24 September 2010

Canberra teen dies on the Barton Highway

| johnboy
Join the conversation
35

This in from NSW Police:

Police will prepare a report for the Coroner after the death of a man following a single-vehicle crash near Canberra this morning.

About 3.50am a car was travelling on the Barton Highway at Jeir, 40kms south-east of Canberra, when it left the roadway and went into a ditch.

The driver, an 18-year-old man from Canberra, suffered serious injuries and was taken to Canberra Hospital but later died.

His 17-year-old male passenger suffered minor injuries and was also taken to Canberra Hospital.

The road has since reopened.

Our condolences to family and friends.

Join the conversation

35
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

buzz819 said :

It’s funny, I’ve driven that road on hundreds of different occasions in a lot of different cars, never died one… After that kind of research I find that the thing that caused the accident would have been;
1) Lack of experience;
2) Too much speed; and,
3) A confusion of one’s ambitions and capabilities.

Tens of thousand’s of people drive that road weekly, it is a major road, when someone isn’t driving sensibly, they are going to die…

Yes, but you’re talking about what caused an accident, I’m talking about how severe the consequences of an accident need to be.

Me no fry said :

vg said :

“Most of you just don’t get it.”

How many fatal accidents have you been to?

None, in an official capacity, not that I’m sure just how the question is relevant. I have been present when people have died, though, very unpleasant. The human body just isn’t designed to cope with sudden impacts at anything much above running speed.

My opening sentence in comment #29 sounds a bit combative, when I re-read it. It wasn’t meant to be. My point is, how safe can any road really be when people die on it regularly? Certainly the Barton Highway would be a bit safer if that bloody big tree the guy ran into – for whatever reason – had been chopped down years ago. That’s all I’m saying – the road isn’t just the black tarmaccy thing you drive on, it’s the whole box and dice, it’s run-off areas that allow you to wash off speed without coming to a sudden stop against a tree, it’s a lack of blind corners, it’s a lot of things.

It’s funny, I’ve driven that road on hundreds of different occasions in a lot of different cars, never died one… After that kind of research I find that the thing that caused the accident would have been;
1) Lack of experience;
2) Too much speed; and,
3) A confusion of one’s ambitions and capabilities.

Tens of thousand’s of people drive that road weekly, it is a major road, when someone isn’t driving sensibly, they are going to die…

vg said :

“Most of you just don’t get it.”

How many fatal accidents have you been to?

None, in an official capacity, not that I’m sure just how the question is relevant. I have been present when people have died, though, very unpleasant. The human body just isn’t designed to cope with sudden impacts at anything much above running speed.

My opening sentence in comment #29 sounds a bit combative, when I re-read it. It wasn’t meant to be. My point is, how safe can any road really be when people die on it regularly? Certainly the Barton Highway would be a bit safer if that bloody big tree the guy ran into – for whatever reason – had been chopped down years ago. That’s all I’m saying – the road isn’t just the black tarmaccy thing you drive on, it’s the whole box and dice, it’s run-off areas that allow you to wash off speed without coming to a sudden stop against a tree, it’s a lack of blind corners, it’s a lot of things.

The road can be as good or as bad as you like. People will still find a way to crash on it. Autobahns etc all throughout Europe are about as good as a road can get – a lot of them are racetrack quality. People still crash and kill themselves.

Maybe we should let all the roads go to crap then people will have to slow down and pay attention to drive them. Probably will have more crashes then – but at lower speeds will be less fatalities.

georgesgenitals2:39 pm 26 Sep 10

Me no fry said :

Most of you just don’t get it. If somebody dies on a road, then the safety of the road could probably be improved.

Like the exit from the Monaro Hwy at Canberra Ave? Was that the road’s fault?

Me no fry said :

Most of you just don’t get it. If somebody dies on a road, then the safety of the road could probably be improved.

I agree with your comment, but my point was that driver error is the cause of prangs, rather than the road, which would be just one factor out of many when determining the cause.

“Most of you just don’t get it.”

