Barr won’t engage in witch-hunt after new Orroral Valley bushfire images released

Dominic Giannini 21 January 2021 17
Aerial photo of Orroral Valley bushfire.

A photo of the start of the Orroral Valley bushfire taken from the helicopter which accidentally started the blaze on 27 January, 2020. Photo: Department of Defence, via ABC.

ACT Chief Minister Andrew Barr said the ACT will not engage in an “endless, circular blame game” with the Australian Defence Force (ADF) over the Orroral Valley bushfire after new images of the nascent blaze came to light on 21 January.

Pictures taken by the crew aboard the MRH-90 Taipan, which accidentally sparked the Territory’s worst bushfire since 2003 due to a faulty landing light, were released to the ABC under Freedom of Information laws. They reveal the damage the helicopter suffered as it scrambled away from the fire on 27 January, 2020.

Questions about why the helicopter crew could not radio in the location of the blaze – which went unreported by onboard ADF personnel until they landed at Canberra Airport 45 minutes later – have also resurfaced.

Mr Barr said he is not interested in “witch-hunts about Defence personnel”.

“Yes, it was regrettable that the incident occurred,” he said. “It was regrettable that they didn’t call it in earlier. What are we seeking to achieve in a witch-hunt? Absolutely nothing. So let’s move on.

“The only value in all of this, aside from a bit of media interest and potentially a witch-hunt against a couple of Defence Force personnel, is whether there are any lessons that can be learnt around the operation of that sort of equipment in a bushfire scenario.”

Fire damage to underside of Defence helicopter.

The damage sustained to the helicopter that accidentally ignited the Orroral Valley bushfire. Photo: Department of Defence, via ABC.

Mr Barr said what happened was an accident.

“We can learn from them, but we are not going to do ourselves any service and undo anything that has happened by having this endless, circular blame game,” he said.

“It does not achieve anything; nothing at all. There are many, many other things [the ACT Government] has to focus on at the moment … not offering endless commentary on things that happened a year ago that has absolutely nothing to do with the ACT Government.”

The ACT is still pursuing the Federal Government for compensation regarding the Orroral Valley bushfire to help with the recovery cost. The Federal Government has agreed to compensate the ACT Government up to $10 million for the damage it caused.

READ ALSO: Crew safety meant chopper couldn’t radio in Namadgi fire location, Defence says

An ACT Justice and Community Safety Directorate spokesperson told Region Media in December 2020 that the government had commenced a claims process through its own insurers with the Commonwealth’s insurers.

A Defence spokesperson said the helicopter crew called in a ‘PAN-PAN’ – a radio broadcast that signifies an urgent situation but does not pose immediate danger to life – relaying the “inflight emergency situation” to Canberra Air Traffic Control and their higher military commanders.

“Addressing the potentially catastrophic risks to crew and aircraft was the crew’s immediate priority, and the focus of their radio traffic during the flight to safety,” said the spokesperson. “Notifications were made as soon as was reasonably practicable.”

A damaged piece of the helicopter that ignited the Orroral Valley bushfire.

A damaged piece of the helicopter that accidentally ignited the Orroral Valley bushfire. Photo: Department of Defence, via ABC.

The person taking the photos was an Australian Defence Force member who was not part of the aircrew, said Defence.

“Passengers do not have means of external communication to air traffic control or civil emergency services while aboard an aircraft,” said a Defence spokesperson.

“Only the aircrew are on external radio nets while in flight.”

Defence did not answer questions about why crew members could not have relayed the fire’s location during the 45-minute flight to Canberra Airport.

It took ACT Emergency Services 17 minutes to spot the smoke from the bushfire from the Mount Tennent fire tower before the location was finally confirmed by a spotter aircraft around 48 minutes after ignition, by which time the fire had grown significantly.

The bushfire burnt 78 per cent of Namadgi National Park and 22 per cent of Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve, sparking the ACT’s first state of emergency since 2003.

What's Your Opinion?

Please login to post your comments, or connect with
17 Responses to Barr won’t engage in witch-hunt after new Orroral Valley bushfire images released
Bradley Heanes Bradley Heanes 3:43 pm 24 Jan 21

Didn't the defence department already appologise for this? (Even though they were assisting the RFS at the time)

Didn't they also supply 100's of thousands of dollars in staff for clean up as well as quite a few million dollars to the ACT gov?

