The ‘exotic weeds’ that saved a Braidwood truffle forest from destruction

Genevieve Jacobs 10 March 2020 20
Peter Marshall

Terra Preta silviculturist and truffle grower Peter Marshall believes deciduous forest saved his truffiere. Photo: Genevieve Jacobs.

Peter Marshall has never been afraid to stir the pot. He reckons that decades of experience as a silviculturist, some impeccable qualifications in forestry and a globally successful truffle-growing operation back him up pretty solidly.

Peter has long argued that a focus on exclusively native planting is misguided: he goes as far as to call it a “nativist pogrom”, and he says that when the Currowan fire hit his property Terra Preta, near Braidwood, the proof was in the fire’s behaviour.

There was plenty at stake: Terra Preta is one of the most productive truffle operations in Australia, exporting over 300 kg of high-quality black truffles annually to chefs in Paris, New York, Los Angeles and Tokyo from the shadow of the Monga Forest.

For decades, Peter has planted a mosaic of trees including his truffle bearing hazelnuts and oaks, but also poplars and willows, and up to 30 bamboo varieties. His aim is to restore the property’s capacity to retain water at all levels, moving it gently through the soil profile rather than streaming off degraded, heavily compacted land.

Peter takes up the story via email: “For months we had been working ourselves silly to get Reidsdale Valley ready, cutting access to Monga Park and shifting fuel away from the forest edge. The Currowan Fire came screaming at us out of Monga forest [creating] feelings of imminent doom. I thought we would lose everything.”

But what happened next surprised everyone, including the local firefighters.

“It hit the bladed lines then the oaks plantation, dropped from crown to ground and went silent. Then out,” Peter says.

“Experienced firefighters were speechless with amazement, then swung into their trucks and headed for the next crucial point. Our deciduous forest released firefighting resources to operate at critical points elsewhere.”

Peter’s reasoning is that even a fire roaring uphill with a good draft will pause when it hits green trees. He estimates that a mature poplar, for example, is carrying 100 to 200 kg of water. As the fire and the trees interact, there’s a burst of flash evaporation from the greenery that absorbs heat. Peter says updraft wind will drop almost instantly under those conditions.

The wind controlling effect of banked deciduous foliage also worked to dramatically slow the fire’s spread and, three rows in, the blaze became controllable with groundwork and shovels.

“Trees [were] exploding and falling up in the eucalypts for days. A4 [-sized] chunks of burning bark [were] falling on us. Nearly all were self-extinguished by the boundary layer, the rest we swatted. Pretty work at night,” Peter says.

The irony for Peter is that his poplars began as rooted cuttings from trees marked for destruction when the ACT Government determined the species were weeds.

“A designed fire retardant landscape worked as planned. Silvicultural decisions made 30 years ago and exotic tree genetics we saved from the nativist pogroms saved our valley. I am amazed, too.

“Our native forest on Ironstone Hill … was saved from the fire by the bands of deciduous trees. It is now full of wildlife seeking refuge.”

Peter is a firm believer that the “native good, exotic bad” message has got out of hand among land-carers.

He’s deeply critical of what he describes as a belief that willows, poplars and oaks are invasive weeds, arguing that “random mixes of ‘natives’, many from a thousand kilometres away, have no silvicultural logic”, and describing wide belts of native planting running east-west as “frightening fire wicks, threatening to outflank firefighters at any time”.

At Terra Preta, the use of non-inversion tillage techniques has restored the soil’s ability to hold water, while biochar produced from coppiced biomass restores the soil’s fungal communities.

Peter points out that in pre-European times, these relationships were nurtured by massive numbers of now-extinct small marsupials, from bettongs to woylies and potoroos who trawled the forest floor looking for native truffle species and churning over soil and mulch. Forest floors were constantly damp and continually composting as a consequence.

He’s arguing for a “war footing” effort to eliminate feral predators, reintroduce native burrowers, thin out crowded forests and enrich forest floors.

“The situation is dire,” Peter says in reference to our degraded and water-resistant landscapes.

