18 August 2008

Candidate questionaire - call for questions

| johnboy
Join the conversation
60

[First filed: July 31, 2008 @ 09:42]

Every election we get you, the readers, to nominate questions they’d like to ask candidates in the upcoming poll.

We pick the best 10 and send them to everyone who’s running and a surprising number of them knuckle down and fill them in. The better ones even deviate from the party line from time to time.

So here’s you chance, put down your questions in the comments and we’ll let you know which ones we’ve picked in a week or so.

UPDATE: Last chance to get your questions in.

Join the conversation

60
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

I sent this list of questions (slightly edited) to a Tuggeranong Labor Candidate recently, after receiving their flyer making vague commetns about quality health care. Some of them apply to all candidates, some not.

Passy

Dear candidate

Which faction, if any, are you in? Which union?

I understand the ACT ALP Conference voted unanimously to support the immediate abolition of the ABCC. What’s your position?

Katy Gallagher has not prevented Primary health from moving 7 doctors from Wanniassa to Philip. I find it almost unbelieveable that the ACT Government could not have pressured Primary health to stay at Wanniassa, eg by threatening punitive action such as increased taxes, taking over their assets, closing down their Phillip lease. What concrete proposals do you have for better access to doctors in Tuggeranong, to stop Primary health at this late stage and to prevent re-occurrences?

Do you support the Liberals in their promise not to close down any more schools and to reduce primamry class sizes to 21. What is your own view about the previous school closures? My kids went to Mt Neighbour and then Kambah High. (They used to be schools in the area.)

Do you support a curfew at Canberra Airport if night flights are spread over Tuggeranong?

What is your position on the data centre and attached energy plant? Do you support the Stanhope Government’s decision to close down the independent review of the health impacts? As an asthmatic I’d be very interested in your answers.

Does Labor have a territory wide transport policy geared towards public transport and what is it? I favour free buses as part of an integrated strategy to reduce car use.

How do you plan to address the chronic GP shortage across Canberra?

Will you legalise Poker-playing in the ACT?

What are your views on the proposal by the Victorian Government which, if enacted, would spread to all other jurisdictions including the ACT, for front number plates on motorcycles. Only two other countries have this requirement (India and Singapore) and no manufacturer incorporates this into their motorbike designs. Victoria is seriously considering the proposal because they have front-facing speed cameras (most states/territories have rear-facing) cameras, and the only rationale for implementation is because of a perception that speeding revenue is compromised. The problems with the scheme include (among other things) danger to pedestrians/riders in the event of an accident, stability problems with changed aerodynamics, problems with fitment that can result in sharp fixing objects millimetres from the tyres, and potential cooling issues for the motor. There is no evidence whatsoever for improved safety; in fact, it is likely to decrease safety.

A Concerned Ulyssian

neanderthalsis2:22 pm 18 Aug 08

1.
What is your party’s stance on the issue of contestability of funding in Vocational education and training as considered in the Boston Consulting report delivered to COAG in March 2008?

2.
What is your party’s stance on the issue on the reporting of school performance and rankings against set performance benchmarks?

3.
Are you considering targeted interventions to combat youth disengagement from the education and labour market (especially given the disengagement rate for 18 – 22 year olds is close to 50%)?

4.
What is your party’s stance on the reporting of employability skills and language, literacy and numeracy skills against pre-determined benchmarks upon exiting from school?

5.
What is your party’s stance on performance pay for teachers?

How do other people view your management style?

What experience do you have in economic and budgetary management?

In 15 words or less, why should anyone vote for you?

How do you view the status quo of the ACT-Queanbeyan relationship, and would you be open to formalising any part of it beyond current arrangements?

How do you plan to balance Canberra’s much needed urban infill projects and enuring that the National Capitals areas of historical significance are not prostituted to corporate development, without handballing major policy decisions to the NCA?

Can you outline any plans for attracting major events to the National Capital, including ensuring that there is sufficient funding for such an event to continue at least well into the mid to short term (please try not to include any current events)?

What particular industries do you see as vital to the continued growth and success of the ACT economy and how are you planning on diversifying the Government’s investment and ensuring dividends are maxmimised in these key areas of your economic plan?

