IGA owner fears for Yarralumla shops if rival liquor store goes ahead next door

Ian Bushnell 9 May 2019 35

Yvonne Dourdoulakis outside the premises next door to the IGA Supermarket, where a Jim Murphy Cellars liquor store is planned. Photos: George Tsostsos.

Jim Murphy Cellars’ bid to open a liquor store at the Yarralumla Shops is hard to swallow for IGA/Local Liquor Supermarket owner Yvonne Dourdoulakis, not just because she will have a rival next door but because she fears for the future of the struggling suburban shopping centre.

Jim Murphy Cellars has applied to ACT Liquor for an off premises liquor licence for 25 Bentham Street, which used to house the post office until it closed in March. It plans to operate every day from 7 am to 11 pm.

Ms Dourdoulakis, who with her husband has run the IGA since 2004, says if the licence was granted it could see the beginning of the end for the Yarralumla Shops, which has seen a number of businesses close in recent times and needs new ventures to complement the ones already there.

“I obviously don’t want a liquor store next to me but I’m looking at the big picture of what makes local shopping centres survive,” said the businesswoman, who also owns with her siblings many of the properties at the Ainslie Shops.

“We are firm believers that the shops within shopping centres need to complement each other, not fight against each other, that’s when you get closures. They’re meant to be businesses that work well together.”

She says local residents and other businesses also don’t want another liquor store there but would prefer something like a bakery, which the centre lost a couple of years ago.

They are also concerned about the impact a liquor store opening until late at night will have on crime and behaviour in the community, which already has a high rate of break-ins and robberies.

As well as the Local Liquor outlet, there are already three on-premises liquor licences at restaurants in the centre, and another liquor store would be too many.

“How many liquor licences do you really need in one centre?” Ms Dourdoulakis said. “It’s a very small shopping centre.”

The Yarralumla IGA includes a large Local Liquor outlet.

She had told the owner of the premises that she would be willing to take the lease and sub-let it to a business to ensure a right fit for the shops but he was confident of being granted the licence.

“I know a number of submissions, by residents and other businesses owners, have been sent to ACT Liquor opposing the granting of the liquor license, but I’m also afraid they may not be taken into full consideration before a decision is made,” Ms Dourdoulakis said.

Yarralumla Residents Association president Mike Lewis said the community organisation did not have a position on the application but members had lodged objections as individuals.

The Association had been concerned for some time at the number of empty premises at the shops and Mr Lewis said the Government should consider penalties for landlords sitting on tenancies, similar to those used to deter land banking.

Ms Dourdoulakis operated the post office business for eight years before selling it in 2014, and has just completed a $100,000 refurbishment to take it back to serve the Yarralumla community.

“It was a headache I didn’t really want but it needed to be done,” she said.

She feared there would be more shops closing in Yarralumla. “To see local shopping centres falling apart is quite a sad thing,” she said.

The key issues contributing to their decline were high commercial rates and rents. Some landowners were also happy to leave premises empty if they could not achieve the rents they wanted.

The consultation period for the application closes on 15 May. For more information go here.

What's Your Opinion?

Please login to post your comments, or connect with
35 Responses to IGA owner fears for Yarralumla shops if rival liquor store goes ahead next door
Jp Romano Jp Romano 10:19 am 12 May 19

Listen to all these anti capitalists. Business is business, if a business sees potential to make money then let them try!

maxblues maxblues 2:08 pm 11 May 19

The ACT is just about the only jurisdiction in Australia that permits off-licence premises to set up in close proximity. Certainly highly regulated in Qld, NSW and SA. Not sure about current set up in Victoria (they went a bit crazy during the cleanskin wine ‘bubble’).

bronal bronal 11:50 am 11 May 19

Surely people realise that the profit from liquor sales helps to subsidise grocery sales? I wonder why Jim Murphy’s didn’t lease the old bakery. It is much larger than the old post office and could therefore stock a wide range. As far as parking is concerned, it has always been difficult at Yarralumla and I don’t see any easy answers as there is residential development all around the shops.

Ana Ryna Ana Ryna 7:16 am 11 May 19

They would all get more customers if there was somewhere to park ...

Amber Jarrett Amber Jarrett 5:04 am 11 May 19

IGA- update your bakery section if that is a need of the community. Pretty obvious business opportunity.

    Lucian Burca Lucian Burca 10:48 pm 11 May 19

    Pfff, pretty hard to keep everyone happy around there, as there is so much room the shop has (pretty small local supermarket, if you visit it). I've done some work there, and Yvonne is really trying hard to keep the community happy as they recently made arrangements to keep the local post office alive, instead of caring just for her business and let the Yarralumla community without postal services within their local shops. Please visit them and check what's going on over there please.

