Is the cost of water killing community sport in Canberra?

Tim Gavel 10 November 2020 21
Icon Water costs are making it difficult for sports organisations make ends meet. Photo: Supplied

The high cost of water is effectively stopping plans for improvement to Phillip Oval infrastructure. Photo: Supplied.

As you look across Canberra and witness the collective return to sport post-COVID-19, there is a feeling that a sense of normality is returning.

Most of us, after all, have grown up with the ability to play sport generally whenever facilities and competitions are available. For many, it is an important aspect of life in Canberra. The expectation is that it will always be there.

Below the surface, though, there are issues brewing which have the potential to impact on this apparent utopia.

Some clubs are struggling with their financial viability in the wake of COVID-19 because of the resultant significant revenue downturn through lack of registrations and sponsorship.

Another emerging impact has the potential to be the most significant of them all: the cost of water in Canberra.

Already we have seen the problems experienced by the Magpies-Belconnen Golf Club and the impact of high water costs.

The club uses treated water supplied by the government-owned Icon Water Limited. The increasing cost from Icon Water could result in the club closing by the middle of next year.

It is an issue being faced by operators of other facilities in Canberra.

The Phillip Oval Management Group administers the sporting facility that includes the headquarters for both ACT Cricket and AFL Canberra. Because of the presence of both cricket and AFL, the ground is used all year.

The cost of water to ensure the standard of the playing surface is maintained, has risen to around $75,000 in the past 12 months, which is around 45 per cent of its operating budget.

Paul Walshe is the chair of the Phillip Oval Management Group. He says the high cost of water is effectively stopping plans for improvements to the facility.

“We want to improve the infrastructure around the ground but it’s hard when you are paying so much for water. You are limited in what you can do.”

Paul Walshe at Phillip Oval. Photo: Supplied.

Paul Walshe, Chair of the Phillip Oval Management Group. Photo: Supplied.

He says there are plans to stage AFLW games and Women’s Big Bash matches at Philip Oval.

Walshe, who knows the utilities industry better than most, having worked for ACTEW for many years, is bemused by Icon Water’s pricing policy particularly when applied to water for community facilities.

“I think we need to look at why we pay so much for water here compared to other jurisdictions,” Paul said.

In South Australia, the government-owned SA Water has provided grants to sports organisations struggling financially because of COVID-19.

Paul Walshe says he has spoken with Icon Water about the impact of the cost of water on the running of the facility.

He says the management group has done everything possible to reduce costs and says it’s now up to Icon Water.

“Icon Water needs to be working more closely with community groups,” he said.

Hopefully commonsense prevails.


What's Your Opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
21 Responses to Is the cost of water killing community sport in Canberra?
Steve Netting Steve Netting 7:55 am 12 Nov 20

We have different but comparable frustrations in Sydney from the disconnects between layers of government. As a nation – health costs, obesity, pressure and wellbeing risks on young people are all increasing. Sport, activity, engagement and bonds from community sport such as BJ_ACT’s Lui example all help. In Sydney local councils close grounds with the sniff of rain so they don’t have to spend as much on ground maintenance, ignoring the bigger picture and bigger opportunity cost….

Jason Filmer Jason Filmer 7:55 pm 11 Nov 20

Money hungry government say no more

John Davison John Davison 7:54 pm 11 Nov 20

How the hell did we let ourselves give our water to profit centres it a basic right and always should be

    Lisa Bishop Lisa Bishop 10:42 pm 11 Nov 20

    John Davison Don’t think anyone ‘let them’. No one would actually vote for such a stupid thing

John Davison John Davison 7:52 pm 11 Nov 20

Yes it is

Benjamin Challen Benjamin Challen 4:24 pm 11 Nov 20

Sink a bore, get a storage tank and pumping system.

Bek Clark Bek Clark 1:11 pm 11 Nov 20

I called Icon last Friday about a busted safety valve in Weston. It was still leaking water straight down the storm water drain yesterday afternoon. Pretty poor form really.

bj_ACT bj_ACT 12:27 pm 11 Nov 20

The cost of social sports in Canberra is ridiculous. $500 a season for soccer, $650 a season for cricket. So much of the fees go towards government ground hire, insurance and water charges.

How can less wealthy families afford the registration costs let alone the equipment? It’s ridiculous.

Nice story yesterday about Raiders journeyman Lui who will play his first game for Queensland tonight. He personally thanked two families who paid for his junior registrations when his family couldn’t afford it.

    Terribledriver Terribledriver 9:53 pm 11 Nov 20

    The system is skewed for the benefit of wealthy people.

Dianne Calvert Dianne Calvert 12:06 pm 11 Nov 20

how do the golf courses get on for watering greens

Peter McDonald Peter McDonald 9:24 am 11 Nov 20

Who needs to water? I’m mowing every weekend.

JS9 JS9 9:17 am 11 Nov 20

The Belconnen Magpies one is bizarre. Its an ad hoc arrangement using water from the treatment plant that otherwise just goes down the stream to NSW. Why Icon Water is charging such a high price I’ll never understand – just charge the marginal cost/Water Abstraction Charge surely?

I’m intrigued however what is driving significant increases in water costs at Phillip however.

The price of water provided by Icon Water has been pretty stable for a few years now, with very little increase – I think they froze the overall bill or something as part of COVID for 2020-21. I assume what is happening is they need additional water to maintain at a higher standard to what it was previously, hence leading to higher bills. That’s a very different story to ‘prices are going up so it’s all Icon Water’s fault’, which is what this article is suggesting reading between the lines.

In the broader discussion in cases where potable water is being used – it is important to remember that if subsidies are provided, then ultimately you, me and everyone else ends up paying for it through higher prices for our usage. Icon Water is allowed $X million per year for its business by the regulator, and if some users get a discounted rate, invariably it will be paid for by the rest of the customers through higher prices, or alternatively by the taxpayer through direct Government subsidies. So be careful what one wishes for.

Cary Elliot Johnson Cary Elliot Johnson 8:30 am 11 Nov 20

Im interested..... say that Icon remains tight on their water consumption costs and volumes (despite us all paying for one new dam wall), then how long can a large body of water sit without going bad? Does it go stale like a bath of water in the heat being de-oxygenated, and thus unusable?

Jon Billows Jon Billows 7:52 am 11 Nov 20

Given that all the dams are full and there are still water restrictions. Maybe it's time to increase capacity...

Corey Karl Corey Karl 7:34 am 11 Nov 20

Now that the water is spilling over the top of just about every dam in the region, why is it so expensive for clubs I wonder 🤔

    Justin Wakefield Justin Wakefield 7:37 am 11 Nov 20

    Corey because the abundance of it makes it no cheaper to store, treat and distribute.

    Corey Karl Corey Karl 8:04 am 11 Nov 20

    Justin Wakefield sure it doesn’t

    Toni Isaacson Toni Isaacson 8:18 am 11 Nov 20

    This is 2020, surely we can solve this issue.

    Dylan Salafia Dylan Salafia 8:31 am 11 Nov 20

    Corey Karl because it’s all about making money

    Johnny Swift Johnny Swift 9:15 am 11 Nov 20

    Justin Wakefield Angus, Barnaby and Littleproud could have some cheap blackmarket H2O for sale?

    John Geale John Geale 1:41 pm 11 Nov 20

    What happens when you privatise everything.

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top

Search across the site