A YES answer to this will win my vote:

Will you immediately dismiss Justice Higgins?

Will you restore the ACT coat of arms to the welcome to Canberra signs? If not, why, and would you instead change the signage to remove the ridiculous blank white space where the coat of arms should be?

Do you think it is appropriate for the Chief Minister (or any other ACT MLA, for that matter) to be concerning themselves with wider political issues outside their role as a member of the ACT Govt?

Mælinar - *spoiler alert* I've seen S04E137:44 pm 02 Aug 08

Who do you think should carry the Australian Flag at Beijing ?

Would you legislate to insure that all Canberran’s have access to companion animals regardless of body corporate by-laws or lease agreements?

ps – Residential drug rehabilitation

Please rate the following in order of importance for future funding:

Mental health services
The birth centre
Waiting times in Casualty
Elective surgery

Mælinar - *spoiler alert* I've seen S04E132:34 pm 01 Aug 08

What is your position on the continued avaliability of Public Housing being linked to the earning power of the occupant ?

Sorry, buggered up the link, but it still works somehow. Sorry JB.

johnboy said :

In the past we’ve had quite a lot of major party candidates responding.

But if they choose to sit out the game then that’s there loss.

No I mean an honest answer. I can answer these questions tricky dicky style quite easily. It wouldn’t tell you anything though.

@tom-tom: Margo Kingston and the CEC candiadate were fruitcakes before they arrived here.

And any candidate need not neccessarily respond to commenters, any more than they respond to the people in a newspaper “Letters to the Editor”.

Because one arsehole commenter will ruin their hard work?

And because political candidates this town are so awash with free publicity?

Good thing you’re not advising candidates.

if i were advising a candidate i wouldn’t let them answer this, not out of spite or anything but just in the past the comments that followed have been attacks that a candidate just doesn’t have time to respond to

In the past we’ve had quite a lot of major party candidates responding.

But if they choose to sit out the game then that’s there loss.

Some of these are really good questions. It’s a shame the two major Party’s won’t touch them with a ten foot pole. Not worth the backlash that would arise from giving an honest and good answer.

What do you see as the largest or single most pressing issue from your electorate (as in specific to your electoral boundary, not a larger regional issue), and how would you move to address this if elected?

What opinions do you have which are in disagreement with the majority of your party, how do you differ, and are they personal opinions or a refection of your electorate?

What is your personal view of taxpayer funded public\transitory\ephemeral art?

As the ACT has a finite income, most recently sustained through property and land sales. The tax and ratepayer has a right to expect that funding spent on public institutions will be appropriately utilised and accounted for, and that any project defunded to pay for another will have been done so for good reasons.
The gaol (or “the Alexander Maconochie Centre for the Criminally Disposed”) is one such major work which will continue to be a facility of not insignificant government operating cost and maintenance expense.
Should there be a major impact from this ‘credit crunch’ or an economic downtown\local recession, it would most likly arrive during your term in the Assembly.
Which ACT Government projects, initiatives, or expenditures would you scrutinise most closely, or even support the axing of, in order to prevent an ACT budget blowout?

Do you support the current system of policing Canberra as a part of the AFP or would you prefer to see a different Model implemented and what steps will you take to ensure tougher and more realistic sentencing is handed down from the judiciary in the ACT.

I have to declare an interest here seeing as I do this for a living but – how about: “Many industries are moving to Performance Based Contracts as a means of driving contractor performance. The essence of good PBC’s are that you only actually pay for what the contractor actually delivers (side note: a strange concept in public sector where they typically pay the full contract price regardless of what is actually delivered). Noting this concept, what is your position on:
A) placing every Minister in your Government (if elected to Government)on an individual PBC so a percentage of your salary (say 50%) is paid according to the number of policies fully implemented, as promised in your campaign; and
B) making all ACT Government contracts above $2m Performance Based?”

The above drives both Ministerial responsibility and effective use of taxpayer provided funds.

Will you vote to allow club style non profit poker card game tournaments to be played in Canberra?

