School fete organisers cry foul at parking fine blitz

Ian Bushnell 18 November 2019 125
Enforcement van

The parking enforcement van’s number plate recognition technology makes it easier to identify offenders and issue fines. Photo: File.

The spring school fete season is well underway but for at least three events the experience has been spoiled by parking inspectors using number plate recognition to slap fines on unwitting drivers.

The latest blitz hit fete-goers supporting St Thomas the Apostle Primary School in Kambah on 9 November, where 11 people so far have copped fines of $123, mostly for parking on nature strips.

Fete co-coordinator Barb Miels-Barrett says the complaints starting coming in on Friday and she has written to Minister for Regulatory Services Gordon Ramsay and City Services Minister Chris Steel, who ironically performed raffle duty at the fete, calling for the fines to be waived.

She says her school is the third that she knows of to be visited by the now-infamous van and she wonders why an event held once a year on a weekend to raise funds for the community should be a target.

“They don’t come around on a Saturday morning to target anything else but that,” Ms Miels-Barrett said.

“It’s mean-sighted, mean-spirited, it’s not fair, it’s not just, it’s not right.”

She says one person was actually in the car waiting for his elderly mother and another needed to park nearby because of their special-needs child. Others were fete volunteers.

Ms Miels-Barrett acknowledged that people should not park dangerously or cause a problem, but the nature strips are quite wide and safety was not an issue.

The school reported no problems at their fete last year with parking inspectors. The enforcement vans, using plate recognition technology, means fines are automatically generated and can capture many offenders in a short space of time. The lack of human contact through an inspector individually booking vehicles means there’s no discretion around parking fines.

Ms Miels-Barrett believes the Government and inspectors should exercise some discretion for these kinds of events.

“It’s legal but where is it fair and just, when you’re trying to raise funds that you can’t get any other way to help continue as a viable community?” she asked.

She says the technology should make it quite easy to identify the “offenders” and waive the fines.

The parking enforcement van also visited Canberra Grammar and Weetangera Primary School on their fete days.

Shadow Minister for Urban Services Nicole Lawder called the parking blitzes predatory.

“It is wrong to prey on fete-goers as a means of revenue-raising,” she said. “Many fete-goers are volunteers who sacrifice their time to support their local community. It is disrespectful to hit participants with hefty fines if they were parking in a safe and reasonable manner. If it’s safe and not blocking access, why must people be pinged at community events?

“Targeting community events for revenue-raising purposes puts a serious dampener on festivities and may discourage people from getting involved.”

She said the Government should focus on improving designated public parking and fixing the disastrous bus network to give the community viable transport options, rather than resorting to predatory attempts at revenue raising.

An ACT Government spokesperson said that on the weekend 9-10 November, Parking Operations attended a number of school fetes and community events.

At the St Thomas the Apostle fete, 50 vehicles were issued with infringement notices for parking dangerously and illegally, but no illegally parked vehicles were identified at the two other school fetes they attended.

Schools and community groups should ensure they included plans for adequate safe and legal parking around their events to ensure attendees were not put at risk by motorists parking illegally, the spokesperson said.

Access Canberra worked with the Education Directorate to provide information to schools to encourage safe parking during events like fetes.

“Drivers should know that it is their responsibility to park legally at all times. Illegal parking practices result in complaints due to inconvenience for local residents and risks to the safety of road users, especially pedestrians,” the spokesperson said.

“This includes blocking pedestrian access and impacting pedestrian safety for vulnerable Canberrans like children and those with a disability, all motorists should park legally at all times so as not to incur an infringement.”

The spokesperson said that when using Licence Plate Recognition (LPR), a parking inspector must assess the individual circumstances of each vehicle before an infringement is issued.

“The LPR team assess issues and gather evidence as they use LPR technology, and review all identified issues after returning to base. If found to be an instance of dangerous and illegal parking, an infringement is issued,” the spokesperson said.

School groups could apply for temporary traffic management permits so there can be a safe outcome when there are limited on-street parking options in their area.

Access Canberra’s event support: https://www.accesscanberra.act.gov.au/app/answers/detail/a_id/2200/kw/traffic%20plan%20event.


What's Your Opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
125 Responses to School fete organisers cry foul at parking fine blitz
Dane Roberts Dane Roberts 10:09 pm 22 Nov 19

Can anyone confirm whether it is legal or not to park on the grass bit in the middle of Yarra Glen between the Melrose roundabout and the Carruthers Street overpass?

BlowMeDown BlowMeDown 9:45 am 22 Nov 19

The ACT Parking Infringements Guide suggests that there is some discretion available depending on the risk posed.

“When this kind of illegal parking is reported, Parking Operation’s response is dependent on the level of risk posed (i.e whether it is high, medium or low risk).”

I would have thought that parking on a nature strip when there are a large number of vehicles parked around the area the risk would be very low.

BlowMeDown BlowMeDown 8:57 am 22 Nov 19

Enforcing the laws is a good thing and it must be without prejudice or favour.

Having said that i seem to recall that some years ago the government made it legal to park on nature strips with some restrictions. If that has changed then i don’t mind but the government keeps changing the laws, and most frustrating of all the conditions around existing laws, and so no wonder people are confused.

Ray Adams Ray Adams 4:09 pm 21 Nov 19

Greedy government.

