16 May 2023

Probing the polls: working from home and the Calvary takeover

| Genevieve Jacobs
Join the conversation
14
Calvary Public Hospital Bruce

Readers have already expressed a variety of opinions over the Calvary Public Hospital takeover. Photo: Claire Fenwicke.

Are you still working from home? Are you planning to stay that way?

Several recent surveys have suggested that public servants want to work at home and most think they can do so without losing any productivity. In fact, there may even be a boost.

In last week’s poll, we asked Do you work better at home?

619 readers responded. Your choices to vote were No, I can’t focus when Netflix awaits me. This received 33 per cent of the total, or 203 votes. Alternatively, you could vote Yes, fewer distractions and I get heaps more done. This attracted 67 per cent of the total, or 416 votes.

This week, we’re wondering how you feel about one of the most surprising stories of the year so far, the government’s decision to compulsorily acquire Calvary Public Hospital in Bruce in order to provide healthcare on the North side.

READ ALSO Ambushed Calvary digs in for legal battle over hospital takeover

Health Minister Rachel Stephen Smith said that negotiations between the ACT Government and Calvary had broken down irretrievably when the government took the decision to take over the hospital because there were no other feasible alternatives.

That suggestion was emphatically refuted by Calvary Health Care’s national CEO Martin Bowles, who told Region that the hospital had heard nothing before being told less than two days before the public announcement.

Mr Bowles said it was now clear that while Calvary and CHS staff had been working together for the past six months, a secret government team was working on the takeover at the same time. There was strong opposition from the Liberals, who described the decision as “a dictatorial stitch-up”.

READ ALSO No holds barred: Government’s new ruthless edge carries big risks

Reader opinions also differed strongly.

ChrisinTurner wrote “Public Hospitals should be run by governments not organisations reporting to the Vatican”, but another reader said “Imagine pretending that a new building will fix systemic issues. Imagine taking over a functioning contracted service and pretending you can do better”.

And Angie Carey wrote “A second large public hospital is needed in Canberra. So is the requirement that private hospitals be responsible for emergency post-operative care on procedures they undertake instead of pushing their patients onto the public system. Canberra should have at least one private hospital emergency department (requiring payment)”.

Our question this week is:

Should the ACT Government take over Calvary Public?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Join the conversation

14
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

The question about the hasty decision hasn’t been proved enough yet. Has anyone looked into the December explosion and what caused that? Patients were evacuated – Still cut open on the operating table – from Calvary public over to Private , packed full of gauze and saline so they could be stitched up and operation finished at the Calvary private.

The December explosion and evacuation was not reported upon or investigated. Who was at fault here? Has anyone established this? The electrical wiring to the property is the responsibility of the ACT Government. They wanted to swiftly come in and take over so they can cover up more of their own bungles.

The ACT Govt can’t manage the Canberra Hospital, so why should they get a second one just to mismanage and cover up all their mistakes?

Someone needs to investigate this issue further.

Capital Retro8:37 am 19 May 23

There have been major electrical problems at TCH as well.

Cranky Chook9:29 am 12 Jun 23

Surely it is Calvary Health Care’s responsibility to maintain the hospital that they run and own.

Catholics will mobilise the NO vote in the poll making it inaccurate.

Daniel O'CONNELL8:23 am 17 May 23

Since when have Catholics not been allowed to have opionion and vote? Let us not return to sectarian divisions of the relatively recent past.

@Daniel O’CONNELL
“Since when have Catholics not been allowed to have opionion and vote?”

I’m pretty sure nobody has denied Catholics (or any other religious group) the right to their opinion or to vote, Daniel. It’s when those religious zealots try to impose their dogma, on those of us who don’t share it, that I arc up.

Whether you like it or not, Australia is a secular democracy and religion and/or spirituality have absolutely no place in government – including the delivery of government funded services.

Labor is full of Catholics, including Albo

Actually the Constitution says differently “WHEREAS the people of New South Wales, Victoria, South Australia, Queensland, and Tasmania, humbly relying on the blessing of Almighty God, have agreed to unite in one indissoluble Federal Commonwealth …”

I have no problem with Public Health needs to be run by the public – or the government, not a religious organization known to refuse services based on their belief contrary to Hippocraic Oath.

It’s not “Thou shall no harm unless it doesn’t meet your Christian values”.

Working from home suits Public Servants. For real workers, it’s face-to-face, or with the tools or in the wards

If the standard and culture of Canberra Hospital is anything to go by, let’s not make another of our hospitals the same sad place. I avoid any treatment at Canberra Hospital if at all possible. My two sons have both been misdiagnosed there (one with a broken jaw and one with a groin injury). I saw a doctor bully a nurse in the emergency area and went for an X-ray while doing chemo and the radiographer had flu and I had to ask him to leave! When my father had a fall at 92 and ended up there, they couldn’t even get his meds correct and on time! Do we really need the same people in charge of another hospital in Canberra?

Nick Stevens7:42 am 19 May 23

I worked in Public Health until my recent retirement and found the dedication of ALL staff to be dedicated, professional and caring, and I not once, observed otherwise.
I am certainly not discounting your complaints, only responding to my time in Public Health.

Like anything the Government do things badly so leave it to Private Ownership. Surely the ACT can’t afford it anyway along with the ever costly trams.

I’d love to hear your thoughts on how profit oriented health care system in US looks to you.

Not everything runs better in the hands of private ownership with a profit motive.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.