What do you plan to do to arrest the decay of the older (City Walk/Petrie Plaza/Garema Place) part of Civic?

Skidbladnir said :

Sorry, put in the a href but left out the link. http://the-riotact.com/?p=6025

OH. MY. GOD!

That was the most hilarious thing I’ve read in a while. Especially when the poor fool got caught out using multiple usernames.

Sorry, put in the a href but left out the link. http://the-riotact.com/?p=6025

Jonathon Reynolds said :

What will you do to change the voting system in the ACT given that perfect democratic voting even with the current Hare-Clark system combined with Robson rotation is, not just in practice but in principle, impossible?

Candidates may (and should) make reference to the Arrow’s impossibility theorem then putting forward their alternative scheme.

You are a sick evil man Mr Reynolds. 🙂

Mælinar - *spoiler alert* I've seen S04E134:04 pm 31 Jul 08

What is your opinion on politicians who make spurious election promises in the full knowledge that they are going to renege on them when/if in power ?

Happy to have that wordsmithed.

The link to the wine story doesn’t work for me.

jakez said :

what will your party do to ensure no canberra citizen is ever again overcharged $5 for a pizza?

What are you talking about?

Inside joke.

The overcharging $5 pizza thread goes back into the Dawn Times, I think.
Someone had a rant about how they shouldn’t have had to pay $5 for their valuable time being wasted.

Not quite as bad as Grazings, or the guy who fired off a spray about not understanding that good wine normally costs more than $2/bottle, and $26 when ‘buying by the case’ was a per bottle rate.

But still worth reading as for something sarcastically named “How to win customers and influence people” both sides went straight for the shitfighter angle.

But, back on topic.

Jonathon Reynolds2:48 pm 31 Jul 08

What will you do to change the voting system in the ACT given that perfect democratic voting even with the current Hare-Clark system combined with Robson rotation is, not just in practice but in principle, impossible?

Candidates may (and should) make reference to the Arrow’s impossibility theorem then putting forward their alternative scheme.

astrojax said :

what will your party do to ensure no canberra citizen is ever again overcharged $5 for a pizza?

(this last one might be most telling)

What are you talking about?

if you are elected, what would you want to point to as your legacy when it is all over?

why are you someone to whom we should entrust the governance of our community?

what will your party do to ensure no canberra citizen is ever again overcharged $5 for a pizza?

(this last one might be most telling)

Do you support the proposal to make the ACTION bus network a free service?

When will you build high rise car parks in the city so that I, the lazy Canberran can drive to work and find a park easily? After all, it is my god given right (note, not privilege) to drive to work every day!!!!

1. What is your solution to the following issues currently faced in canberra?

Car parking in the Canberra region
Hospital Emergency department wait times
economic pressures on employers / employees
rising cost of living
housing affordability
lack of qualified support workers for families

2. If elected, what do you believe your party’s greatest focus area will be, in the first 12-months?

3. What is the primary issue faced by canberrans, and in your own opinion, how would you rectify it?

what steps will you / your party take to ensure the ACT is maximally self-suffient for energy, including no / low carbon renewable energy sources in and around the territory?

how will you / your party work to improve motorist’s skills and compliance with all road traffic laws in the ACT? And as part of the response, what role do you see yourself taking to promote cycling as a genuinely alternative transport solution for a maximum number of residents?

Ooh good one captainwhorebags.

“Do you think the planning role of the NCA should be restricted to the Parliamentary Triangle and National Institutions?”

captainwhorebags12:51 pm 31 Jul 08

Would you/how would you seek to improve the territory/Federal relationship? Be as broad or narrow as desired – meetings & consultations, all the way up to constitutional reform on the status of the territories.

If elected will you reverse the Stanhope Government’s rate hikes?

A bit broad and open ended but I’d like to see what they say. If anyone can improve on it please do so.

1) What will you do to address the pathetic car parking situation in Civic where all government carparks (for which I buy my monthly prepaid ticket) are completely full before 9am every day.

2) Will you remove Friday night & Saturday paid parking in Civic to encourage a more ‘vibrant’ city centre?

