Skip to content Skip to main navigation

News

Excellence in Public Sector consulting

ACT Government to close off religious schools’ discrimination ‘loophole’ today

By Ian Bushnell 1 November 2018 21
Old books on a library or bookshop shelf background with copy space

The ACT Government is moving to amend the Discrimination Act today but the Catholic sector says there is no need to rush to legislate.

The ACT Government is moving to strip religious schools of the legal right to reject gay teachers and prevent them discriminating against anyone on the basis of sexuality, gender identity, race, pregnancy or intersex status, with amendments to the ACT’s Discrimination Act to be introduced to the Legislative Assembly today (1 November).

It said the ACT’s Discrimination Act would be amended to clarify exceptions for religious schools, ensuring discrimination is only allowed on the basis of religious conviction.

“The reaction to leaked elements of the Australian Government’s review of Religious Freedoms demonstrates that the Canberra community does not accept the notion that it is okay to treat people differently based on their sexuality,” Chief Minister Andrew Barr and Mental Health Minister Shane Rattenbury said in a joint statement.

“Religious schools of all faiths serve an important role and we support the valuable contribution these schools make to the diversity of our ACT community. However, it is clear that current exceptions allowing religious schools to discriminate against students and staff are out of step with community expectations.”

They said the Act as amended would still allow schools to give preference to students and employees on the basis of their religious conviction.

The reforms had been based on discrimination laws in Tasmania.

“The right to religious beliefs is absolute, but the right to demonstrate those beliefs must be subject to reasonable limitation to protect other human rights such as the right to equality, to freedom from discrimination and children’s rights to be cared for and protected during their education,” Mr Barr and Mr Rattenbury said.

“As a community we all have a role in preventing the serious harm that discrimination can cause to vulnerable young people and their families, and our valued teachers and education staff.”

The Chief Minister last week flagged the changes, describing current ACT legislation regarding religious freedoms as a “legal loophole” existing between the Discrimination Act of 1991 and the Human Rights Act 2004.

The Catholic sector said that there was no need to rush to change legislation and that it was open to dialogue.


What’s Your opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
20 Responses to
ACT Government to close off religious schools’ discrimination ‘loophole’ today
Filter
Showing only Website comments
Order
Newest to Oldest
Oldest to Newst
John Moulis 5:36 am 02 Nov 18

“Ensuring discrimination is only allowed on the basis of religious conviction”.

Why? Surely if you are outlawing discrimination it should apply to everybody without exception. After all, that is discrimination in itself. This amendment will change nothing. The “religious conviction” loophole will stay.

The Bracks Labor government in Victoria closed the religious conviction loophole altogether. After the election of the Baillieu Liberal Government it was brought back.

Why has Andrew Barr wimped out like this? Very uncharacteristic for someone like him to put forward a bill to allow anti-gay discrimination. Shane Rattenbury and Caroline Le Coutier should put forward an amendment outlawing *all* anti-gay discrimination. None of this “religious conviction” BS.

Bek Clark 5:05 am 02 Nov 18

Private religious schools are havens for hiding and shifting pedophiles around.

Let’s not give them a cent.

gooterz 8:12 pm 01 Nov 18

Its a choice to go to one of these schools.
Surely they could just not go.

When we had the survey, it was all about it doesn’t affect you. Turns out it does.

Scott Welsh 6:09 pm 01 Nov 18

Just don’t remove the public holidays... unforgivable

Ruth Lee Martin 5:34 pm 01 Nov 18

About time.

Shaun Hazell 5:10 pm 01 Nov 18

Its never happened once it's just grandstanding and virtue signaling

Jessica Brisbane 3:43 pm 01 Nov 18

They can still discriminate as long as they publish a policy to do so.

Wendy Miles 2:27 pm 01 Nov 18

Religious schools should be able to discriminate on the basis of religion only.

    Stephen Page-Murray 2:30 pm 01 Nov 18

    Yes, and remove all their public funding

    Wendy Miles 2:43 pm 01 Nov 18

    Stephen Page-Murray I have a more moderate approach. Every child, regardless of where they are schooled should receive an equal allowance. If it costs $1000 a year to educate a public school child then all private school children should be allocated $1000 each a year and not one cent more. That is equality.

    Jenni Zimoch 3:51 pm 01 Nov 18

    If private schools want to pick and choose who they accept and also charge massive fees every year,then no they shouldn't be given equal money from the government.

    Kerryn Price 4:42 pm 01 Nov 18

    Except the parents do pay their taxes and have made a choice of the best school for their child and pay the fees over and above what they have already paid in tax.

    Wendy Miles 4:42 pm 01 Nov 18

    Stephen Page-Murray can we agree to disagree on this one?👵🏻🤔

    Warwick Penn Bradly 5:59 pm 01 Nov 18

    Wendy Miles disagree. Private schools should receive no government funding whatsoever.

    Rauny Worm 6:16 am 02 Nov 18

    Wrong debate..

    Pia Hughes 7:12 am 02 Nov 18

    Lynne Audsley Thank you. Wendy Miles is completely clueless with her response.

Dave Ferymtok Ward 10:58 am 01 Nov 18

Seems reasonable.

Spiral 10:17 am 01 Nov 18

So we have:

” However, it is clear that current exceptions allowing religious schools to discriminate against students and staff are out of step with community expectations.” “

And

“… the Act as amended would still allow schools to give preference to students and employees on the basis of their religious conviction.”

Isn’t that still allowing discrimination?

I’m puzzled as to what is actually being achieved.

Grail 8:18 am 01 Nov 18

How long until the Federal Government vetoes this legislation?

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top
Copyright © 2018 Region Group Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.
the-riotact.com | aboutregional.com.au | b2bmagazine.com.au | thisiscanberra.com

Search across the site