25 June 2009

Cultural relevance and CityNews? (also bottoms)

| johnboy
Join the conversation
37

CityNews has an endless capacity to surprise.

I was particularly surprised by this week’s effort by Sonya Fladun in which she attempts to argue that larger bottoms are “back” in fashion.

What’s the data?

    Much of this new popularity for the bigger bum owes much to celebrities with rounded posteriors who have proudly embraced their curves (think Beyoncé or J. Lo). Butts are so big in pop culture that there is even a song dedicated to the larger derrière titled “I Like Big Butts’’. (Predictably, this is a song my six-year-old son has somehow learnt the words to – accompanied by numerous sniggers.)

So, J.Lo and Beyoncé are hardly recent adventures. But what’s this song “I Like Big Butts”? Could Sonya be referring to Sir Mix-a-lot’s 1992 classic, in actuallity titled “Baby Got Back”? Why yes, I think in fact she is.

A seventeen year old song for which you’ve got the name wrong highlights a new social trend does it?

Join the conversation

37
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

“Oh dear. Please don’t lump all 35+ first time mothers into that particular basket.”
Fair call – all generalisations are bad

gold, lulu, straight to the pool room with that one..!

Felix the Cat8:23 pm 25 Jun 09

Desperate for stories much, JB? Not sure how this is relevant to Canberra anyway except that it’s a recycled City News story.

rosebud said :

Does this website make my butt look big?

Bwahahahahaha!

I simply loooooove real size women who’ve lived a little and are comfortable with themselves. This is much more attractive to me than photoshopped or synthetic women.

Hi S.S.A.
“Oh dear. Please don’t lump all 35+ first time mothers into that particular basket.”
Fair call – all generalisations are bad – we all do our best, whatever age. And all ages have their advantages too I think.

Hi Chewy 14
“i bet you and your daughters get mistaken for sisters all the time don’t you?”
Yeah we do sometimes but what’s always happened more is that my mum (who was 53 when the child was born) is mistaken for my daughter’s mother. I think it’s interesting that that’s the more common mistake.

FC said :

How about women keep trying to convince themselves that the whole purpose of their existance isn’t to be attractive for men.
Get a clue about how much pressure there is in this society for women to be slim, Addison, for women to try and fit into some unrealised mould of what they ‘should’ look like.
And then comment that we are just trying to convince ourselves that fat is attractive.

this has nothing to do with how women think they should look to be attractive to men this is about women putting pressure on themselves. most men don’t really care that much about body shape they are more interested in women who are fun and they can laugh with. most men read magazines with cars and trucks and boats and the occasional skinny woman, women read magazines with heaps of skinny women and clothes and makeup. any women who is trying to fit themself into a mould of what they should like should look to other women not men for fault.

Nambucco Deliria4:28 pm 25 Jun 09

Danman said :

Chronicle can not be that bad, They printed a Feldons band profile this week accompanied by one of my live pictures. Touché

The trouble is, I put the Chronicle in the bin without even unwrapping it… every bweek.

Her column about turning 40 ticked me off (I think it was last year) – yes I suppose you would feel old and tired if you were parenting a 2 year-old when that particular birthday came around. I, on the other hand felt great at 40 because, having whelped in my 20’s, I was experiencing a new sense of freedom from kids who no longer needed moment-to-moment supervision.

I guess that column was well after I stopped reading her drivel. I suspect she and I are in the same age demographic, and perhaps even have children of a similar age but the similarities end there.

A column she once wrote about outsourced birthday parties made me want to vomit, as did most of the crap columns she’s written that I ever bothered to read. I guess her columns do come in handy for parking my cuppa without any worry about spilling it on something I might later want to read LOL.

I guess to me, Sonya represents a generation of women who waited till they were well passed primary breeding age to have children in order to feather their nests and live a comfortable, vacuous middle-class existence.

Oh dear. Please don’t lump all 35+ first time mothers into that particular basket.

Ah Lulu,
i bet you and your daughters get mistaken for sisters all the time don’t you?
And yes i hope your daughter goes against this recent geriatric breeding “trend” and has her children early, God knows we need more young mothers in this town.

I’m a mum in this City and I find Sonya’s column really offensive. I’m not sure why it pushes my buttons so much. I guess I feel it gives the impression that mums are fat, boring, old and REALLY middle class! Her column about turning 40 ticked me off (I think it was last year) – yes I suppose you would feel old and tired if you were parenting a 2 year-old when that particular birthday came around. I, on the other hand felt great at 40 because, having whelped in my 20’s, I was experiencing a new sense of freedom from kids who no longer needed moment-to-moment supervision. I guess to me, Sonya represents a generation of women who waited till they were well passed primary breeding age to have children in order to feather their nests and live a comfortable, vacuous middle-class existence. Good on her and all the others like her but we’re not all like that. I’m slim, fit and fun, my children are my friends and they’d certainly be embarrassed if I described an early nineties song as a current hit. I think my daughter’s generation will be the beginning of a backlash against the alarming trend toward geriatric breeding – I hope so anyway.
Mind you, I think the column is well-placed in the City News and probably suits their demographic.