Amber Jarrett Amber Jarrett 5:00 am 11 May 19

A kebab and nice beer will be a great combo👌

Bronwyn Meredith Bronwyn Meredith 11:02 pm 10 May 19

The IGA offers a great range of food. I'd prefer it to stay than to see it gone because of a liquor store.

Timothy Hughes Timothy Hughes 10:30 pm 10 May 19

Competition is healthy for the consumers! How would another shop selling alcohol result in the end of the shops? Just because the lady can’t charge 30% more for grog is it the end of the world?

Ainge Sakthivel Ainge Sakthivel 9:55 pm 10 May 19

they need to expand the kebab shop. That's what everyone outside yarralumla comes for. Best kebabs in Canberra

Scott Humphries Scott Humphries 8:59 pm 10 May 19

The IGA has a great deli and grocery selection. Their fresh food offering is pretty poor. But overall they should be able to withstand some competition.

Murray Emerton Murray Emerton 8:47 pm 10 May 19

Competition! Get over it

    Narrelle Kelly Narrelle Kelly 9:18 pm 10 May 19

    Murray Emerton exactly- let the best man win- we poor work slaves have to do it why is it different for small businesses

    Lucian Burca Lucian Burca 10:57 pm 11 May 19

    Yep, smart move, take out IGA and replace it with liquor shop, I bet everyone is going to be happy in the area, having to travel more for groceries, and just across the corner for booze... great ideas, let's make Australia great again!!!

    Mat Farrington Mat Farrington 11:00 am 13 May 19

    Campbell Liquor Discounts had an IGA open nextdoor. The IGA won. The liquor store couldn't compete. I fancy the IGA's chances.

HiddenDragon HiddenDragon 6:40 pm 10 May 19

“She feared there would be more shops closing in Yarralumla. “To see local shopping centres falling apart is quite a sad thing,” she said.”

Without getting into the merits of this particular case, a government which actually meant what it says when it talks about “active transport” would be doing all it reasonably could to make local shopping centres as attractive and useful as possible for people in the surrounding area – and there is much more to that than the occasional squirt of funding for a bit of landscaping, street sculpture etc.

bj_ACT bj_ACT 6:23 pm 10 May 19

It’s very important to keep small local shops viable. Kambah lost shops at Springbett as well as Livingstone ave (plus Marconi far from its former glory).

ACT government gives grants to many businesses in the centre of town but hits outer suburban shops with increasing Rates bills that are making them uneconomical to do business.

Richardson shops are another recent death. Big support for Google drones, no support for Joe Schmidt living out of a tiny suburban supermarket.

Sharon Hunter Sharon Hunter 3:41 pm 10 May 19

What happened to the bakery?

    Scott Humphries Scott Humphries 8:57 pm 10 May 19

    Closed a few years ago due to rent increases. Also the newsagency and Thai restaurant.

    Sharon Hunter Sharon Hunter 9:06 pm 10 May 19

    Scott Humphries


    Thank you

Capital Retro Capital Retro 3:32 pm 10 May 19

I’m buying all my beer, wines and spirits on line these days. The range of product is almost infinite, the delivery is to my front door (and it very fast) and most of all it is a lot cheaper.

It sort of makes up for the punishment we are getting from the high costs of other things in Canberra, including government

When I moved to Canberra 35 years ago, owning a local grog shop was a license to print money (like a newsagent, F&V shop etc.)

Michael Groenhout Michael Groenhout 1:56 pm 10 May 19

IGA have great liquor purchasing power. Look at your margins and remain competitive

Blen_Carmichael Blen_Carmichael 1:51 pm 10 May 19

“We are firm believers that the shops within shopping centres need to complement each other, not fight against each other, that’s when you get closures.” Perhaps the IGA should surrender its liquor licence, then? Supermarket sells grocerices, liquor store sells liquor. They complement each other perfectly. Problem solved.

Widya Santoso Widya Santoso 12:16 pm 10 May 19

There's already a second liquor shop down the road, near the library, and one further up, at the Kingston hotel.

bronal bronal 11:49 am 10 May 19

At what stage does a local supermarket become a community asset? Well, we’ll soon find out in Monash because our supermarket closed two days ago. Lord knows what the residents of the Goodwin retirement village will do now. I believe in competition as much as anyone else but, like free speech, it has its limits. The knock-on effect must always be taken into account. My doctor is at Yarralumla and I always do a shop at the supermarket afterwards to get brands and items that aren’t available at Woolies or Coles. I hope the application fails and that Yarralumla retains its current atmosphere.

charlie1 charlie1 11:46 am 10 May 19

Local shopping centres need a variety of shops in a small complex, not one’s that compete with other businesses. I would prefer to support a local business not a national company.

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site