19 February 2012

Andrew Leigh completed as a wonk?

| johnboy
Join the conversation
17
andrew leigh tweet

Member for Fraser Andrew Leigh is in a chipper mood with this tweet:

My research (http://andrewleigh.org/pdf/InequalityMobility.pdf) cited in the Economic Report of the President (http://www.whitehouse.gov/sites/default/files/docs/erp_2012_complete.pdf) p177. My life as a wonk is complete.

Congratulations to him!

Join the conversation

17
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

johnboy said :

To be honest if you’re unfamiliar with wonk in it’s use to describe policy experts it would be best to refrain from commenting.

Ignorance is not the best place from which to mount a criticism.

(snigger) it’s use?

The trouble with self-deprecating humour on Twitter is that the whole thing exists only to publicise the individual; to keep him in people’s minds, so Andrew Leigh sneaking in a mildly self-critical word like wonk makes it sound like ‘Look at me, look at me (I’m overwhelmingly educated but I have a *cool* sense of humour)’.

Comments on websites are totally different. Of course.

maybe someone needs to make a flowchart for anyone over the age of 25:

Was the word used by a teenager / rap star / painfully cool person -> urban dictionary
Was it used by a relatively normal person without a penchant for crudeness -> google define:

wonk
Noun:
A studious or hardworking person: “any kid interested in science was a wonk”.
A person who takes an excessive interest in minor details of political policy: “a policy wonk”.

johnboy said :

Wonk is hardly twitter exclusive. And if not ignorant then what word would you suggest?

While “ignorant” might technically be the correct word for someone who is in ignorance of the true meaning, you must know that it sounds a little harsh.

Technically is the best kind of correct! (Especially to a wonk)

My familiarity with the term “wonk” seems to be similar to those expressed above, with the exception that I’ve never ever heard it as being exclusive to policy. To me, had he said “policy wonk” it would have sounded perfectly understandable, however just saying “wonk” made me wonder WTF he was on about until I read everyones discussion of the subject.

johnboy said :

To be honest if you’re unfamiliar with wonk in it’s use to describe policy experts it would be best to refrain from commenting.

Ignorance is not the best place from which to mount a criticism.

Most of us are not as erudite as you or the subject of this blog JB, so when some of us consult a cyber dictionary and quote our sources it is unfair to call us ignorant, especially as the definition chosen was kind.
Psychiatrists are suggesting people who use Twitter are likely to have NPD. Indeed, at least one of the two politicians that are battling for leadership of a destroyed political party are suffering from NPD.
If you want to ban Rioters who aren’t Twits or whatever you call yourselves from contributing, at least have the cojones to say so. Don’t just label us as ignorant.

Wonk is hardly twitter exclusive. And if not ignorant then what word would you suggest?

dungfungus said :

Not knowing what a “wonk” was I have consulted the Urban Dictionary.
There are several definitions, some very unflattering.
The one I believe is most apt is:
Noun – An expert in a field, typically someone who is fairly young and very intelligent.

Sounds like someone has NPD as well.

Really? Have you looked at his CV? http://andrewleigh.org/pdf/CV.pdf
His academic record suggests he’s around 40. He became a full professor at ANU 3 years ago and has an impressive publication record. I’d have no problem applying your definition to him.

c_c said :

No, just proves what a complete tool and a low altitude flyer this guy really is. I mean bragging on Twitter about having your name in a Harvard citation really does show what a midget he is compared to real academics.

I think the link to your own high-altitude research must have been cut off.

johnboy said :

To be honest if you’re unfamiliar with wonk in it’s use to describe policy experts it would be best to refrain from commenting.

Ignorance is not the best place from which to mount a criticism.

+1 [wink] 🙂

Not knowing what a “wonk” was I have consulted the Urban Dictionary.
There are several definitions, some very unflattering.
The one I believe is most apt is:
Noun – An expert in a field, typically someone who is fairly young and very intelligent.

Sounds like someone has NPD as well.

To be honest if you’re unfamiliar with wonk in it’s use to describe policy experts it would be best to refrain from commenting.

Ignorance is not the best place from which to mount a criticism.

Well, I guess posting crap on Twitter like this avoids having to deal with real issues like choosing Team Julia or Team Kevin.

I don’t know about Leigh being a wonk but if you replace the letter O in wonk with an A you’d be closer to the mark.

c_c said :

No, just proves what a complete tool and a low altitude flyer this guy really is. I mean bragging on Twitter about having your name in a Harvard citation really does show what a midget he is compared to real academics.
His name appears in a citation for a report he co-authored with a Harvard academic, and it’s the middle of three citations that simply refer to further discussion on a topic.
The fact he calls it “his research” rather than “My report with….” just screams ego trip.

I think some people need to calm down and appreciate how the twitter-wit operates. I follow a load of pollies, wonks, lefties and neo-cons and most have a dig at themselves – and each other – on the odd occasion.

It’s called sarcasm in 140 characters.

No, just proves what a complete tool and a low altitude flyer this guy really is. I mean bragging on Twitter about having your name in a Harvard citation really does show what a midget he is compared to real academics.
His name appears in a citation for a report he co-authored with a Harvard academic, and it’s the middle of three citations that simply refer to further discussion on a topic.
The fact he calls it “his research” rather than “My report with….” just screams ego trip.

He has got a hard character limit to work with

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.