How many fatal accidents have you been to?

Most of you just don’t get it. If somebody dies on a road, then the safety of the road could probably be improved.

Look at the approach the Swedes have taken on road safety. They have this plan called Vision Zero (must have stolen the idea from Stanhope…..) which involved accepting that people will probably always find a way to crash their cars (stupidity, inexperience, momentary distraction, whatever), so you just have to mitigate the effects of that crash by trying to control the amount of kinetic energy carries into a crash. They do things like clearing trees and large rocks from the roadside, changing all 2 lane roads into 3 lane roads (presumably with the 3rd lane switching sides occasionaly so that each side of traffic knows an overtaking lane isn’t too far away) and putting up crash barriers between opposing traffic lanes.

Oh, and if you get caught drink-driving in Sweden you apparently stand a good chance of being sent to jail. No pissy little 3 month driving ban, $600 fine and a restricted licence to drive to work – jail.

“What about registered black spots then?”

Are they registered because the road has accidents?

Your life is a hell of a price to pay for inexperience.

It’s a pity it takes years to develop driving experience… I’m all for getting kids to get some driving experience off the roads, well before they a legally allowed on them.

Condolences to the families and friends… whatever the reason was.

Tooks said :

Postalgeek said :

A road is a road, the surface beneath your car. It’s not safe or unsafe. You could drive on the Barton highway on a rainy night at 40kph and it’d probably feel safe.

What is safe, or unsafe, is the concentration of drivers, their expectations, their judgement, their skills, and their ability to assess the road and conditions.

Spot on. The media especially love blaming roads, rainy weather etc for prangs.

What about registered black spots then? Do you think they are just tragic coincidences? Perhaps caused by a malevolent spirit? Some bits of roads are safe and some are UNSAFE. Drivers skill and other factors come into it too but so does the road.

Yes, a better engineered road with a centre divider and three lanes each way will probably result in fewer crashes, but there is too much blaming of roads for crashes, in my opinion. It irks me when I hear the media say things like “the (insert name here) Highway has claimed another life”.

Drivers are safe or unsafe – that is the main factor. Yes, a better road will give a driver more room for error, but inexperience, lack of observation and anticipation etc are all bigger factors than the quality of road.

Felix the Cat5:39 am 26 Sep 10

How can the road be the cause (or a major contributor) of the crash if thousands of other motorists use it every day with no incidents?

Possibly a ‘roo could of jumped out in front of the car. 3.50am is pretty early to be out and about, maybe the driver fell asleep momentarily (Dr Karl microsleep) and then reawakened to see themselves heading off the road but were too late to stop the car.

He wasnt a ‘man’ at all, he was just a boy, my good friend.

Postalgeek said :

A road is a road, the surface beneath your car. It’s not safe or unsafe. You could drive on the Barton highway on a rainy night at 40kph and it’d probably feel safe.

What is safe, or unsafe, is the concentration of drivers, their expectations, their judgement, their skills, and their ability to assess the road and conditions.

Spot on. The media especially love blaming roads, rainy weather etc for prangs.

During this time of year, and the transition through winter, this part of track can get pretty hairy. Even some of the most experienced drivers I know who do the daily commute, have got themselves into trouble with people either not slowing down, or plain not paying enough attention (oh look at the new baby goats!!). After making the daily commute up and down this stretch of highway for a few years, there are times when it can be absolutely terrifying.

The huge trucks heading back down to Albury, the idiots who like to use it as their own personal speed way, the kangaroos who like to mull around, or just the plain ol’ weather. I think fixing the situation comes under a number of different solutions, the matter is getting to that suitable point.

Condolences to the family.

georgesgenitals1:45 am 25 Sep 10

Very sad, but the road is not at fault here.

Notimportant10:53 pm 24 Sep 10

I can’t believe he’s gone.

VikingWizardEyes6:53 pm 24 Sep 10

was pretty foggy on the highway at 420 this morning….condolences to family and friends.

Holden,

I really simplified my comment as it could have gone on forever.

