24 June 2013

Liberals ask where the light rail beef is?

| johnboy
Join the conversation
14

Alistair Coe is asking pointed questions of just where Simon Corbell’s grand light rail visions are coming to and from:

After questioning from Deputy Opposition Leader Alistair Coe, Simon Corbell has again refused to provide documents relating to the massive light rail project.

“Today in Estimates, Simon Corbell refused to release documents he claims to have about light rail, even though he uses the documents to justify the project,” Mr Coe said today.

“To date, we have seen not one engineers’ report, not one business study, not one cost benefit analysis. However, on Friday last week, Simon Corbell claimed that such documents do exist but they have not been released to the public.”

“Treasurer Andrew Barr has already admitted ACT Labor will proceed with light rail ‘at any cost.’ Meanwhile, the Canberra Liberals have been calling for proper studies to be conducted and released.

“It is simply unacceptable that Simon Corbell and ACT Labor are rushing into a project that will cost hundreds of millions of dollars in upfront costs and unknown millions in on-going costs without revealing these studies to the public,” Mr Coe concluded.

Join the conversation

14
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

2604 said :

Bugle said :

I wish we had light rail. I catch the red rapid busses to work and they are often packed full. It can reach the point where it takes five minutes at some stops for people to get off and on. I can see why people drive. Light rail would pretty much end that.

We could add more buses for about 100th of the cost.

Firstly, busses cost around $500,000 each the trams cost about $5 million each, so that is about 10% But for that price you get something that had much more passenger capacity and can load passengers much more quickly.

Tracks cost money, but so do road works. It isn’t uncommon to spend a few tens if not hundreds of millions on roadworks.

Felix the Cat said :

Article on ABC website suggests it will cost around $200M just to move utilities along the route and it will cost around $7M per year to run. There are a few other interesting cost figures there too.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-06-25/canberra-light-rail-costs-mapped-out/4777632

I don’t get why they would be moving so many utilities. Can’t lay the tracks down the islands between Gungahlin and Civic? My understanding is that the utilities down the sides of the roads.

But they have budgeted $27 million for each station! Trams don’t need stations, they can use glorified bus shelters.

This is why we can’t have good things.Instead of spending money wisely, the government wastes money on unnecessarily over engineering certain parts of the infrastructure.

thebrownstreak691:24 pm 25 Jun 13

knuckles said :

beardedclam said :

farout said :

2604 said :

We could add more buses for about 100th of the cost.

yeah thats just what we need. More buses on the road in peak hour. Think bigger people, environment, well being, I am sure a vehicle set on a fixed track would be safer than having people in control of free moving buses on the road.

Sydney commenced building their rail network in 1855 with a population of approx. 40,000. Imagine if they had said cars are the way of the future and all we will ever need.

This isn’t just about us. It’s also about Canberra’s future residents.

If they said thar cars are all we need back in 1855 I would have been very impressed.

Just keep throwing up the houses in West Belconnen, they are so affordable they don’t need light rail.

I have a lot of trouble reconciling the idea of light rail in my head.

What I think we really need is medium rail, running not down Northborne, but between the town centres along routes which pass over/under the main road without effecting their traffic. Then we also need stops in between the town centres with big arse car parks so people can genuinely park and ride if they can’t get a reasonable bus from their house to a town centre.

The only part of my plan to seems to be hard would be somehow putting a spur line which goes past the city centre – but running along parks way should be possible, and it could go past the airport then too.

Or maybe a loop arrangement?

beardedclam said :

farout said :

2604 said :

We could add more buses for about 100th of the cost.

yeah thats just what we need. More buses on the road in peak hour. Think bigger people, environment, well being, I am sure a vehicle set on a fixed track would be safer than having people in control of free moving buses on the road.

Sydney commenced building their rail network in 1855 with a population of approx. 40,000. Imagine if they had said cars are the way of the future and all we will ever need.

This isn’t just about us. It’s also about Canberra’s future residents.

Felix the Cat10:08 am 25 Jun 13

Article on ABC website suggests it will cost around $200M just to move utilities along the route and it will cost around $7M per year to run. There are a few other interesting cost figures there too.

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-06-25/canberra-light-rail-costs-mapped-out/4777632

farout said :

2604 said :

We could add more buses for about 100th of the cost.

More buses during peak hour and smaller mini-buses or vans during off-peak, is what I say.
In the afternoons or late evenings, the buses running past my house are almost empty. Surely with all the data Action is gathering from its MyWay system, it can work out which routes / times only need a mini-bus or van, and which peak hour services need more buses thrown on.

yeah thats just what we need. More buses on the road in peak hour. Think bigger people, environment, well being, I am sure a vehicle set on a fixed track would be safer than having people in control of free moving buses on the road.

Has no one considered running a skywhale shuttle down Northbourne?

2604 said :

We could add more buses for about 100th of the cost.

More buses during peak hour and smaller mini-buses or vans during off-peak, is what I say.
In the afternoons or late evenings, the buses running past my house are almost empty. Surely with all the data Action is gathering from its MyWay system, it can work out which routes / times only need a mini-bus or van, and which peak hour services need more buses thrown on.

wildturkeycanoe5:51 am 25 Jun 13

2604 said :

Bugle said :

I wish we had light rail. I catch the red rapid busses to work and they are often packed full. It can reach the point where it takes five minutes at some stops for people to get off and on. I can see why people drive. Light rail would pretty much end that.

We could add more buses for about 100th of the cost.

If there was another bus right behind the one taking 5 minutes to load, unless you are one of the lucky ones getting on the first bus, you still have to wait for the second or third bus, so it wouldn’t be a great deal quicker. Then when you get to the end stop, the first bus is holding up the ones behind, unless the platforms are made longer.
No light rail, how about a subway, or skytrain to match the skywhale’s “out there” philosophy?

Sorry, should have typed “1/100th”.

Bugle said :

I wish we had light rail. I catch the red rapid busses to work and they are often packed full. It can reach the point where it takes five minutes at some stops for people to get off and on. I can see why people drive. Light rail would pretty much end that.

We could add more buses for about 100th of the cost.

As soon as you mention light you lose half the audience.
How many people drink lite beer?
No light rail I want full cream rail.

There are 2 answers to what is happening with light rail:

1. Nothing is happening and everyone is stalling.
2. Things are happening but its awesomely slow and awesomely more expensive and giving out any information will mean that its a deadline they have to stick to and no doubt they’re planning to fall behind.

It’d be cost effective to outsource the toot toot now.

I wish we had light rail. I catch the red rapid busses to work and they are often packed full. It can reach the point where it takes five minutes at some stops for people to get off and on. I can see why people drive. Light rail would pretty much end that.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.