30 September 2024

Inquiry criticised for ‘pitiful’ recommendations to tackle Indian Myna threat to Canberra's native birds

| Oliver Jacques
Join the conversation
16
Indian Myna on a branch

Conservationists have suggested the ACT Government isn’t taking the threat of Indian Myna seriously. Photo: Supplied.

A Legislative Assembly committee has been criticised for its “pitiful” and “weak” recommendations in its inquiry aimed at combating a pest that may threaten the existence of several native bird species.

Indian (Common) Myna are small birds with brown bodies, black hooded heads and a yellow patch behind the eye. Originating in Asia, mynas arrived in Canberra in 1968 when a newcomer from Sydney released a dozen birds because he missed hearing their call.

It is estimated that there are some 250 Indian mynas per square kilometre in the urban area of Canberra, or about 150,000 birds in total.

The ACT Conservation Council told the inquiry: “The birds are territorial and aggressive, killing the chicks of native birds, destroying their eggs, and pushing them out of nesting hollows.”

Bill Handke, president of the volunteer-based Canberra Indian Myna Action Group (CIMAG), argued that mynas have driven native birds out of Sydney and Melbourne and that the same could happen in Canberra if more action isn’t taken.

But the Committee on Environment, Climate Change, and Biodiversity, chaired by Labor MLA Marisa Paterson, noted ACT Government research “indicated that the impacts on threatened hollow-nesting species is negligible”.

READ ALSO Ex-newsreader ‘Robbo’ on 1980s fame, the Jolimont Siege, the Raiders’ heyday and post-celebrity life

The Committee’s final report, released this week, did not make any concrete recommendations for action, only stating that government should recognise CIMAG’s work in controlling Myna numbers and continue to monitor the issue.

“I had a quick look at the inquiry final report but was too depressed to go on … it was pitiful,” veteran Canberra naturalist Ian Fraser said.

“I’d have to say this government is the least environmentally concerned of any government since self-government … it’s a fairly old playbook they’re using, saying we have no evidence of the problem and then say then when we have a problem, they’ll say it’s too late.

“Government needs to start taking a proactive role; it presumes CIMAG are always going to be there; they assume work being done for free will always be done. The government has no right to expect a community group will always do their work for nothing.”

Simon Copland, director of the Conservation Council ACT, also expressed disappointment at the Committee’s “weak” recommendations.

“Observations by the community both in the ACT and elsewhere in Australia have shown the Indian Mynas gradually displace many native birds, but when mynas are removed, the natives return,” Mr Copland said.

“There are many places along the Eastern Seaboard bereft of native birds because of the impact of Indian Mynas and we do not want this to happen in the ACT.”

Group photo in forrest

Simon Copland (centre) and his staff at the ACT Conservation Council want government to do more. Photo: Facebook.

The council said other jurisdictions, predominately local councils, provide financial and other support to community-based Indian Myna control programs, but the ACT Government does not.

Mr Copeland suggested the ACT Government could step in to trap mynas on government-controlled land and consider incentives for commercial and public buildings to include exclusion barriers to exclude Indian Mynas nesting in roof cavities.

READ ALSO Four-storey apartments to replace Lyneham home sites

The Conservation Council noted that to date, Indian Myna control has been exclusively undertaken by the community on private property, even though these birds also live and proliferate on public land.

“That’s where government can step in, looking at shopping centres and so on,” Mr Fraser said.

The Indian Myna inquiry final report can be found on the ACT Legislative Assembly website.

Join the conversation

16
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

I have enjoyed our bird life in my yard. Parrots, honeyeaters, bow birds plus others. Then this week as much as I hate getting them to be terminated the Indian Minors have returned & it is sad to see. Plus the kangaroos well no longer see them. Possums I love & have boxes for them. So please can this government or next one work seriously on the Indian Minors being terminated. PLEASE encourage & admire our wonderful wildlife & the beautiful birdlife. I even had a pair of Swift Parrots have water in my yard knowing they are on their way across the Bass Straight to breed.

I’ve dispatched around 40 of them in my backyard over the last couple of years but it is a drop in the ocean compared to the numbers I see in public places.

“Canberra naturalist Ian Fraser: “I’d have to say this government is the least environmentally concerned of any government since self-government … ”
That is a damning statement, which should make all Greens voters think. But probably won’t.
Consider also the:
. kangaroo cull removing most roos off Red Hill (spot one now if you’re lucky)
. reduced Canberra tree canopy
. smaller gardens and less shade from infill densification
. cost of living impact on families from excessively rising rates
. slower traffic flow because of tramworks
. housing unafffordability

The Greens – once a community focussed conservation party. Now just progressively hypocritical.

This Government is useless. Make them aware of a problem and they turn it over to an inquiry who then makes it go away by ignoring it.

wildturkeycanoe5:21 pm 30 Sep 24

I’ve done my bit, just eradicated a dozen in last 2 days. We need to promote more backyard trapping, otherwise it’s a losing battle.

Can you let me know where you got the trap from? I’ve contacted the Action Group but haven’t heard back (noting they’ve no doubt had a busy week with the Committee report). The damn myna birds are destroying our garden in Crace

Julie Lindner4:01 pm 30 Sep 24

Isn’t it strange that the Government is all for slaughtering our native kangaroos at a cost of $800,000 per year and go soft and unhelpful when acting against an invasive species.

Driving us crazy in Belconnen. Small nests litter the streets. Dawn chorus of fights. And yet, you ban outdoor cats. Now I also have rats. I don’t have a cat btw.

Wright stuff7:20 am 30 Sep 24

Has the government not heard of the Precautionary Principle? The approach taken in the enquiry report is beyond disappointing 😢

There’s an endemic population at the Fyshwick markets, been there years now, but I still don’t know what number to call to get them, uh, well, exterminated.

And they’re that invasive, they’re also at that population density there that they’ll spread out… They need management.

So many people have seen them, and nobody has done anything.

Well past time they had the necessary done, though.

I am not certain the Tram will fix it. You could send the ones in Civic to Gungahlin but someone would need to go with them. Mynas cannot travel on trams unaccompanied.

These are birds that we should legally be able to kill.

William Teach9:14 pm 01 Oct 24

Any non-native animal not restrained on private land (with the landholder’s permission, of course), inside a building or vehicle (again, with permission), or on a leash should be classed as vermin, able to be killed without restriction.

richard stone3:46 pm 29 Sep 24

Myna birds are endemic in Fadden – they have exterminated the once prolific native small bird life in my garden. Moreover, on my daily walks around this suburb, I no longer see small native bird life anywhere.
Myna birds have no fear of larger native birds here – the Mynas attack them in packs.

I’ve seen them attack smaller birds way too often.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.