28 February 2022

Procurement issues likely endemic, says Integrity Commissioner

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
Construction work to Campbell Primary School

The Integrity Commissioner is considering an investigation into the Campbell Primary School tender. Photo: David Murtagh.

Procurement issues raised in the audit report on the Campbell Primary School Modernisation tender are likely to be endemic in the ACT public sector, Integrity Commissioner Michael Adams has told a Legislative Assembly committee.

Mr Adams appeared before the committee a day after he issued his explosive statement announcing the corruption watchdog was considering launching an investigation into the Campbell Primary School tender, and calling for members of the construction industry to come forward if they had suspicions of improper or corrupt conduct in government tender processes.

The damning report from the Auditor-General found that the procurement process lacked probity and that the ACT Education Directorate did not deal with the tenderers fairly, impartially and consistently.

“It is very unlikely I think that this kind of thing has happened only once,” Mr Adams said.

READ ALSO Corruption watchdog weighs probe of Campbell Primary tender process

Outlining the process ahead, Mr Adams indicated that an investigation would almost certainly proceed because it seemed to be the only way to answer some of the questions raised in the report.

“When we’ve looked at the material, we will decide whether there is a reasonable suspicion of corrupt conduct. We will then consider whether we will use our coercive powers,” he said.

“Almost certainly the answer is yes because there are some answers that are perfectly obvious from the Auditor-General’s report, that require someone getting in the witness box and being cross-examined to explain behaviour and explain decisions.”

Mr Adams said the commission had gathered about 80 per cent of the material required, including 30,000 documents related to this one transaction, and would obtain interviews and other material from the Auditor-General in about a week.

“It’s not impossible, of course, that our request to the public will produce further material that we will need to examine,” he said.

Michael Adams

ACT Integrity Commissioner Michael Adams: “It is very unlikely I think that this kind of thing has happened only once.” Photo: IPCC.

Asked whether he had enough resources to pursue investigations of this nature, Mr Adams said the relative cost was small.

“When you talk about my costs of investigations, they are trivial compared with the cost of some of these tenders,” he said.

“The Campbell Primary School tender was $17.5 million. The amount spent on investigating could be very small compared to the public interest in ensuring that this kind of thing did not happen.”

Mr Adams said the investigation could include the sale of land, saying it was a fraught issue in the ACT.

“The sale of land is an issue that comes up more than once in complaints,” he said.

“I might say we have not yet had a complaint that has moved to the investigation stage once we have examined its basis.”

Mr Adams said there would not be a closing date for submissions from the construction industry.

Despite Canberra firm Manteena being selected in 2020 as the preferred tender for the Campbell Primary project, the contract went to multinational Lendlease after the weighted evaluation criteria used in government tenders were, in effect, re-weighted and re-prioritised.

The Integrity Commission said the Auditor-General highlighted repeated departures from consistent recommendations of the tender evaluation teams about the superior bid, resulting in another otherwise unsuccessful tenderer being offered the contract.

The Auditor-General also found that the overall process did not comply with proper practices and gave rise to unidentified conflicts of interest and communications with tenderers that were not appropriate, controlled or adequately documented.

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
Julie Patricia Smith6:02 pm 01 Mar 22

The auditor might decide now is time to brush the dust off their 1990s inquiry into ACT land administration. Systemic problems. So systemic that unlawful gifts of land value through ‘rezoning’ leases for redevelopment were judged to not be corrupt. And have they ever looked at public housing. Before people gave up there was a lot of shonky stories circulating. It’s about time someone did some real investigations. Just as we used to think the federal government was corruption free we may get a shock when someone actually looks at ACT administration. Not party political. …

Finagen_Freeman12:36 pm 01 Mar 22

Anyone in the ACTPS knows just how easy and how much of this has gone on. No surprises expected for the commissioner’s statement.
Expect no senior executive to take the fall. It will only be a sideways move, and a bland statement along the lines of “lessons learned”.

Julie Patricia Smith6:05 pm 01 Mar 22

The nearest thing the ACT has to a Royal Commission is a judicial inquiry. We had a judicial inquiry into land administration led by Justice Paul Stein. That was exactly the response… the auditor then took it forward but concluded it was not corrupt as it was ‘endemic’.

Stephen Saunders10:08 am 01 Mar 22

Language Police here. We reject the idea that procurement issues can be endemic.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.