“We don’t have another 20 years to waste on discredited ideology. Native or exotic trees, my family will use every tool available to protect our land.”


What's Your Opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
20 Responses to The ‘exotic weeds’ that saved a Braidwood truffle forest from destruction
Steve Taylor Steve Taylor 7:37 am 11 Mar 20

I worked on the Braidwood fire (and many others). The area that this article talks about was mainly affected by a flanking fire (lower fire severity), so it did not crown in the exotic trees. The head fire (highest fire severity) did not distinguish between native or exotic trees. In those locations both native and exotic trees burnt. As an example, this is a photo of where a crown fire occurred in Poplars at the Pialligo fire near the airport. The head fire raced through this area: https://inaturalist.ala.org.au/observations/39725365

Stuart Charlton Stuart Charlton 10:31 am 09 Mar 20

Exotic trees aren’t weeds anyway…. Put anything in the wrong place and it can be a weed, even natives or food crops !

Stuart Charlton Stuart Charlton 10:28 am 09 Mar 20

The same happened with the Mt Macedon Fires back in the 1980s Destroyed many beautiful gardens but the moisture content of the Large deciduous trees acted like a Mist of water, nullified and slowed the flames and saved buildings That would have been lost … The trees did not survive, but they slowed the fire .. I guess it would depend on individual circumstance and fire ferocity , wind etc, but its worth noting .

Steve Taylor Steve Taylor 10:01 am 09 Mar 20

I worked on the Braidwood fire. That area was mainly affected by a flanking fire (lower fire severity), so it did not crown in the exotic trees. The head fire (highest fire severity) did not distinguish between native or exotic trees. In those locations both native and exotic trees burnt. As an example, this is a photo of where a crown fire occurred in Poplars at the Pialligo fire near the airport. The head fire raced through this area: https://inaturalist.ala.org.au/observations/39725365

Cary Elliot Johnson Cary Elliot Johnson 6:59 am 09 Mar 20

The NSW Environmental Minister has recently said they we be considering suggesting steps be introduced across the State similar to those implemented at Mulloon Estate

Sue Sutton Sue Sutton 9:00 pm 08 Mar 20

Hardly weeds

Karen Butler Karen Butler 5:44 pm 08 Mar 20

Petrina more evidence for your plant like England cause. My uncle told me these facts 30 yrs ago.

Gail Langendorf Gail Langendorf 10:38 am 08 Mar 20

Rosemary Blemings interesting article

    Rosemary Blemings Rosemary Blemings 7:23 pm 08 Mar 20

    Yes indeed Gail and thanks for forwarding it. I suppose so much depends on managing any spread of these species into areas that should retain native vegetation. And who would be game enough to define what "should" grow where?

    Gail Langendorf Gail Langendorf 7:34 pm 08 Mar 20

    Right. Tough call. Even managing the spread is hard, as we know.

    Rosemary Blemings Rosemary Blemings 7:38 pm 08 Mar 20

    Exactly...

Liz Tilley Liz Tilley 10:19 am 08 Mar 20

Farmer Peter Andrews, who has since created The Mulloon Institute, has a similar approach with his natural sequence farming approach. And on Canberra’s doorstep!!! Australian Story has been following him for several years https://www.abc.net.au/austory/hope-springs/10395974

Maxine Mellie Maxine Mellie 1:09 am 08 Mar 20

totally agree

Lisa LaMaitre Lisa LaMaitre 10:45 pm 07 Mar 20

So much info in this article! Thank you for writing this article!

Gee Jay Gee Jay 8:27 pm 07 Mar 20

Edward Largarhands same sort of this when the fire hit your Leighton greens!

    Janet Barling Janet Barling 10:52 am 08 Mar 20

    Gee Jay / Edward Largarhands can I ask how the Leighton Greens coped in the fires?

Jenni Harding Jenni Harding 5:58 pm 07 Mar 20

Should be required reading for every pastoralist, gardener and farmer

Sandra Naden Sandra Naden 4:33 pm 07 Mar 20

Keith Naden, really interesting.

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

 Top
Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site