One of the biggest things I see on our roads is lack of judgement. Judgement comes with experience behind the wheel with good teaching.

It comes in all forms from people waiting to overtake at the last minute, taking corners too fast, driving while tired ect.

I grew up on the Sapphire coast so I had the benifit of having a driving career that started at the age of 11 or 12 (I cant really remember). I did all the things country kids do, paddock bashing, screaming through the bush on dirt bikes & generally being a hoon.

When I got my licence this didnt stop (I was bullet proof at 17). We had 2km of dirt road from the main road to my house & I used to use it as my rally track (among other roads).I should be dead with the risks I took, we regularly saw the top side of 200km/h.

The reason I survived was A) Sheer luck & B) I had learned car control prior to being let out on the roads.

Now, I am definately not condoning this behavoir at all (wisdom of hindsight & all that) but if the learner driving requirements included say 10-20 driving hours of specific training on a closed circuit to teach car craft say at Sutton then a vast majority of accidents will/could be avoided.

Another thing, people should be made to drive a vehicle that weighs 4.49t and at least a scooter for experience.

I have a motorcycle licence, have driven vehicles up to 7 tonnes. It is a skill that is not nurtured enough before a person is let loose on the roads. Most people learn as they go along, most people survive but people like the bloke this morning dont.

These are just my thoughts but I think they would go a long way to helping a problem.

Now, those people who are going to slag me for my past actions, think about it, I may just be the one on the road that wont run over you in the future.

I drive the Barton often and in August every day for two weeks outbound in light traffic near midday and returning on dusk against heavy traffic often in rain. I can not see that bad road conditions can be nailed as the cause of many accidents but drivers will not slow for the conditions. I am not a slow driver – I do 100k whenever safe to do so – my pet hate is slow drivers on say 85K who always speedup to 100-105K when they get to the dual lanes specially installed for overtaking. Nothing seems to be done about these idiots – anyway – they are obviously not just on the Barton. On the other hand – if I am going through overtaking lanes keeping left at 100K – I just hear woosh-woosh-woosh as the speeders rocket past as tho I am an obstruction. The worst danger that worried me we was southbound on that strait near the ACT where the northbound traffic has a right turn from the middle of the road into Spring Range Rd (I think it is) Phew – my hackles would rise approaching at 100K hoping nobody would turn right stupidly or a foot would slip on a clutch pedal and lurch into the southbound lane. To me that is v bad road engineering – an accident waiting to happen – right turners should pull off to left and turn when clear.

A road is a road, the surface beneath your car. It’s not safe or unsafe. You could drive on the Barton highway on a rainy night at 40kph and it’d probably feel safe.

What is safe, or unsafe, is the concentration of drivers, their expectations, their judgement, their skills, and their ability to assess the road and conditions.

Also, last night would have been perfect for unexpected foggy patches, even if you’re familiar with the road.
BOM: Areas of fog and patches of light frost this morning.

Holden Caulfield3:46 pm 24 Sep 10

KB1971 said :

…Driver training is one of the keys to reducing the road tolls, this young fella obviously had not had anough experience behind the wheel to control the vehicle correctly (or he fell asleep & woke suddenly), you get that from training. City drivers are especially vulnerable to having accidents in the country for a variety of reasons, namely lack of experience.

Either way, people really need to stop blaming infrastructure for these things. Its just too easy to get your licence.

I don’t necessarily agree with all of what you say, but there is merit to your basic argument. I think it is also a really good point about driving on country roads, especially unfamiliar roads and at night. In theory, there’s not too much to it, but the fact you can get a full licence without ever having to be tested under such conditions raises a few serious questions IMO.

screaming banshee3:43 pm 24 Sep 10

Tragedy? Yes

Was the road at fault? No

Holden Caulfield3:39 pm 24 Sep 10

Condolences to the families involved.

As to the condition of the Barton Highway I used to drive the road to and from Yass about 330 days a year for three years or so back in the early 90s.