Jonathon Reynolds12:02 pm 31 Jul 08

For each of the following geographic areas of Canberra in YOUR electorate* specify for each area, your top (ONE ONLY) priority that you will undertake if elected:

— Belconnen
— City / Central Canberra
— Gungahlin
— Hall
— Jerrabomberra
— Majura
— Molonglo
— North Canberra
— Rural Canberra
— South Canberra
— Tharwa
— Tuggeranong
— Weston Creek
— Woden Valley

* this is also a test to see if you know which areas are covered by your electorate.

Make them put down a collateral for each of their election promises?

Question for the candidates:

“Would you, when in Government, mandate rain dancing as a role of the Department of Environment & Heritage. Afterall, it is you who we the people expect to solve everything”

How will you improve Canberra’s transport network?
And how do we know your previous answer isn’t just pre-election promises and will not come to fruition?

QUESTIONS FOR CANDIDATES HERE PLEASE

Not wishlists and self-promotion.

Skidbladnir said :

Do we know which candidates will actually be responding to these questions, or should we just write them blind?
(Yes, I know that all candidates get the same questions)

But some questions will get very different answers from different candidates dependant on phrasing.
IE: Mike Crowther and the ACT Cuddleprison. Richard Mulcahy and party unity. Andrew Barr on schools.

No.

Questions need to be applicable to all candidates.

Jonathon Reynolds11:31 am 31 Jul 08

Aurelius said :

It doesn’t matter what they say now, they’ll say something different post October.
Has anyone got a list of what they promised last time around, with a scoresheet of what they achieved?

Yes, the Gungahlin Community Council undertakes a rigourous questionnaire process at each election on Gungahlin related issues. The documentation from 2004 is available at: http://www.gcc.asn.au/oldgcc/gamva/index.htm

The Gungahlin Community Council is in the process of preparing a new online community survey of local issues for the October election. The GCC Candidate/Party questionnaire and emphasis at the 8 October “GCC Meet the Candidates Event” will reflect the results of this survey.

The Meet the candidates event will be filmed and the available for viewing on the web. Responses from the GCC Candidate/Party questionnaire will be published in the October 2008 edition of GunSmoke: http://gcc.asn.au/content/view/275/270/


Jonathon Reynolds
Vice President

Gungahlin Community Council Inc
PO Box 260 Gungahlin, ACT 2912
m 0418 812 281
e vicepresident@gcc.asn.au

Do we know which candidates will actually be responding to these questions, or should we just write them blind?
(Yes, I know that all candidates get the same questions)

But some questions will get very different answers from different candidates dependant on phrasing.
IE: Mike Crowther and the ACT Cuddleprison. Richard Mulcahy and party unity. Andrew Barr on schools.

Loquaciousness11:18 am 31 Jul 08

LG said :

3 – sure, they towed the party line

Which makes one wonder … towed it where? Frankly, I’d be quite glad to see the party line removed to some distant horizon. Somewhere where I don’t have to listen to it, anyway 😉

L

It doesn’t matter what they say now, they’ll say something different post October.
Has anyone got a list of what they promised last time around, with a scoresheet of what they achieved?

Not a question but I’d like for RiotACT members to be able to rate (by poll) the responses on a bullsh!t scale on how honest the candidates werein their responses.

Eg.

5 – my god! they actually read the questions and prepared a considered response

3 – sure, they towed the party line but it looks as if they actually wrote the response themselves

1 – I don’t think they read either the questions or the answers, which were obviously prepared by a party hack / head office

One for the Christian voters:

“What is your stance on abortion, gay marriage, RU486, and embryonic research?”

A question – if you, and/or the party you represent, are not elected, who would you prefer to see in the Assembly? Which major party? Which minor party or independent? WHo would you least like to see elected?

(For non-major party candidates) In the event of neither major oarty having a majority, who would you support on important legislation and matters of confidence?

The objects, if answered honestly, would be to flush out what candidates stand for and, perhaps, to suggest which if any of them of them are running as proxies for others.

Ok I’ll go first then.

“What will be your number 1 spending priority, and what are you willing to de-fund in order to pay for it?”

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.