All this after an ACCIDENT while assisting the RFS!

It was an accident!!!!!

Are we laying charges against the bee keeper that started the one at Pialligo that burnt for two days?!?!?

Are we laying charges against the electricity company who's power lines apparently started the one at Brindabella park?

Lets move on ppl and work how to prevent/reduce the risk in the future!!

franky22 franky22 1:00 pm 24 Jan 21

Why can’t the ADF simply state that they made a mistake.

Capital Retro Capital Retro 11:41 am 24 Jan 21

Here is the proof that the ADF was “working closely with ACT ESA” at the time of the incident.

So, I ask the question again, why didn’t the ACT ESA call in the fire?

Peter Curtis Peter Curtis 2:59 pm 23 Jan 21

A mistake is questionable – using a very hot light under those conditions suggests a lack of forethought or understanding of conditions.

Peter Curtis Peter Curtis 2:52 pm 23 Jan 21

Lack of faith in politicians and democratic accountability is fueled by the language CM Barr uses to disparage reasonable questions. Yes mistakes are made, but I cannot imagine that the pilots were not thinking that they should be reporting the ignition. There is a problem when protocols preclude flexible responses to unforeseen events. If a person was using machinery or doing something that would cause ignition of flammable material they would probably be charged. Using a landing light as they did does seem to fit within this category.

HiddenDragon HiddenDragon 7:52 pm 22 Jan 21

Unless there’s a nice little quid pro quo coming up for the ACT in the next federal Budget (dream on….), this outbreak of “let’s move on” reasonableness is a bit like the dog that didn’t bark in the Sherlock Holmes story.

sportsmum sportsmum 1:22 pm 22 Jan 21

There doesn’t need to be a witch hunt, but an acknowledgement of the fact that 45 minutes and an exact location of the fire would have made the world of difference to containment is important. Perhaps a different protocol needs to be applied in future when Defence personnel actions do spark bushfires, especially as this is far from an isolated occurrence.

Acton Acton 10:37 am 22 Jan 21

I don’t often agree with Mr Barr, but I do on this. Accidents happen, mistakes are made, humans err or just bad luck. Let it go.

Capital Retro Capital Retro 10:38 pm 21 Jan 21

I was of the understanding that the helicopter was meeting with ACT ESA people for a media event so if that was the case wouldn’t they have called it in?

    Capital Retro Capital Retro 7:07 pm 23 Jan 21

    No one has contradicted my claim so far so, am I correct? The aircraft was clearing landing sites in liaison with ACT ESA as part of supply strategies in the event of a bushfire so ACT ESA would have been fully aware what was going on.

    Also, that photo says it was taken “at the start” of the Orroral Valley fire but that isn’t credible because it has already covered at least 100 acres. It would appear then that the aircraft lingered at the scene for some time which needs explaining.

Robyne Mitchell Robyne Mitchell 7:28 pm 21 Jan 21

What about the people who lost their livelihoods and houses as a result of this fire?

Daniel Burden Daniel Burden 6:17 pm 21 Jan 21

Somehow I thought if you burnt down 80% of a national park someone may get in trouble. Or at least investigated further

Robyne Mitchell Robyne Mitchell 6:10 pm 21 Jan 21

Someone has to be accountable for their actions or lack of it. 😠

    Jilly Beans Jilly Beans 7:07 pm 21 Jan 21

    Robyne Mitchell well that would be the ADF- so it’s Scotty.

    Silins Kris Silins Kris 7:08 pm 21 Jan 21

    They were Supposably to blame for the 2003 fires as well if I remember correctly and weren’t held accountable at that time either ... could be wrong either way someone needs to stand up

    Louise Flood Louise Flood 7:21 pm 21 Jan 21

    Robyne Mitchell and the Blue Mountains fire that started with in Lithgow

    Peta Siebert Peta Siebert 12:20 am 22 Jan 21

    Kris Doph 2003 fires was caused by a lightening strike. The fire started in NSW and the NSW RFS left the fire to burn until it was too late to contain.

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site