14 November 2024

What should we do about Kevin? Shadow Foreign Minister says forgive him

| Chris Johnson
Join the conversation
30
Kevin Rudd

Kevin Rudd’s role as Australia Ambassador to the United States is at risk due to his old social media posts about Donald Trump. Photo: Kevin Rudd, Facebook.

Shadow Foreign Minister Simon Birmingham believes Australia’s Ambassador to the United States Kevin Rudd should remain in the job despite previously criticising president-elect Donald Trump.

But not all the Coalition’s ranks agree. Another senior Liberal suggests the former Labor prime minister should prepare to exit his Washington posting.

Speaking at the National Press Club this week, Mr Birmingham was quite generous towards the foreign policy approaches of previous Australian governments from both sides of politics and weighed in on the security of Mr Rudd’s tenure.

Mr Rudd has used social media to describe Mr Trump as an enemy to democracy and a “traitor” but has since deleted those posts out of respect for the Executive Office of the President.

The Shadow Foreign Minister said those comments should stay in the past and believed Mr Trump would be quite forgiving even though the president-elect said during the presidential campaign that Mr Rudd wouldn’t last long in the job.

Mr Birmingham said while he was keeping an open mind about Mr Rudd’s future, he wanted to see him succeed in the role.

READ ALSO Policy rumblings begin in Australia following the US election

He noted Mr Trump had appointed a running mate and other senior members of his team who previously heavily criticised him.

“Hopefully, the type of forgiveness that has been demonstrated to those members of the new administration will be extended in this case as well,” Mr Birmingham said.

“Ambassador Rudd and the Prime Minister are the ones who are in the box seat to best make the assessment in coming weeks or months about how effectively he is going to be able to continue to have the influence and get the outcomes that Australia needs.”

Mr Birmingham said both he and Opposition Leader Peter Dutton “have wanted to see Kevin Rudd succeed all along”.

But he added Prime Minister Anthony Albanese knew the “risks” of appointing Mr Rudd as ambassador to Washington at a time when Mr Trump had declared his intention to run for president again.

Mr Dutton has subsequently suggested Mr Rudd could be on borrowed time, pointing out his appointment was a “captain’s pick” and some inside the Labor Party were now briefing against the ambassador.

Shortly after Mr Birmingham’s address, WA Liberal Senator Dean Smith broke ranks with his party to suggest Mr Rudd should be recalled.

“I don’t think Kevin Rudd is operating from a position of strength at the moment,” Mr Smith said during a radio interview.

“If I was the foreign minister, I’d probably ask him to pack his bags…

“I just don’t think he’s up to the job anymore.”

READ ALSO The ‘real’ phone call between Trump and Albo

Acting Prime Minister Richard Marles said Mr Rudd was highly successful as Australia’s ambassador and had worked “across the entire political spectrum” in Washington.

He maintained the Australian Government’s confidence in Mr Rudd and said we were “well placed to advance our interests” with the future Trump administration.

“Kevin has been really important in terms of introducing us to a number of figures who may play a part in the Trump administration going forwards,” Mr Marles said.

“I really have no doubt that once President Trump is sworn in again, Kevin will be able to play a really important role representing Australia… to that administration.”

A key member of Trump’s transition team – and former deputy White House chief of staff – Daniel Scavino Jr, fuelled speculation over Mr Rudd’s position by reposting the ambassador’s statement on X that he had deleted his old Tweets. Mr Scavino Jr added a gif of an hourglass suggesting time was running out for Mr Rudd.

Former Liberal prime minister Tony Abbott came to Mr Rudd’s defence, saying the US administration should not be prescribing who can and can’t be Australia’s ambassador to Washington.

Another former Liberal prime minister Malcolm Turnbull, who took Mr Trump to task over refugee intakes when he was president in his first term, also said Mr Albanese should stick with Mr Rudd.

“I didn’t have success with Trump as prime minister because I kissed his arse,” Mr Turnbull told the media.

“You have to be tough.”

Join the conversation

30
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Having worked with the man I can confirm two things; the man is a complete megalomaniac, but he gets things done.

Ambassadors are messengers and representatives, if he sticks to the script hell be fine. This is the risky part, there is no one at DFAT that can control him.

If Trump doesn’t personally like him that will limit the number of opportunities we gets to meet with Trump/Amercia during his time, also another problem.

Everyone thinks Trump is a nut case but as a public official, least not as an Ambasador, you just can’t go around mouthing off like that. This is not the Kevin Rudd show and you keep you opinions to your self.

Regardless of my thoughts it will fall to Simon Birmingham to make this decision in 2025.

Penny Wong has been MIA for much of her time as foreign minister, I really thought she’d be a lot more effective in this role but I can’t point my finger to a single achievement.

She’s too busy trying to outdo Albanese with multi million dollar real estate purchases

Capital Retro8:51 am 18 Nov 24

Like Rudd, Wong is seeking a sinecure with the UN. She has all the right qualifications.

@Futureproof
Interesting, Fp, that 2GB’s Ben Fordham, hardly known for being a lunatic lefty, didn’t see an issue with the purchase, stating “… the property wasn’t a flashy, mega-mansion, but that it was just a beautiful home in a popular area that highlights what $3.4 million can afford in the current housing climate.”