Chris Hobbs Chris Hobbs 12:00 am 21 Nov 19

Hate these things. Just a cash grab, no actual life saving being done!

bd84 bd84 10:00 pm 20 Nov 19

People who are too lazy to park legally further away and walk a few extra metres deserve every parking ticket they get. Parking tickets are voluntary revenue raisers, quite easily avoided.

Carl Ostermann Carl Ostermann 9:33 pm 20 Nov 19

To set things straight... The law is the law, who which has no conscience due to the words written on a computer screen from those we do not know! Common sense has been around longer than insurance companies! Unfortunately to the people trying to do the right thing and being punished for trying to fit into a popular event, obviously! Why would anybody want to ruin someone's event by scaring the visitors off from future events, all because They parked in the wrong spot even if they left room for their fellow driver! You geeks are so annoying!!!

Michael Dyczek Michael Dyczek 6:23 pm 20 Nov 19

If don't have law and order, we have the law of the jungle. What's wrong with parking legally and walking a bit might loose a few kg.

John Moulis John Moulis 4:03 pm 20 Nov 19

They’re targeting fitness events as well. At the Spartan Challenge a few weeks back they were booking everybody. A few of them need something like the Spartan Challenge, it is obvious the only exercise they get is opening their box of Krispy Kreme doughnuts.

Ngaire Harvey Ngaire Harvey 12:14 pm 20 Nov 19

I live close to st thomas and at the fete I was very angry at the absolutely inconsiderate parking. Their were cars parked unsafely everywhere. So good work ACT govt for making sure people try harder next time.

astro2 astro2 7:08 am 20 Nov 19

Andrew O’Brien, sorry mate but my kids’ safety is more important then your convenience to park wherever you want to.

Jeremy Coghlan Jeremy Coghlan 1:29 pm 19 Nov 19

Canberrans love to park cars on nature strips; it's always been illegal, but we've always done it. In fact, if you park on the road - which is legal- you'll be judged harshly by your peers.

Acton Acton 12:36 pm 19 Nov 19

I really miss those long ago days when we lived in a society where people were kind to each other and understood that school fetes are an important community event, existing parking is never adequate and once a year people park a little differently. But we elected an ACT Government bereft of common sense, lacking discretion, focused on revenue raising at any opportunity and rigidly enforcing its petty socialist rules and ideology. You voted for them.

    bj_ACT bj_ACT 3:20 pm 21 Nov 19

    I think you have made the key point.

    A once a year Fete in Kambah isn’t the time to do a one off parking blitz. I agree poor parking is bad and dangerous. But this kind of parking happens all over Canberra and is ignored all the time.

    As for this particular school fete. There used to be spillover parking in the neighbouring Public School (coincidently named Mt Neighbour primary). But hey the ACT government got rid of this school, the playground, the basketball court, the oval and the car park for multi unit development. I guess the Government can raise a few extra bucks now that they don’t accept developers donations.

    BlowMeDown BlowMeDown 9:27 am 22 Nov 19

    Apparently patrons should be “active traveling” to these events and leaving the cars at home. Or catching a bus?

    I would also guess that a number of the cars being booked belong to organisers and stall holders trying to leave room for patrons to park legally.

Richard Robinson Richard Robinson 12:08 pm 19 Nov 19

Can so the people who think it's a safety issue please tell me when someone was hurt at a school fete because of illegal parking?

Martin McMaster Martin McMaster 10:54 am 19 Nov 19

were at Weetangera Fete on Sunday

Elliot Maroney-O'Brien Elliot Maroney-O'Brien 10:53 am 19 Nov 19

A new low for the ACT parking infringement infringement group. Disguising revenue raising at its "best". Didn't think they could stoop any lower!

James Forge James Forge 10:08 am 19 Nov 19

I don't agree with the "don't speed and you won't get a fine " brigade because it's easy to unintentionally slip a couple of KM over the speed limit but the same does not apply to illegal parking.

That is something people do by conscious choice

Peter O'Brien Peter O'Brien 8:07 am 19 Nov 19

I actually have no problem with this. A fete is, by its very nature, full of young children.... Parking legally is important to ensure their safety. Last thing we want is a child running out from between illegally parked cars where they can't be seen, especially since speed restrictions won't be in place as they are during school hours. It really isn't that hard to walk half a block and not get a fine

    Andrew O'Brien Andrew O'Brien 9:37 am 19 Nov 19

    Peter O'Brien yeah, if you had children you'd understand haha.

    The cars parked aren't usually next to the fete and kids don't just go wildly running around the cars (with parents), people park next to other cars on the school grounds or along front of houses on the streets next to them usually.

    The thing is these act vans loiter around school zones and try to get parents $$ (often doing volunteering) at these times on Sundays etc is pretty bad. None of it is dangerous parking.

    It's bad enough weekdays when parents can't find a car spot and park on a verge on the school grounds for a few minutes. I've seen the vans go do consecutive loops in and out trying to get $$. It's not "illegal", it's parents trying to drop off or take their kids to/from school and school events. I'm lucky I live 3 min walk to the kids school.

    It all sounds fine ideally, but then you see their tactics and it's clear it's largely revenue raising. They know the hot spots where they can catch people/parents out.

Glenn Beaumaris Glenn Beaumaris 7:16 am 19 Nov 19

another week and another story about people complaining about parking fines. it's simple really - don't break the law.

    Mick Graham Mick Graham 6:57 am 20 Nov 19

    No tram to Kambah mate so everyone had to drive 😉

Victor Armstrong Victor Armstrong 7:07 am 19 Nov 19

Money hungry act government. End of story...

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top

Search across the site