Chronicle can not be that bad, They printed a Feldons band profile this week accompanied by one of my live pictures. Touché

Does this website make my butt look big?

barking toad1:40 pm 25 Jun 09

I might have left out an apostrophe and and a t FC – then I’d agree

No matter how egregiously bad the City News is, the Chronicle is much, much worse.

I think it is abou the ‘curvacious’ look being ‘in’ rather than the ‘starved’ look.
I don’t thinnk Kim Kardashian is any any way ‘fat’.
i don’t think J -Lo or any of the girls in the ‘sir mix alot’ clip either are just trying to convince themselves that ‘fat is attractive’

How about women keep trying to convince themselves that the whole purpose of their existance isn’t to be attractive for men.
Get a clue about how much pressure there is in this society for women to be slim, Addison, for women to try and fit into some unrealised mould of what they ‘should’ look like.
And then comment that we are just trying to convince ourselves that fat is attractive.

barking toad1:31 pm 25 Jun 09

#19 – Maybe the Secret explains all. And #18 is right.

Lasses probably realise at midnight that blokes don’t want to discuss Proust

barking toad1:23 pm 25 Jun 09

Round midnight when the princesses appear, fat bottomed girls are sweet.

I really don’t know what this cloth-eared bint is on about

chewy14 said :

Addison said :

women keep trying to convince themselfs that fat is attractive, and guys are just happy if they get some.

Haha,

Don’t you know size 18 is the new 12?

they should keep telling themselfs that, maybe it will come true. women shouldn’t be skinny stick insects, but fat is fat.

Addison said :

women keep trying to convince themselfs that fat is attractive, and guys are just happy if they get some.

Haha,

Don’t you know size 18 is the new 12?

Secret Squirrel12:19 pm 25 Jun 09

I know Sonya, and she WISHES fat bottoms were “in”!!!

women keep trying to convince themselfs that fat is attractive, and guys are just happy if they get some.

rosebud said :

This song is good, but my favourite is Spinal Tap’s: Big Bottom.

“Big bottom, big bottom
Talking ’bout bum cakes
MY BABY”S GOT ‘EM!”

(to heavy metal screaming)

Haha anything from Spinal Tap is enough to put a grin on my face.

“The bigger the cushion the sweeter the pushin'”

neanderthalsis11:55 am 25 Jun 09

City news covering the big issues (bad pun intended).

I’m sure rising levels of obesity will be welcomed by those with a fetish for posteriors that are three pick handles across.

I was particularly surprised by this week’s effort by Sonya Fladun

I am never particularly surprised by any of Sonya Fladun’s columns.

Or at least the ones I read before deciding that the “Mum in the City” columns were such predictably pathetically cliched takes on parenthood that I should just ignore them.

Haha. I love singing that song on sing star!!

Primal said :

“My anaconda don’t want none unless you got buns, hon.”

I think there’s something in that for all of us.

(disclaimer: I have ‘Baby Got Back’ on my iPod. By choice!)

Me too!

It’s one of the best songs ever.

“My anaconda don’t want none unless you got buns, hon.”

I think there’s something in that for all of us.

(disclaimer: I have ‘Baby Got Back’ on my iPod. By choice!)

I wish City News would change the paper they use – that shiny stuff just smears it around whenever I wipe with it.

At least bring it 15 years into the future with Mika’s 2007 “Big Girls (You Are Beatiful)”

You take your skinny girl
I feel like I’m gonna die
‘Cause a real woman
Needs a real man, here’s why

You take your girl
And multiply her by four
Now a whole lotta woman
Needs a whole lot more!

Just look at the size of Kim Kardashian’s butt. HUGE! and hot.

why not regurgitate Queen’s song – fat bottom girls – to boot (!)

Hells_Bells7411:10 am 25 Jun 09

fnaah said :

An eminently more suitable song would be Queen’s “Fat Bottomed Girls”.

Was totally thinking myself how’d they leave that one out

Hells_Bells7411:08 am 25 Jun 09

Woohoo Rosebud – nothing like some heavy metal morning glory! 🙂

An eminently more suitable song would be Queen’s “Fat Bottomed Girls”.

This song is good, but my favourite is Spinal Tap’s: Big Bottom.

“Big bottom, big bottom
Talking ’bout bum cakes
MY BABY”S GOT ‘EM!”

(to heavy metal screaming)

If you thought the Canberra Times was awesome, wait until you read the articles in City News.

Ahhhhhh, now you’ve got that song in my head. get it out get it out.

“some punks like to hit and quit it, but i’d rather stay and play……

Clown Killer10:22 am 25 Jun 09

I’m not sure what disturbs me most about this – the confected story used as segue to Sonya’s admission to the trying on of rubberised granny pants or the fact that City News has an on-line presence… both are trying too hard.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.