Skip to content Skip to main navigation

Opinion

In the fight of your life
you need the best at your side

Fast rail strategy but high speed service still a way down the line for Goulburn

Maryann Weston 26 November 2019 34
Local Member for Goulburn Wendy Tuckerman

Local Member for Goulburn Wendy Tuckerman met with Professor Andrew McNaughton recently. Profesor McNaughton chairs the NSW Government’s expert panel and is overseeing the development of a Fast Rail Strategy for NSW. Photos: Supplied.

Transport infrastructure and rail times in the Goulburn region were key issues in the closely fought battle for the seat of Goulburn in March, and with the NSW Government’s Fast Rail Strategy expected to be delivered before the end of 2019, all eyes are on what it might contain for the ACT and Goulburn region.

The Southern Corridor, which includes Canberra and Goulburn, has been identified by the government as among rail routes for investigation into a NSW fast rail network with a prediction that delivery of fast rail has the potential to slash travel times by up to 75 per cent. However, it’s unlikely this region will see substantial improvement in travel times in the shorter term.

While the NSW Government has committed $295 million over four years to begin early works on the fast rail network, money going to new rail alignment is primarily being spent in the outer Sydney regions on the north and south coasts, planning a route to the Central West, and to preliminary work on a new straightened track to high speed standard between Menangle in the Macarthur region and Yerrinbool in the Southern Highlands.

While it could be argued that major centres like Goulburn on the Southern Corridor would benefit from time savings on a faster journey from Menangle to Yerrinbool, the four-year funding cycle means that unless additional funding is announced, passengers can only anticipate ‘incremental’ improvement in travel times.

Member for Goulburn Wendy Tuckerman recently met with the chair of the expert panel developing the strategy, Professor Andrew McNaughton, an international fast rail expert advising the government on the delivery of a fast rail network. Professor McNaughton has also been meeting with organisations, agencies and councils in the region.

“I welcomed the opportunity to meet with Professor McNaughton to share my views on the benefits fast rail would deliver for local job growth, business activity and community access to services and social opportunities,” Mrs Tuckerman said.

“The NSW Government looks forward to receiving the Fast Rail Strategy … and is committed to identifying immediate improvements to existing corridors that deliver incremental benefits to customers, while building towards a fast rail network that delivers transformational journey times.”

Experts agree on the economic benefits to communities located along fast rail corridors and, equally, regional rail lobby groups agree on the need for faster train services.

Charles Sturt University Associate Professor Ian Gray, whose research has focused on the link between rail services, regional development, and social issues, believes a train service that is attractive to commuters can make a big difference to communities’ access to employment, health and other services. Smaller towns and villages along the line can also benefit, as well as larger population centres.

train station locations

A key election issue, towns like Goulburn on the Southern Corridor will be eagerly awaiting recommendations on train station locations for future fast rail service.

Mrs Tuckerman acknowledges large-scale transport infrastructure projects take time.

“International experience shows that fast rail projects are complex and aren’t delivered overnight. It requires a bold vision for improved connectivity that clearly articulates where and when fast rail investments should be made to maximize benefits for communities,” Mrs Tuckerman said.

Despite the complexity of delivering a fast rail infrastructure, the NSW Government’s Fast Rail Strategy is to be welcomed, providing it is implemented over successive funding cycles and potential government changes. To date, limited progress has been achieved on high-speed rail in Australia.

“Professor McNaughton will identify the preferred alignment of the rail line, recommended train speeds and station locations. This work will also inform potential improvements to existing rail corridors in the short to medium term,” Mrs Tuckerman said.

The NSW Government is also replacing its aging regional rail fleet of XPT, XPLORER and Endeavour trains. The new trains will improve safety, accessibility, amenities and reliability for commuters travelling from Sydney to the regions, as well as Canberra, Melbourne, and Brisbane.

Planning and detailed design work have already begun for the new fleet with the first of the new trains expected to be running from 2023.

In the meantime, towns and larger regional centres along the Southern Corridor are anticipating what the Fast Rail Strategy might say about possible locations for train stations and how they might eventually benefit from faster rail times.