Is it just a case of the green-eyed monster for you?

@Capital Retro
Yes, CR, Wong is probably as qualified for a UN role as (former Liberal Senator) Cormann was for the role of Secretary-General of the OECD in 2021.

Be careful who you call a village idiot -the last laugh may be on you!

Both major parties use ambassadorships as jobs for the boys…that should stop.

However, Rudd is there now, and historically, backing down to Trump does not win any favours; quite the opposite. Like most bullies Trump preys on weakness and fears strength.

Get Rudd and his ego out of there, he has damaged our relationship with the US. He was given the job by Albo because he is a mate of his. How can we expect Trump to do us any favours when our ambassador has insulted him on numerous occasions, not just once? Australia’s interests must come before Rudd’s. Can we make him the ambassador to Russia…please?

“How can we expect Trump to do us any favours”…Australian MAGAs already trying to make Australia subservient to their orange God.

If they don’t like Australia they can always leave.

@dazzer
Apparently Rudd has worked amicably with both sides of US Congress to progress the AUKUS partnersip legislation passed. Not sure how that has you conclude “he has damaged our relationship with the US”

It really depends what kind of personality you want in the position as being representative of national character. Rudd comes across as smug and full of himself. If that’s the image Australia wants to project, go for it.

Our best ambassador would be someone with personal connections to Trump. Rudd’s undiplomatic comments will cause residual suspicion, contempt and antagonism, disqualifying him as an effective ambassador to the new administration. A better ambassador is not going to be a career diplomat or former politician, but someone Trump knows personally, respects, even trusts. Having a business background would be ideal. Someone like Anthony Pratt. Trump and Pratt previously enjoyed a good relationship and in 2019 the then president helped open a new Pratt Industries plant in Ohio. Trump at the time called Pratt a “friend” and heaped praise on him. There are other Australians with business and personal connections to Trump who have wisely had the maturity and intelligence to resist the self indulgent contagion of TDS.

@Acton
“Trump at the time called Pratt a “friend” and heaped praise on him.”
Hmmm … not sure that is still the case.

You may recall the 60 Minutes report of Pratt revealing his discussions on ‘sensitive matters’ with Trump. Trump has dismissed those accounts, posting on social media that the stories “about a red haired weirdo from Australia, named Anthony Pratt, is Fake News.”

Seems like there’s people on both sides of the aisle who have attracted bad publicity when it comes to Trump.

If Vance can call Trump ‘America’s Hitler’ and then become VP, I think Rudd’s comments are not worth noting. Besides, Trump is an adjudicated rapist, convicted felon, insurrectionist, pathological liar and sociopathic narcissist, why ANYONE would have ANYTHING positive to say about him is extraordinary.

We should do nothing. The former PM, Mr Rudd, should do something. My suggestion is resign the role, reiterate his analysis of Mr Trump (with which I wholeheartedly agree, by the way) and allow the current PM to appoint a new ambassador who can help Australia face the incoming tsunami of chaos.

Mr Rudd has become a story and a lightening rod. We don’t really need that.

Mr Rudd may be a good appointment for Beijing, or he could just ‘do a Julia’ and move on. I wish him well.

You would have to be an absolute idiot to be a diplomat in another country and slag off publically about politics in that to country. What a fool

@Futureproof
Do you realise that Rudd made those comments before he was given the US ambassadorship, Fp – i.e not while he was a diplomat?

He made his bed by mouthing off without any forethought. He should just be sacked. We certainly can’t keep him as an ambassador under the circumstances.

And yet Vance called Trump, ‘America’s Hitler’ and is now VP-elect. Funny world isn’t it.

It is, but Vance doesn’t have the job of being an outsider trying to gain favour for his nation.

There seems to be a need to rethink on the appointment of former politicians, by governments on both sides of the ideological spectrum, to the position. In recent times we’ve seen Kim Beazley (2010 – 2016), Joe Hockey (2016 – 2020), Arthur Sinodinis (2020 – 2023) and Kevin Rudd (2023 – present). It’s almost like it’s a ‘reward for your service’ to our party.

The reality is that the ambassador represents the Australian government in the US, and irrespective of what the government may think of Trump, he will be the US president from January next year.

Rudd’s future in the position is probably untenable, given the adverse publicity his purported ongoing tenure is attracting – and that publicity is not going to go away, especially as it’s clickbait for the right aligned press in both countries.

However, the issue is that Albo will probably dismiss the ‘furore’, as politically motivated conservative noise, and delay the (arguably) inevitable decision. The longer the debate continues, the harder it will be for the incoming incumbent to establish a rapport with the Trump administration.

Logic would suggest, it’s time for the appointment of an overtly and demonstrably non-partisan ambassador, acceptable to both sides of the aisle. Sadly, logic and politics very rarely play nicely together.

Rudd in Australia is bad for Albo

There are strict prohibitions on officials voicing political opinions online. Junior APS staff have lost their jobs over this. Why then is Rudd exempt? If it was a career DFAT officer who had done this, he would have been pulled long ago. Irrespective of the implications to the bilateral relationship, there needs to be a consistent approach to all. For that reason, he should decamp Dupont Circuit now.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.