When is gentrifying your Canberra neighbourhood a good idea?

Zoya Patel 16 March 2021 45
Braddon

Braddon has been transformed from a working-class suburb to a hipster’s paradise. Photo: File.

As a bleeding heart leftie, it’s fair to say I’ve spent my share of time on the soapbox espousing the evils of gentrification.

Gentrification can be described as the slow sweep of the middle-class elite into urban areas that have been made cool by the edgy reality of ordinary working communities. They’re drawn to the area by the promise of a unique and vibrant culture that has been built out of the grassroots evolution of a community; and then, once happily ensconced in the suburb, they use their economic and political capital to gradually price the original residents out of the area.

Braddon is a good example of this.

Once the stomping ground of revheads and the working man, and the occasional hipster who made it far enough up Lonsdale St to get to the few fashion stores right up the top end – it’s now a bourgeois home to overpriced coffee and cramped apartments that are rented at ridiculous amounts to the yuppie tenant who likes the vibe there.

(I would know. I was myself a yuppie tenant living on Lonsdale St, buying my fresh ground coffee from Barrio and almond croissants from Sonoma.)


READ ALSO: Flat out with flat whites – first Haig Park market a huge success


As an economic mechanism, gentrification is damaging to communities and relies on market pressures to keep cycling new people with more money into areas deemed to have land value but the wrong type of resident.

But the flip side of that is that more infrastructure spending follows, and amenities are upgraded according to the expectations of the new middle-class community that wants things to be a certain way.

And having now moved my yuppie/hipster self further north, I can’t help but wonder if a little gentrification might be exactly what Dickson shops needs.

Just across the road from the shopping complex, the main drag of restaurants and cafes in Dickson seems to have escaped the tawdry reality of their neighbours. There are clean pavements and a smorgasbord of places to eat and drink.

It’s pleasant enough and retains the area’s reputation as the heart of Canberra’s Asian dining, but the shops seem to be getting grimier and less welcoming with every passing year.

Like most inner north residents, I’m faced with the weekly dilemma of either spending way too much buying my groceries from IGAs, navigating the hell that is the Canberra Centre to access Coles and Aldi, or doing the dreaded trip to Dickson Woolies.

Despite my better instincts, I usually succumb to the geographic convenience of Dickson and brave the Woolies, even though I am yet to ever leave the place feeling anything other than frazzled and stressed.


READ ALSO: Denser Canberra in danger of leaving communities behind


The dingy exterior of the shopping centre, with its weird orientation and little alleyways filled with scraps of human detritus, combined with the annoyingly jammed carpark, the uneven pavements, and the sheer disconnect between the size of the supermarket versus the huge number of people in the surrounding regions, fills me with dread.

Two friends on recent occasions have told me stories of being heckled in the car park of Dickson Woolies. One copped a racist slur. Another, who was there with her girlfriend, had to endure homophobic taunts (both times by people who appeared to be sleeping rough or at least loitering in the area, seemingly vagrants).

Don’t get me wrong – I don’t want Dickson shops to become another glossy, inaccessible, overpriced precinct, or to lose the important amenities of the library, local retailers, and the longstanding cafes that have been in the courtyard for eons. Public areas are for all people, and that absolutely includes the poor, homeless and suffering who may come to Dickson to access shops and health professionals, and the bustle of community.

But I also want vulnerable members of our community to be able to easily access the resources they need, and it stands to reason that this could be more easily achieved if the space was given a bit of a spruce up. A rearranging of the infrastructure to make it less dark and creepy and more open and inviting, a bus stop that was closer than the interchange perhaps, and obviously a massive improvement to the Woolies or the addition of a Coles that we’ve been waiting for now for years would all help.

Why has this public area been left to languish for so long and what will it take for the breeze of gentrification – as problematic as it can be – to unleash at Dickson shops?


What's Your Opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
45 Responses to When is gentrifying your Canberra neighbourhood a good idea?
Michael Ilsley Michael Ilsley 5:20 pm 24 Mar 21

Dickson and manuka are both desperate for a serious redevelopment

jorie1 jorie1 11:20 am 20 Mar 21

I really don’t understand the point of this article. Sounds like the author is saying she wants Dickson to be more fancy and upscale, but then feels guilty liking fancy things as she says she is a woke left wing person. But then judges homeless people. Very odd indeed.

Natalia Rose Natalia Rose 9:27 am 20 Mar 21

Why is it that middle class so called Canberra lefties can never ever acknowledge their own class privilege? Sis just say you hate homeless and poor people. I don’t care if your a person of Color, there’s nuances to privilege and it’s time Canberra acknowledged it.

Tim Rutherford Tim Rutherford 3:18 pm 19 Mar 21

Dickson can keep waiting and complaining, Molonglo valley needs a new coles and woolworths asap.

Philippa Nitsche Philippa Nitsche 4:38 am 19 Mar 21

David Collins

mickos mickos 3:52 am 19 Mar 21

Keek what a disgusting comment I suppose you think that poor people are too dumb to use the internet ,well obviously not, What all the ignorant ‘upper middle class’people don’t understand is the poor people you all despise stay in Canberra because you can do virtually anything without consequence here the whole system encourages criminality and other poor people who live in public housing are not allowed to transfer to NSW if they find a job elsewhere, so thanx to the governments who keep the long term unemployed trapped in Canberra no wonder the place is a toxic production line of mental illness. Then we see well meaning affluent people who hand cash to vagrants in Dickson, thinking the person will buy food, yeah right all these junkies want is another shot of heroin and people still keep giving it’s typical no wonder the mental health system is completely stuffed.

