22 August 2024

Will education be ACT Labor's Achilles heel?

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
18

Opposition Leader announced the Liberals’ schools package at Denman Prospect, which included $98m to implement the literacy and numeracy inquiry recommendations. Photo: Ian Bushnell.

Education Minister Yvette Berry may rue the time it took for her to respond to growing concerns about ACT public school standards.

The Canberra Liberals are running hard on education, feeling vindicated by the findings and recommendations of the Expert Panel who investigated literacy and numeracy teaching.

READ ALSO Australia-first residential eating disorders centre prepares for first patients

The government accepted the panel’s verdict, budgeting $24.9 million for implementing the recommendations over a four-year period.

But Opposition Leader Elizabeth has well and truly upped the ante by committing to spending $98m, adding $200 supplies vouchers for teachers into the bargain, no doubt to highlight the plight of classrooms as schools scramble for resources.

Ms Lee also zeroed in on concerns about behaviour in government schools offering teachers access to the Classroom Master program Catholic schools are piloting, if they want it.

For good measure, she has also criticised Ms Berry for not getting on with it sooner, saying there was no need to wait to introduce Year 1 phonics checks for reading.

It all serves to contrast the government’s initial reluctance and then relatively pedestrian approach with the Liberals sense of urgency and the weight by sheer number of dollars it will give to an issue that most Canberrans have experience of.

Just about everybody has an opinion on schools and parents can be galvanised when it comes to the future of their children, which is why education could be a such a potent weapon for Liberals.

They can argue with some justification that the party has fought the good fight, often in the face of a defensive Minister who appeared to be in constant denial about slipping standards, behaviourial as well as academic, in government schools.

Ms Berry has said that she has simply followed the evidence but the evidence has changed.

That will be hard argument to sustain, given the number of reports and amount of data pointing to something systemically wrong, and the growing evidence that explicit instruction, to use the term broadly, should have a greater role, especially in the early years.

READ ALSO Government inquiries are usually a wasteful deflection and it’s time to call them out

To be clear, the government has committed to changes in the teaching mix, a more centralised curriculim to ease burdens on teachers, and an overhaul of school autonomy to provide more consistency across government schools.

But the Liberals are sowing seeds of doubt about the seriousness of the commitment. This is a government, they say, that presided over the decline in standards. How can it be trusted to fix it?

If you want it done properly then elect a party that was waving the red flags all along and will put money where its mouth is?

This isn’t a single-issue election but, again, education is one that can cross party lines and have so many touch points with the community. And for some the government’s realisation will come too late for their children.

It could well be that the government’s record on education could come back to haunt it at the ballot box in October.

Join the conversation

18
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Has Labor become ACT’s Achilles heel?

Let’s be frank. Many public schools in Canberra are war zones. There is no discipline or authority structure in public schools. The system is a mess. Standards are low. Science and maths are avoided. Left wing perspectives dominate the curriculum. At one stage the TER for a teaching course at the UC was incredibly low. Is it any wonder many parents choose to send their offspring to private schools? Labor has been in for a very long time. Sure the teachers union is fairly happy. Labor can rely on the ACT polity to tick their box and for nothing substantial to be done; socialism once again turning a blind eye to its own failure.

GrumpyGrandpa6:52 pm 24 Aug 24

Labor/Greens have a lot of Achilles Heels. Education, Health, Public Transport (Inc LR), Rates, Housing, Grass mowing, Tuggeranong’s neglect etc.
The real question is whether in a left-leaning town, sufficient voters will show their outrage and actively vote against Labor and Green candidates?

Labor have FAILED Canberrans on education for decades – first with closing or merging half our schools, then with kids in cages, now with illiterate kids in cages! Definitely time for a change in government, anyone would be better than this lot

The Education Minister has slowly created a two tier Public School system in Canberra.
High quality public schools are available in many areas, whilst poorly resourced schools struggle to keep good teachers and struggle to provide acceptable education results in other parts of the city.

The Ministers’ weak response to the closure of Calwell High by Worksafe was a disgrace.
Building so called Superschools in two of Canberra’s lowest socio economic suburbs and then not properly supporting them financially and psychologically, will go down as one of the biggest failures of a Government I have ever witnessed first hand.

It’s time our students get an Education Minister who’s not simply sweeping issues under the carpet.

pink little birdie2:04 pm 23 Aug 24

my kids primary school has had 1 playground and it hasn’t been updated in 30 odd years. The kids grow out of it in year 1. Last year the single slide was out of action for 10 school weeks – 12 if you include the holidays. The ministers response was less than good.
Teaching is amazing and better or equal to everywhere else but the facilities for the kids need updating. So much so there’s a petition: https://epetitions.parliament.act.gov.au/details/e-pet-028-24

What on earth is an “all abilities playground”? A slab of concrete so the one wheelchair kid can get in? 🤣

Thomas Emerson11:57 am 23 Aug 24

I’m hearing A LOT of concerns on doorsteps about what’s going on, and not going on, in our public education system. People are unwillingly taking their kids out of the public system into the private system. What I haven’t seen is any concerted plan for catching up all the kids who have fallen behind in recent years, alongside the roll-out of the inquiry recommendations.

I don’t have any ‘skin in the game’, when it comes to education in the ACT (i.e. no relatives in the education system) so have always been a casually interested observer. Nevertheless, I have certainly heard about the issues, highlighted by Bushnell, and other issues, from friends who are involved.

“That will be hard argument to sustain (that Berry has simply followed the evidence)…”
I’m sure Jack D. will be come back hard to maintain that argument – or will he? This article presents a real challenge. Does he lambast Bushnell, the traditionally Labor-friendly journalist on here, for his opinion and daring, so close to the election, to raise such negativity about the government’s record on education, or does he simply let it slide in the hope nobody will notice?

The whole social media team are missing out on Friday long lunch and beers because of this! 🤣

It is chuffing for me to see you call for my feedback so often JS, under your various guises!

If you had been paying attention, you would have read my comment a few days ago where I expressed support for this policy announcement.

The Liberals have been criticised for not taking the electorate seriously and their gimmicky policy announcements and one-off payments and voucher schemes. This is the first and only serious policy announcement from them and I look forward to more, with only a small number of weeks to go. I have a strong interest in education policy having experienced the appalling and unforgetable system which my family endured under the previous Liberal government. I look forward to much better from them although I do remain sceptical.

I look forward to Yvette Berry putting a smile on her face and matching the Libs policy or pledge to do more. She has been disappointing so far and slow off the mark.

Liberal leader Elizabeth Lee seems to have moved on, distancing herself from the conservatives who currently dominate her party. She was particularly hostile towards the union when she was education minister previously, threatening not to deal with them if she was ever in government. However, the union are welcoming of this policy which is a good start.

Unfortunately, it is the right-wing nutters who dominate and continue to undermine the party and her leadership. I hope Ms Lee holds out and does not let them use their power to obstruct this proposal’s implementation should the party win this year’s Territory election.

Time will tell!

@Jack D.
Oh and what “various guises”would they be?

Has it not occurred to you that there are many RiotACT-ers who, like me, draw great enjoyment from watching you attempt to make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear, in your spinning on behalf of ACT Labor.

To favour a political party or ideology is one thing – I’m definitely pro independents holding the balance of power at all levels of our democratic system, but I personally doubt that your blatant electioneering and fawning sycophancy are likely to sway those in here who are not rusted on Labor.

But hey, keep trying, you never know ….

the irony of asking this question to people educated by the system is too much

Canberrans have been willing to ignore Labors dismantling of the education system since they closed half the public schools from 2006. I don’t see it being the election issue it should probably be.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.