I have never had any major issues with the road. But then I was about the same age as the deceased in the OP when I started travelling the route regularly, so even if there were problems with the road I probably wouldn’t have cared.

Now I probably drive the Barton Hwy 2 or 3 times a year and I have noticed how the growth of the trees has drastically altered the sight lines around and through corners. The volume of traffic would have increased tenfold, or more, for the daily commute I expect. It must suck, actually.

Who knows what caused the accident with this young kid, but the assumption made by vg at post #2 cold very well be accurate. But we may never know.

I used to fly on that road back in the day, so I’m certainly in no position to cast judgment, other than to say 18 year olds (esp males) like driving fast. Nothing will change that.

niceplacetolive said :

vg, the Barton Highway is not fine. It is a sealed bullock track that is unsafe and needs to be upgraded as a matter of priority.

Totally disagree, it is a well contsructed bit of road with large shoulders and no sharp off camber corners to trap you on (go for a drive on the Bobeyan road, it has the same speed limit). You can safely do 100km/h along it with no issues at all.

As Me no Fry said, its the volume of traffic (partly) but the largest issue is the way drivers treat the road (Kings Highway is a victim of this affliction as well). Yep, its 40-50km of single lane road but you get a couple of extremes of drivers out there, the ones who will sit at 20km/h under the limit due to lack of confidence causing the traffic to bank up & the people who have to drive as fast as they can to get there & will overtake anything at all costs. Monaro Highway in the ski season is another example.

Driver training is one of the keys to reducing the road tolls, this young fella obviously had not had anough experience behind the wheel to control the vehicle correctly (or he fell asleep & woke suddenly), you get that from training. City drivers are especially vulnerable to having accidents in the country for a variety of reasons, namely lack of experience.

Either way, people really need to stop blaming infrastructure for these things. Its just too easy to get your licence.

vg, you should reserve judgement on the cause of the crash. But regardless of the cause, the Barton Highway is not fine. The road is barely adequate for the volume of traffic it carries, in places there is very little room for error (that is, safe places to run off the road – for whatever reason) and too many roadside obstacles to crash into if you make an error. Major roads shouldn’t be do or die places where an error costs you your life.

On that topic, I think it is nothing short of shameful that the NSW RTA thinks it is appropriate to place those massive road “safety” structures on the highways, overhanging the roads. They are going up everywhere – have seen them on the Clyde Mountain and the Hume highway up to Goulburn.

Barton used to freak me out as a P plater, being overtaken bby trucks that weer much more confident than me.

niceplacetolive1:35 pm 24 Sep 10

Skidbladnir, I saw that car this morning. I saw the skidmarks and I saw the tree. The police will investigate the details, and we shouldn’t jump to conclusions because of a driver’s age, time of travelling or brand of vehicle..

The fatality occured in an area where large trees are located within two metres of the very limited road verge, almost opposite where a fatality occurred a couple of years ago. The particular area also has a large kangaroo population, is winding and undulating. Almost opposite the Valencia Estate.

What we do need is a community banding together to support safety improvements on the Barton Highway.

niceplacetolive1:25 pm 24 Sep 10

vg, the Barton Highway is not fine. It is a sealed bullock track that is unsafe and needs to be upgraded as a matter of priority.

Canberra is 40km SE of Jeir…

Anyway vg is right, time (so probably exhaustion also), age, single vehicle leaving the road…
The highway isn’t at fault.

caf said :

I think NSW Police may need to buy some new magnetic compasses. Nowhere on the Barton Highway is to the south-east of Canberra.

You beat me to it…..40km SE of Canberra is Michelego, or more correctly, Jerangle.

I think NSW Police may need to buy some new magnetic compasses. Nowhere on the Barton Highway is to the south-east of Canberra.

The road is fine. Just put the age, time and the fact its a single vehicle accident together. It is a tragedy but I’d guess an avoidable one

niceplacetolive12:00 pm 24 Sep 10

Truly truly tragic. We need a safer Barton Highway and we need it now. My thoughts are with the family.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.