

Stevian said :

As I have said previously the toxic military environment creates perverts. Undeniable

The most elite male college at Sydney Uni has an unchecked rape culture – far worse than ADFA.

As I have said previously the toxic military environment creates perverts. Undeniable

WonderfulWorld11:20 pm 29 Apr 11

toriness said :

Faces.

I found it hilarious (not) to read in above linked article:

The lawyer for one of the men immediately moved to have the case heard in a closed court because of “national security concerns”.

Seriously? You’re a misogynist idiot 18/19 year old and you (via your lawyer) think your identity constitutes a national security concern? Come now tell the truth, you are bloody embarrassed at being revealed for being the pig that you are. Congratulations on your arrest and I hope you look forward to a lifetime of these articles showing up any time anyone googles your name.

Here Here

video or it didn’t happen.

georgesgenitals7:40 pm 29 Apr 11

toriness said :

Faces.

I found it hilarious (not) to read in above linked article:

The lawyer for one of the men immediately moved to have the case heard in a closed court because of “national security concerns”.

Seriously? You’re a misogynist idiot 18/19 year old and you (via your lawyer) think your identity constitutes a national security concern? Come now tell the truth, you are bloody embarrassed at being revealed for being the pig that you are. Congratulations on your arrest and I hope you look forward to a lifetime of these articles showing up any time anyone googles your name.

Blatant legal maneuvring.

Faces.

I found it hilarious (not) to read in above linked article:

The lawyer for one of the men immediately moved to have the case heard in a closed court because of “national security concerns”.

Seriously? You’re a misogynist idiot 18/19 year old and you (via your lawyer) think your identity constitutes a national security concern? Come now tell the truth, you are bloody embarrassed at being revealed for being the pig that you are. Congratulations on your arrest and I hope you look forward to a lifetime of these articles showing up any time anyone googles your name.

‘You raise a good point. Although I guess the victim did not complain in a public forum in that case.’

It did.

‘Woof, woof, grrrrrr, woof,’ says it all. 🙂

Joe Canberran said :

I’m wondering why they were arrested and not subject to a summons

http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/act/consol_act/ca190082/s212.html

You just answered your own question.

Joe Canberran12:43 pm 29 Apr 11

I’m wondering why they were arrested and not subject to a summons

http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/act/consol_act/ca190082/s212.html

TVStar said :

So, the the Raiders COULD have been charged over Joel Monaghan!

You raise a good point. Although I guess the victim did not complain in a public forum in that case.

“The 18-year-old man has been charged with Use a Carriage Service to Cause Offence.”

So, the the Raiders COULD have been charged over Joel Monaghan!

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.