Emily Grace Emily Grace 2:36 am 19 Mar 21

As someone who has had Dickson as their "local" for their entire life, this is not what Dickson needs. What is does need is:

- homeless service

- mental health services

- drug and alcohol service

- more frequent police presence

Just my opinion.

    Rachel Jay Rachel Jay 12:25 am 20 Mar 21

    Emily Grace I agree except the extra police presence, dickson has also been my local for nearly the entirety of my life too 😅

pdpd pdpd 10:12 pm 18 Mar 21

That’s why I prefer living in the working class paradise of West Belconnen. We treat each other with respect, and if any druggies try their crazy shit in the shopping centres, car parks etc there are many a tradie about to sort the situation out and restore the peace.

Brian Beard Brian Beard 9:37 pm 18 Mar 21

How are we using the term 'Gentrification' without irony in canberra. This isnt New Orleans, no-ones knocking down the Treme to put up luxury apartments.

This is Dickson shops. peeps. Get a grip. Have private industry fund, make sure current shop owners get a cut rate on rent, and first rights on new premises. Tax the crap out of it and put the money towards mental health and at risk youth services.

HiddenDragon HiddenDragon 8:30 pm 18 Mar 21

Aside from the fairly obvious point that the problems described above are typical of inner urban areas everywhere, this article is a good summary of why many people are very happy to live in the yet-to-be-gentrified (ruined) parts of suburbia.

Howard Maclean Howard Maclean 6:49 pm 18 Mar 21

I'm definitely pro-development and urban illumination, but how keen this article is to prove its progressive anti-gentrification credentials while essentially arguing for gentrification in order to get rid of homeless people is very jarring.

    Howard Maclean Howard Maclean 6:57 pm 18 Mar 21

    Out of all the reasons to argue for urban renewal, better illumination, more housing, a more vibrant local economy, and better infrastructure, illumination and so on, the author focuses their argument around "seemingly vagrants"

    Michael Page Michael Page 8:27 pm 18 Mar 21

    As a progressive, I want to end gentrification everywhere outside a 5k radius from my house

Celie Clucas Celie Clucas 6:33 pm 18 Mar 21

Should Dickson be gentrified? Or should the ACT and Federal Governments be finding homes for people to live in and have better mental health and drug counselling services?

    Jim Jim Jim Jim 1:52 am 19 Mar 21

    Celie Clucas “drug counselling” 😂😂 how out of touch with what is going on at Dickson shops are you? Yes counselling the drug addicts there will help immensely. Seriously? How about actually removing the drug problem i.e supply so that scrubs aren’t hanging around there high or waiting to score.

    Matthew Patrick Matthew Patrick 7:10 am 19 Mar 21

    Looks like this young lady was raised right. Cris Clucas 👍🙂

    Cris Clucas Cris Clucas 9:47 am 19 Mar 21

    She is a good human. <3

Anna-Maria Sviatko Anna-Maria Sviatko 6:29 pm 18 Mar 21

'...a bus stop that was closer than the interchange perhaps': you might like to try the two on Cowper Street behind Dan Murphy's, by the Dickson pool, or the four on Antill Street: two near the corner of Cowper Street, and two by the Shell station... 😁

Levi Regan Levi Regan 6:27 pm 18 Mar 21

We don’t need Dickson gentrified. We need proper support for those who are living rough in the area. You’ve got businesses like Woolies calling in the cops to move homeless people away from their walls, what sort of support network is that?

Apart from the St Vinnies Night Patrol van I never see anyone outside of the public putting any support towards Dickson and those that call it home.

Matthew Soall Matthew Soall 2:41 pm 18 Mar 21

Dickson needs proper outreach. The mental health and health systems here in Canberra are a complete joke. I have seen numerous times people with obvious mental difficulties being taken away by either police or ambulance, not receiving the care they need, then being plopped back on the Woolworths Dickson doorstep only for the horrid cycle to repeat itself all over again.

    Geoff Pindsle Geoff Pindsle 2:59 pm 18 Mar 21

    The same as in Sydney, the streets are effectively part of the mental health system because you don't get benefits without a fixed address

    Tim Popham Tim Popham 7:39 pm 18 Mar 21

    Geoff Pindsle Even then the Sydney system is a complete joke. Months upon months wait for critical mental health services.

Penny Hemsworth Penny Hemsworth 1:16 pm 18 Mar 21

I thought all the protests going on in the world, was for equality. So what rubbish is this now?

Dylan Silke Dylan Silke 12:53 pm 18 Mar 21

Ben Silke just say you hate poor people

Suzanna Palombi Suzanna Palombi 11:44 am 18 Mar 21

Mawson shops too🤔

Jo Holburn Jo Holburn 11:34 am 18 Mar 21

Dickson shops are very daggy and unattractive

Anna Dennis Anna Dennis 11:24 am 18 Mar 21

the canberra liberal elite truly believe they're left-wing whilst simultaneously pleading for the developers to come and gentrify the dirty homeless people out of their nice suburbs

this should be satire

    Kate Klaver Kate Klaver 6:06 pm 18 Mar 21

    Couldn’t have put it better. ❤️ If only it was satire...

    Geoff Pindsle Geoff Pindsle 9:32 pm 18 Mar 21

    Can't see any other point to this article. What does business development have to do with mental health

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

 Top
Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site