3 November 2022

CORRECTED: Role of religion in accessing abortion services in Canberra questioned

| Lottie Twyford
Join the conversation
Calvary Hospital

An unnamed woman has detailed her fear of being taken to Calvary Hospital after accessing an abortion through Marie Stopes and being left in extreme pain, requiring hospitalisation. Photo: Region.

Abortion in the ACT has been decriminalised since 2002. Two decades later, in August of this year, medical and surgical abortions were made free.

The government also announced women could access free long-lasting contraception at the same time, if desired.

Until August, the most significant barrier to accessing abortion in the Territory was cost, although some GPs said abortion accessibility could still be improved.

A Legislative Assembly committee is currently inquiring into access to abortion services in the Territory following the overturning of Roe v Wade in the United States.

READ ALSO Eighth person accuses ex-rock climbing coach Stephen Mitchell of alleged sexual abuse

Archbishop of Canberra and Goulburn Christopher Prowse told the committee on Friday (28 October) not enough support is provided to women who find themselves pregnant to make an “informed decision” about what they do.

“[We] are of the view that the ACT is seeking to provide ready access to those who seek to terminate a pregnancy but is offering very little support and few options to those who seek to continue a pregnancy,” he told the committee.

“We hold that termination for those who choose it should be safe, legal and rare.”

Health Minister Rachel Stephen-Smith said a range of support services are available to women, including ones funded by the ACT and Commonwealth government.

Others questioned religion’s role in the provision of healthcare services – which could include abortion aftercare in some cases – and in the debate itself.

READ ALSO Canberra community invited to deep dive into proposed big battery

Witness Greg Tannahill detailed his experience supporting a woman going through a termination.

The woman, who wished to remain anonymous, had decided to have a termination as she feared for her mental health if she carried the baby.

After receiving the termination, this woman was in immense pain and experiencing complications.

READ ALSO Canberra’s big hearts on display for Australian of the Year

As they live on the north side of Canberra, they went to Calvary Public Hospital in an ambulance.

The woman became highly distressed upon arriving at the hospital as she feared the hospital and its staff might not support her decision to have terminated her pregnancy and would not give her the medical care required.

In the end, those fears did not eventuate and the woman received quality care.

Nonetheless, Mr Tannahill questioned whether it was appropriate for a major public hospital in the Territory to be operated by a Catholic organisation – the Little Company of Mary.

“Abortion has been legal in the ACT for 20 years. It’s settled law and I think it’s inappropriate for a hospital to be run by an organisation that fundamentally doesn’t agree with it,” he said.

In a perfect world, he said, the government would operate that hospital.

READ ALSO What makes good public art in Canberra? It’s about more than giant sculptures

In a later hearing, Ms Stephen-Smith was questioned about this.

She said discussions were continuing with Calvary about how support and conversations were provided to patients at Calvary Hospital.

“Given Canberra Hospital also doesn’t provide surgical abortion services specifically, I don’t think there’s that much disconnect,” Ms Stephen-Smith said.

“But for things like support and advice … or even for people who have experienced sexual assault or rape and then can’t access the morning-after pill at Calvary Hospital … that is raised regularly with us.”

READ ALSO Drug harm reduction is about more than the new pill-testing centre

A group of local doctors – Canberra Deep End GPs – said some barriers still exist when accessing a safe abortion easily in the Territory.

This included the fact there are limited numbers of medical abortion prescribers in the Territory and that no referral pathways are in place for GPs to help their clients get treatment at Marie Stopes International (MSI).

The fact abortions can locally only be provided until 16 weeks was also a problem, Dr Melanie Dorrington told the committee hearing.

They also called for better provision of information as it is currently difficult to determine which GPs provided the service.

Calls for more services – including culturally appropriate ones – and better information were supported by the ACT Council of Social Service (ACTCOSS).

An earlier version of this article incorrectly stated the ACT Right to Life Association supported the position of the Archbishop. The group does not believe abortion should be legal under any circumstance.

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments

Here we go again!! The Calvary Hospital! This publicly funded hospital funded by taxpayers to the tune of millions of dollars every year. The hospital continues to refuse health services to women accessing contraception and abortion. The hospital’s owner, the Little Company of Mary Health Care agreed to sell the hospital to the government about 13 years ago. This sale would have saved taxpayers many millions of dollars. But then the hospital backed down. I seem to remember Cardinal George Pell getting involved somehow. Jeremy Hanson and Vicki Dunne and their anti-abortion crusaders were certainly there in full force, on a mission to obstruct the sale. They argued that the government was ruining the hospital’s Catholic ethos. And they won!

The current healthcare system is a big mess, with far too many vested interests (many ’causes’ seeking to make money off sick people). It will always be a case of Faith versus Science. I personally do not like drugs, and object to all the drug taking we have in our society (mostly pushed by greedy big pharmaceutical companies that seek to profit from sickness). There are many of us in the community who do not want certain views forced upon us, whether that be certain religious views, or the views of drug companies. We are all humans and should be permitted to make decisions about our own body.
Faith (not just religious, but also nature based care) is an important part of healthcare, to many people. People should be entitled to receive the healthcare of their choice, and supported (in their own beliefs), rather than have the beliefs of big pharmaceutical companies (or any religion they don’t agree with) pushed onto them. Sadly, the $$$$ always speaks the loudest.

The only reason the Catholic Church stays involved in the medical system is so it can influence issues like abortion and euthanasia.
They should play no role in the health system.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.