7 July 2024

Enrolment figures a warning to government to fix public schools

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
17
Yvette Berry with primary school students

Minister for Education Yvette Berry remains upbeat about public school enrolments and changes to come. Photo: Supplied.

For Education Minister Yvette Berry, whatever the parent feedback, the statistical studies and recommendations from an independent expert panel say, the Territory’s public schools are still delivering a great education.

They just need to change with the times now the evidence is finally pointing to decades of flawed practices in the classroom.

Some parents can’t afford to wait.

The latest School Census figures show a continuing leak of public enrolments in recent years, while non-government schools have prospered.

Changing demographics and birth rates are playing a role, with the losses this year confined to pre-school and primary school years, but in a growing city in the middle of a cost of living crisis, one would expect the public school system to hold its own or still grow.

READ ALSO 7.5-star complex unveiled: Public housing build on the up after delays ease, says Berry

The ongoing growth in non-government schools shows that a number of families are looking for more than the public sector can offer them, as well as the disenchanted seeking an education for their children that works.

The latter group tell a common story – their kids were not learning, they needed more structure, values were not aligned and schools were unresponsive.

Schools can’t be all things to all parents and students, but these were things that many submissions to the literacy and numeracy inquiry also raised, along with inconsistencies across the system.

The family Region talked to was not seeking an elite education for their children but the basics taught properly in a structured environment, something that should be the bread and butter of a public school.

Faddish classroom approaches such as “flexible furniture” that left their Year 2 son adrift should be one of the things to go when the Directorate rings in the changes recommended in the report.

It may be Ms Berry’s job to defend government schools publicly, but she does get herself in a tangle talking about it.

On one hand, kids are still getting a great education, but change is coming, and it will be “significant”.

Why? Because the experts have finally stated the so-called “great education” is not really that great.

For Ms Berry, some schools are already changing while others are not so progressed. That’s part of the problem. It seems to be driven by postcodes and parents, not the Directorate.

Ms Berry also likes to focus on how teachers will have less of a workload, freeing them up to focus on teaching.

“Our schools are excited about the opportunity to make changes that will particularly assist teachers,” she said last Thursday (4 July) when asked about the census.

That plays well with the teachers’ union, but parents might be asking for a bit more attention on their children.

But there is hope that the public system can find lessons in what is working in non-government schools and collaborate.

Ms Berry suggested that the different education sectors did not have to compete with each other.

“Catholic and non-government schools and public schools work pretty closely together,” she said.

“We’ve shown we can do that really well, particularly during COVID.”

READ ALSO Australia to partner with Amazon Web Services to deliver top secret cloud capabilities

It would be good if the government could be more candid about the issues confronting public schools and acknowledge families’ experiences.

The first step in restoring the fortunes of public schools and the confidence of parents is to admit something is wrong and show a determination to fix it.

The Budget funding of $25 million over four years – some say it should have been more – for the Strong Foundations literacy and numeracy initiative is a down payment on change.

Let’s hope it’s not too little too late.

Join the conversation

17
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
Martin Keast1:14 pm 03 Aug 24

Strong evidence that the government should step back from education and allow private schools to thrive. The size of the ACT education bureaucracy has grown while numbers are shrinking – shows where the money is going, it is not into more teachers but more regulators and woke/DEI training courses and consultants.

My family have lived in the ACT for over 140 years. I have never felt such an intrusion of political agendas in public schools as I do now. My family have been excluded, bullied, shunned, silenced and all 3 of my children violently assulted in some way. I am not allowed to speak of this. It is sanctioned. If you are not Indigenous, LGBTQI+ or wealthy, they are not interested. After 3 generations at the same high school, we are the outcasts. They may be woke but they ain’t AWAKE. I am NOT HAPPY JAN with the Labor/Greens who have ruined my Canberra. Sorry if that “sounds bad”. Care factor zero.

GrumpyGrandpa6:49 pm 08 Jul 24

Both Mrs GrumpyGrandma and I attended public schools. Our kids all attended public schools.

We are supporters of the public system, however, the government has allowed the standard of public schools to deteriorate.

We have friends who tell us of kids with drugs and teachers being assaulted. It’s no different to how the government doesn’t enforce collection of fares on our buses and allows scammers to ride for free with no fear of consequences.

Private schools have stricter rules and there is the consequence of exclusion.

And I wonder why more parents are choosing Private?

Private schools are safer, have higher quality teachers and don’t have an agenda of forcing woke ideals on the children. I had 2 children go private and 2 go public and the privately educated ones are more empathetic and much kinder. Both went because they had potential social issues that might make then open to bullying (which does exist in the private system but dealt with much better). Their siblings were much more robust and tougher. If you want to see the difference between schools, go and wait at the front of a school at the beginning and ending of the day and you’ll feel the difference.

I hope the young person with the pencil is not taking any assistance/advice with numbers from the Local Council’s Education Minister. We all know that the Local Council are not very good with numbers just ask our Chief Minister and his budgets.

“You see this number? You tell your teacher they can’t see it and then do everything you can to block the FOI request”

Daniel O'CONNELL3:23 pm 08 Jul 24

In spite of a cost penalty, families are switching from public to private; why?

pink little birdie2:59 pm 08 Jul 24

sign this petition for the ACT government to fund a playground at Charnwood-Dunlop school that the children don’t grow out of in year 1. Playgrounds in schools are essential infrastructure!
https://epetitions.parliament.act.gov.au/details/e-pet-028-24?fbclid=IwZXh0bgNhZW0CMTEAAR0Wk-rFMfpcNU5Du8iVuS1424yrWxuOrmSf3Vph0VCd94mzX43Q8GpVznY_aem_G-innWGqk_vaerNWle7CjA

Interesting that this https://www.economist.com/special-report/2024/07/07/schools-in-rich-countries-are-making-poor-progress came out this morning. I wonder if anyone in the ED will bother reading the series.

Ms Berry has been sweeping too many long ongoing public school funding and teaching issues under the carpet for too long.

Ignoring problems with the two failed Superschools and pretending there’s no resourcing issues in lower socio economic parts of the city, won’t magically fix public education problems.

The good inner Canberra public schools in high socio economic suburbs are papering over the cracks and hiding the hard truths in struggling schools.

the cracks in the looney left are starting to show everywhere now. With its basic premise being that you can get away with 1 + 1 = 3, everything it’s been trying to do since about, say, the 1960s is falling to bits and even normies are starting to notice and get fed up – (in this instance) doing tribal dances in class or learning about little tommy’s new dress just not enough to cut it where real world concerns are always a constant.

You stick to your side of the border Vasily and we’ll stick to ours!

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.