And local MPs in regions across NSW, some in marginal seats, will continue to face commuter and regional development pressure for fast rail services.

You can find out more about the NSW Government’s Fast Rail Strategy here.


What's Your Opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
34 Responses to Fast rail strategy but high speed service still a way down the line for Goulburn
Jason Oneill Jason Oneill 6:32 pm 30 Nov 19

must be an election soon....

Capital Retro Capital Retro 2:19 pm 29 Nov 19

I think the consortiums intrested in big infrastructure deals like this proposal seek out tax and other concessions similar to what the ACT governmnet has passed on to some multinational retailers and service providers who have set up shop in Canberra.

Trevor Watson Trevor Watson 2:04 pm 29 Nov 19

If this was actually financially viable how come a private consortium has not financed the project snd got it moving? Oh wait that was tried but the consortium wanted the government to pay for it....

Trevor Watson Trevor Watson 1:54 pm 29 Nov 19

There is a huge difference between fast rail and high speed rail. We now have speeds up to 110 kmh in some areas for some trains. To go to Fast rail ie 160kmh there is a lot of work to do. To go to high speed rail ie around 200 kmh its a case of virtually starting over again. A lot more political will is required to do this and perhaps look past a bit of pork barreling for the next election.

Roger Mungummary Roger Mungummary 12:37 pm 28 Nov 19

They have been waffling on about this for forty years! Will never hapoen

Matt Ellem Matt Ellem 9:39 am 28 Nov 19

Fast rail Sydney to Canberra, now that’s an interesting topic that’s never been raised before 😂

Capital Retro Capital Retro 9:56 pm 27 Nov 19

“In the meantime, how about just replacing the xpt?”

I think the Canberra train is the Explorer and the XPT never ran on the route. Both were never suited to the constraints of the rail track however.

    Joe Delaney Joe Delaney 10:42 pm 28 Nov 19

    XPT ran to Canberra as one of the first interstate XPT services. Was changed over to an explorer service when the Riverina (Albury) service started to run right through to Melbourne.

    Capital Retro Capital Retro 5:56 am 29 Nov 19

    Thanks Joe.

HiddenDragon HiddenDragon 7:35 pm 27 Nov 19

Sounds like a much more practical use (of a much smaller amount) of money than the mirage of an east coast high speed rail line.

Louis Sotiropoulos Louis Sotiropoulos 4:35 pm 27 Nov 19

Whatever happened to that Spanish mob that were going to trial, and pay for, new tilt trains that were supposed to do CBR to Syd in 2 and a half hours?? That died down quick

    Trevor Watson Trevor Watson 1:58 pm 29 Nov 19

    Louis Sotiropoulos yes well it was a good idea however the tilt trains do tilt and when the tilt they don't fit our archaic loading gauge ie they could not tilt in tunnels or when other trains pass them. Plus of course tilt trains don't like sharp curves or steep grades. Mind you that would have got us to arround 140kmh....

    Louis Sotiropoulos Louis Sotiropoulos 3:02 pm 29 Nov 19

    Trevor Watson bummer. All we've heard is talk. I remember them talking about the fast train when Sydney won the Olympics. If only they started back then

    Trevor Watson Trevor Watson 9:55 am 01 Dec 19

    Louis Sotiropoulos they have been waffling about this since before I came to Canberra in 1973.

Stephen Saunders Stephen Saunders 10:19 am 27 Nov 19

The responses are on to it. Gladys’ “Fast Rail” plan mimics Scott’s “Faster Rail” plan. Lip service. We do infrastructure very late and very grudgingly in this country. Goulburn will continue to enjoy the very best of 19th century rail for some decades yet.

Capital Retro Capital Retro 10:06 am 27 Nov 19

Jose Vega rightly states the fast times of the Spanish AVE between Madrid and Cordoba (which carries about 4 million passengers a year) as compared to our existing, slow service between Canberra and Sydney. But in reality, comparisons can’t be made.

https://www.railway-technology.com/features/spain-high-speed-railway/

The major infrastructure Australia needs right now is the harvesting and inland diversion of high coastal rainfall in Queensland. Forget fast trains.

