9 August 2024

Universities warn of massive job losses if international student cap introduced

| Chris Johnson
Join the conversation
10
Foreign students at the University of Canberra.

Universities Australia says 14,000 jobs could be lost in the sector if international student enrolments are capped. Photo: Supplied, University of Canberra.

Australia’s universities have warned that 14,000 jobs could be lost to the sector if the Federal Government goes ahead with its plan to cap the international student intake.

The Education Services for Overseas Students Amendment (Quality and Integrity) Bill 2024 seeks to cap the number of international student enrolments for universities across the country for two years from next year.

But Universities Australia chief executive Luke Sheehy has told a Senate inquiry the Bill was a “political smokescreen” to help Labor get the upper hand in the “poll-driven battle over migration” while the Coalition blamed the housing crisis on immigrant students.

Mr Sheehy said if the legislation was successful it would lead to 14,000 job cuts across Australian universities and have a wider impact on the economy.

“The impact of having 60,000 fewer international students arrive on our shores is significant,” Mr Sheehy told senators.

“It would represent a $4.3 billion hit to the economy and could cost the university sector alone over 14,000 jobs – not to mention the flow-on effect for small businesses which rely heavily on international students.

“No other major export industry is treated the way international education is right now. Not mining, not agriculture, not tourism. None of them.”

The government seems set on implementing the cap from 1 January, but has not finalised the limit to be imposed.

It has dismissed reports there might be a 40 per cent cap.

Mr Sheehy said the number of student visas being granted had already dropped by almost 23 per cent over the past year and that trend should not be allowed to continue.

He said the government should stop “taking a sledgehammer” to the international education sector.

“Using students as cannon fodder in a poll-driven battle over migration and housing simply doesn’t add up,” he said.

“The danger of using these talented people as scapegoats to blame the housing crisis on is what we stand to lose by telling them to stay home.”

In a subsequent media interview, Mr Sheehy said he wanted to protect as many higher education jobs as possible.

Universities Australia calculated the 14,000 jobs lost figure on the current visa and visa processing changes introduced by the Federal Government in December last year under a controversial Ministerial Direction.

“What we’re seeing with Ministerial Direction 107 is chaos in the visa processing system and 60,000 fewer higher education international student visas issued in the last year alone,” Mr Sheehy said. “On our calculations, with four international students supporting one higher education job, 14,000 jobs could be at risk.

“We don’t want to see any jobs lost in higher education because it’s such an important part of Australia’s economy, and teaching students and delivering the research that we do is so important for our economic and social success.

“We are making the case to the Treasurer, to the Prime Minister and his ministers not to undermine this sector unnecessarily because it’s delivering economic growth for Australia.

“There’s an interdependency… not just with our sector, but other sectors that rely on international students and their families coming to Australia – like tourism and hospitality.”

READ ALSO Scientists’ call to urgent action sows seeds of hope to save Australian landscapes

According to Department of Home Affairs data, 376,731 student visas were granted in the financial year to 30 June this year.

Greens higher education spokesperson Mehreen Farqui, who sits on the Senate committee examining the impact of the government’s Bill, said it was time Labor listened to the sector.

“Almost all of the submissions to the inquiry into this terrible Bill don’t support it, raising significant concerns that the Bill will cause major and long-lasting damage to Australia’s higher education sector,” Senator Farqui said.

“This is clearly a migration policy disguised as an education policy. Labor is crushing universities in a bid to look tough on borders and compete with the Liberals on cruelty.

“Using international students as cash cows and then scapegoats for the Labor government’s failure to provide affordable housing is pure racist dog whistling which targets and harms international students and migrants.

“Not only are these caps damaging to Australia’s reputation as a destination for international students, they are also a direct attack on the fundamental principles of student choice and university independence.”

Join the conversation

10
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

I understand the reasoning behind it but feel that the shortcomings are not great.

Firstly education is one of Australia’s biggest export earners.

Secondly, universities sadly get more funding per student for an international student than for a local one. That disparity would need to be made up for. That involves taxpayer dollars.

The debate needs to be looked in broader terms than housing availability. It comes back to the level of university funding. Universities want international students because they receive insufficient funding from the govt. International students are an easy cash cow and help make up the deficit. I was at ANU when international students started mushrooming under the Coalition govt. Many were not serious students and academic standards dropped to accommodate them.

No one should care about GDP regardless of how many times lobbyists and politicians try to push it. What matters more is PPP GDP per capita. Getting rid of these economic migrants masquerading as students will if anything help GDP per capita, which has been negative for the past year. Australian labor can and absolutely should be redirected from “teaching international students” to a number of more important and productive national endeavors.

William Teach11:39 am 14 Aug 24

And GNI is more important than GDP too – GDP is how much wealth we’re creating, GNI is how much we’re getting. Then there’s just the question of how that’s distributed, since if it all goes to a few billionaires that doesn’t help the rest of us much.

Amanda Kiley12:47 pm 10 Aug 24

This will devastate universities – our current government has absolutely no idea – they are reactive without thinking of the consequences beyond a few weeks.

According to Mr Abdul Rivzki, the former Deputy Secretary of the Department of Immigration, a student visa has become a low skilled work visa.

The government is trying to return the student visa system back to the original intention of the old student visa system, that is a system of real students coming to Australia to study, not to work.

There would be ways around that surely? Capping the hours an overseas student can work and/or how much they can earn per week might help.

Limiting the % of overseas students a business could hire might be another way. There would have to be a way to share those hours out. For instance you can’t limit the number of staff to 50% and have that 50% doing 80% of the paid working hours.

@purplevh
“Capping the hours an overseas student can work and/or how much they can earn per week might help”
Unfortunately, while your proposals sound good in theory, they fail in practice because of the unscrupulous employers who are more than happy to engage cheap “off the books” labour to circumvent any regulatory controls.

William Teach11:36 am 14 Aug 24

We need much stricter enforcement for employers of illegal workers. Ideally we’d say that any revenue, directly or indirectly, from the labour of a person working outside their legal hours (excess hours for students, too late for children, etc.), are proceeds of crime.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.