Wild ideas to save St John’s orphanage

John Thistleton 17 June 2019 11
St John’s orphanage

St John’s orphanage before fire destroyed sections of its structure. Photo: Supplied.

Western Sydney developer Ammar Khan says he has a redevelopment plan including a 156-unit, four-star hotel that would finance the restoration of St John’s old orphanage in Goulburn.

Mr Khan, who attracted 2.6 per cent of the vote as an independent candidate for Chifley in 2016, says he took his plan to owner John Ferrara two years ago as well as Goulburn Mulwaree Council.

Mr Khan’s redevelopment proposal includes a five-storey and three-storey resort-style hotel built in stages, a performing arts theatre and housing. He would use profits from the hotel to restore the crumbling, fire-ravaged orphanage.

But Mr Ferrara is uninterested in Mr Khan’s plans. “It’s something different altogether. I didn’t think his plan would work. He has no money. Cash speaks a lot of languages,” he said.

Mr Ferrara’s priority is a subdivision at Goulburn Airport, which he bought in $2011 for $2.5 million. He said the orphanage redevelopment would have to wait, and ultimately it would finance his retirement.

“I am only 50. I have plenty of time,” Mr Ferrara says. “Have you got any money? You should invest some money, you can make some money,” he says. “The best I can do for St John’s is to keep the front façade. The rest has to come down.”

Mr Khan says St John’s orphanage’s early history inspired him. He could organise finance and investors in the redevelopment. “I do this sort of thing often as a developer. I could do a development application, but if the owner says thanks for a job well done but no thanks, I have just wasted $10,000-$20,000. I took it to Mr Ferrara and he said he wanted to have a retirement village there. I said OK, it is your property, I respect that.”

The Catholic Church sold St John’s orphanage to Mr Ferrara in 1999 for $450,000. Subsequently, Mr Ferrara has submitted several plans for the elevated site, including a retirement village and 76 units and homes.

St John’s orphanage artist impression

An early artist’s impression of St John’s orphanage.

On a prominent hill in a residential area, St John’s scorched and broken exterior stands like a hideous smile at the town that fed and clothed its orphan boys in a previous era.

As unlikely as Mr Khan’s proposal is, the more recent restoration of the former St Joseph’s girls’ orphanage on the outskirts of town – Goulburn Regional Conservatorium occupying the old technical college in Bourke Street – and a licenced club occupying a restored Goulburn Club on Market Street demonstrate that not only do radical plans succeed in rescuing old buildings, they are essential.

Across rural Victoria entrepreneurs, small businesses and communities are restoring an old carpet mill, rescue station for coal miners, bacon curing factory and primary school to name a few projects. All of these projects were sparked by risk-taking dreamers who showed leadership.

After reading the St John’s orphanage’s recent history and watching videos, Mr Khan says the redeveloped site could bring much benefit to Goulburn. “The other old orphanage, St Joseph’s has been turned into apartments. Great. They saved the building, but I think this has to be a youth camp, or university, or something that still serves the younger generations like it did back in the day,” he says.

“That is the building giving back to the town, not me coming in as a big, greedy developer. I am not even big for starters. That is us focusing on people who need it.”

Mr Khan’s approach to a hotel chain to become involved was unsuccessful. “They wanted to be on the highway. It doesn’t mean another operator, or a private one, could not be brought in,” he says. There is a need for these four-and-a-half-star hotels. “

Mr Khan says he would facilitate deals in which separate owners come in and take up sections of the project.

What's Your Opinion?

Please login to post your comments, or connect with
11 Responses to Wild ideas to save St John’s orphanage
BeeJay1990 BeeJay1990 3:20 pm 06 May 20

I’d love to see the site restored as much as possible with part of it turned into a museum to honour the people who actually did good service there as well as pay respect to those who attended and anyone who may have been hurt there.
Turning this site into a resort or homes seems in bad taste to me.
Perhaps that type of investment could be done on land that isn’t occupied by historically important parts of the site.
But where absolutely possible, I’d implore any developer to please be mindful of it’s spiritual and historical importance.

Tammy Marie Tammy Marie 12:38 am 25 Jun 19

Forgotten Australians should be consulted first on what should be done with this building!!!!! And no decision should be made without the involvement of those forgotten Australians who were abused in this home and other forgotten Australians!!!

Tammy Crisp Tammy Crisp 12:24 pm 21 Jun 19

It should be restored and used the trouble is we don’t have s lot of historical buildings in Australia so we should try our best to keep the ones we do have

Jason Malcolm Jason Malcolm 7:21 pm 19 Jun 19

Renetta, Lisa yay or nay?!

Sarah West Sarah West 6:08 pm 19 Jun 19

Looks haunted!

Vee Churchill Vee Churchill 5:48 pm 19 Jun 19

Emillie... we were only just talking about this

Robert Honeybone Snr Robert Honeybone Snr 1:28 pm 19 Jun 19

This would be a positive move for Goulburn Goulburn is in need of more progress

Stephen Esdaile Stephen Esdaile 1:18 pm 19 Jun 19

Why does the current owner have a say? He's deliberately let it go to ruin. Time for the council to compulsorily acquire it and get it restored with a decent development supporting it.

    Peter Bee Peter Bee 2:55 pm 19 Jun 19

    Stephen Esdaile only the state gov has compulsory acquisition powers??

    Stephen Esdaile Stephen Esdaile 4:07 pm 19 Jun 19

    That's a shame. Maybe the council should apply to do it through the courts.

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site