    JS9 JS9 2:43 pm 28 Nov 19

    Deary me….. rightfully takes a pot shot at rail investment that is probably marginal in its payback, but then suggest an even crazier scheme that has been shown, time and time again, to be so far from cost effective its not funny…

    Capital Retro Capital Retro 6:33 pm 28 Nov 19

    If you want to preserve the standard of living you have been enjoying so far, think about where our extra water is going to come from as Australia doubles it population over the next 30 years. Already, there is barely enough to go around. The ridiculous “environmental flows” will be the first thing to go and bans on new dams in national parks (like the Welcome Reef one) will soon follow.

    The last “pot shot” at a major infrastructure Australia attempted was the NBN which will be sperceded before it is completely rolled out. You are a bit optimistic if you think a fast train investment will be “marginal in its payback”.

Mark Scott Mark Scott 8:41 am 27 Nov 19

Diesel trains? Let's hope the track can be electrified (preferably to 25kv AC unlike Sydney's 1.5kv DC) and the trains converted to green electricity, not imported fuel

Chris MacDonald Chris MacDonald 8:10 am 27 Nov 19

Nothing will happen while it’s left to the NSW government alone - the ACT government needs to partner with NSW and get some federal money to upgrade the rail line

    Trevor Watson Trevor Watson 2:00 pm 29 Nov 19

    Chris MacDonald you mean the 9km between Canberra and Queenbeyan? Good luck with getting the ACT government to pay for anything...

    Chris MacDonald Chris MacDonald 2:02 pm 29 Nov 19

    Trevor Watson What makes you think NSW will spring for anything past Goulburn?

    Trevor Watson Trevor Watson 9:59 am 01 Dec 19

    Chris MacDonald they have upgraded the track to Crisps Creek. However that is because they need to take Sydneys waste to the Woodlawn Bioreactor. Between there and Canberra the route runs through some hilly terrain and also has the very scenic climb through the Molongolo Gorge...

Jose Vega Jose Vega 8:09 am 27 Nov 19

25 years behind Europe, China and Japan on railway infrastructure in our region. Canberra to Sydney 4 hours to do around 300km, Madrid to Cordoba 1 hour 40 minutes to do 450kms.

David Brown David Brown 7:27 am 27 Nov 19

Only in political promises and my wildest dreams.

Kriso Hadskini Kriso Hadskini 7:21 am 27 Nov 19

In the meantime, how about just replacing the xpt? I would much prefer the travel by train to Sydney and sometimes still do, but the rolling stock is woeful. The carriages are 35yrs old, they often smell of exhaust, seats are hard and threadbare, lighting horrible and no wifi. It could be so much better. Waiting to replace carriages while the fairytale of this vft never happens is stupid.

    George Keleher George Keleher 9:58 pm 30 Nov 19

    Kriso Hadskini they are being replaced, it says this in the article.

Michael Cameron Michael Cameron 7:17 am 27 Nov 19

Is there an election coming soon? Must be, as this stuff crops up each time over the past 20 odd years!

    Trevor Watson Trevor Watson 2:01 pm 29 Nov 19

    Michael Cameron yes along with the Eden rail link...

    Ashley Wright Ashley Wright 5:53 pm 29 Nov 19

    Michael Cameron nope. Still over 3 more years before the next NSW election.

    Michael Cameron Michael Cameron 5:55 pm 29 Nov 19

    Ashley Wright Hmmmmm. so why are they bringing this fast rail thing out so early? Normally it happens just before elections! Seems a bit like Easter buns out well before Easter..lol

    Jason Oneill Jason Oneill 6:34 pm 30 Nov 19

    Canberra elections next year.

    Michael Cameron Michael Cameron 7:03 pm 30 Nov 19

    Jason Oneill I knew it!!!!!

    Trevor Watson Trevor Watson 10:08 am 01 Dec 19

    Jason Oneill got it in one...And you can bet this fast rail strategy will favour the ACT. BUT DONT BE FOOLED its not going to happen.

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top
Copyright © 2019 Region Group Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.
the-riotact.com | aboutregional.com.au | b2bmagazine.com.au | thisiscanberra.com

Search across the site