Let’s get behind Ricky

Tim Gavel 31 July 2018 17

Ricky Stuart on the sideline during the Raiders loss to the Melbourne Storm last weekend. Photos: Supplied by Canberra Raiders.

As sure as night follows day, the messages started flowing through.

Many were along the lines of “it’s Ricky Stuart’s fault,” or, “why aren’t the Raiders in the market for any big name players next season? It’s the fault of the coach that the side won’t make the finals for the second season in a row.”

This was after the substantial loss to the Melbourne Storm on Saturday where supporters vent their spleen on social media. It has become the medium of choice for fans to express their frustrations immediately after games.

There was little consideration of the fact that the Raiders had four key players ruled out, or that a prop ended up playing in the centres. The Raiders, against a side such as the Storm, can ill-afford to be without key players, coupled with the lack of discipline displayed on the night.

Is the lack of discipline the entire fault of the coach as was expressed so eloquently on social media, or do the players need to take some responsibility? The coach, it would seem, is called upon to take the brunt of the criticism.

There is almost an insinuation that the coach has not done all he can to ensure the side is prepared, or that he doesn’t take losses as badly as they do.

I had a chat with Ricky Stuart at the airport on the way home. He takes losses harder than anybody I have seen in 30 years of covering sport in Canberra. I get the impression that he takes it personally such is his competitive nature.

And it doesn’t end with analysis by fans and critics alike after the game. At the airport, on arrival home, you can sense people wanting to have their say, although most keep their space. It is not as if he has done anything wrong, but because of his profile, the judgement is very public. It is even more so with social media where people can say things without a filter and seemingly without feeling for the person under attack. He seems to be a magnet for non-Raiders supporters as well, as they sense a bit of blood in the water. For them, it’s a chance to put the boot in at every opportunity, especially after a big loss.

Wherever he goes in Canberra everybody, it seems, wants to provide some free advice. It is a job like no other where you are judged on a weekly basis, but take a step back for a moment: is there another sphere of life where there is such a contrast between the highs and lows than the life of a professional sportsperson or a coach?

Heading out to Raiders’ training, the atmosphere after a win is completely different than after a loss; there is no middle ground. After the loss to the Sharks, the mood was sombre, to say the least. It was Ricky’s job to get the players’ minds around to playing the following week.

The result then dictates much of the questioning for the following week in the lead-up to the next game. If they win, it’s along the lines of maintaining the momentum, while if it’s a loss, how are you going to turn things around? This goes for 24 weeks or longer if the side makes the finals.

People only see the coach and the players on match day or in media sessions through the week. There is so much more going on behind the scenes. In the case of the Raiders, there are seemingly constant negotiations with players and player managers about not just next season but the season after that. There has been the Jack Wighton affair; juggling the salary cap; player injuries; and players leaving, such as Charlie Gubb, mid-season. Explaining the salary cap and why the Raiders won’t be in the market for high profile players next season after losing Boyd, Austin and Paulo, is taking a fair bit of oxygen at the moment.

It is simply relentless.

Most high profile coaches will tell you that it is hard to switch off and mentally get away during the season, especially this one for the Raiders with so many highs and lows. Even during the off-season, there is little chance to avoid scrutiny as disappointment turns to expectation.

Knowing Ricky Stuart as I do, he is thinking 24/7 about the Club, the past game, the game ahead, and getting the best out of the players on and off the field. As Raiders supporters, we should be grateful to have somebody as passionate and committed in our corner.

What's Your Opinion?

Please login to post your comments, or connect with
17 Responses to Let’s get behind Ricky
Keran Niquet Keran Niquet 4:18 pm 02 Aug 18

Why? He was a great player, is passionate about the game and his team, but he is just NOT a good coach!

Anne Willenborg Anne Willenborg 7:33 am 02 Aug 18

Passionate is right, and at the end of the day he has done so much for the canberra community at large. Admit, being a raiders fan is frustrating but we all know that he wants to win just as much as everybody else, so part of the excitement is that it will happen this Saturday, or the next or the next after that😃.always behind Ricky a hundred percent.

Steve Anderson Steve Anderson 9:01 pm 01 Aug 18

For the quality of player he’s got at his disposal, he’s not doing a bad job. Sitting 10th but with a positive for and against. We’ve been in almost every game this year and with a bit of luck, could be sitting pretty in the top 4. There has been games where the players are to blame but there has also been some shocking calls by the ref. Look at the ponies, they’ve been handed 3 games by refs. To get a quality player, Brisbane pay 800k plus 3rd parties. To come to Canberra, your paying 1.1, 1.2 mil with no 3rd parties. Hard to fill the rest of your rooster with decent players when you paying that much for 1.

David Vickers David Vickers 7:05 pm 01 Aug 18

We know he is an old Canberra hand, a good man and a great player. His current job is to coach a Rugby League team to success. He is failing to do this. It is not mean criticism it is a fact. He is not a charity case. He is a tough, tough man who can take it.

Paul Henson Paul Henson 5:42 pm 01 Aug 18

Not a solitary Raiders fan that is sane questions Ricky's commitment to the Raiders. He's a passionate Raiders man and we all love it.

Ricky was a fabulous footballer, but he is not a good coach. Records over an extensive period highlight this easily. His percentage of coaches that have coached over 300 games is near the bottom, let alone all the rep failures.

Ricky would be under pressure in any other job except here, where this small town rubbish media run scared like Gavel because they're either mates of Ricky, or they know if they question him the next spoon fed article won't come their way next week. This is bush club mentality and why we are who we are. This club has made the finals once in five years under Ricky's watch and a lot of that has been because of his coaching. He should be sacked. Not one media around here is saying a thing about it because they're muffled. Talk to some fans who actually know what's up with the club.

Andrew Baker Andrew Baker 4:45 pm 01 Aug 18

Great bloke and no-one can doubt his passion for the club but at the end of the day this is a results business.

Roberta Lynne Anning Roberta Lynne Anning 4:37 pm 01 Aug 18

We are grateful. 💙💚💛

David Abreu David Abreu 4:34 pm 01 Aug 18

Kirrin Pedron Adam Breasley good article

Ron Norton Ron Norton 4:04 pm 01 Aug 18

Very well said Tim. I’ve been a rugby league follower all my life and covered the code as a journalist for more than 50 of those years but in that time I have never seen a coach, or player, as committed to or passionate about his club than Ricky Stuart. For heaven’s sake, he can’t go out on the field and lead his team through every play. The players proved what they are capable of and how well they were prepared in the first few minutes of the second half of the game against Melbourne. If they had been that committed at the beginning of the game the result would have entirely different. It’s NOT the coach’s fault that they are not in the top 8.

Mike Long Mike Long 2:52 pm 01 Aug 18

If all clubs have the same salary cap why is it that clubs like Melbourne. Brisbane Bronco's Qld Cowboys are in the top half and Canberra are in the bottom half ?

    Stephen Page-Murray Stephen Page-Murray 3:11 pm 01 Aug 18

    Little to no TPA’s here. The NRL doesn’t have a true salary cap as such

    Meetal Nand Meetal Nand 9:25 pm 01 Aug 18

    TPA is a game changer and we don have it, it needs to change to even playing fields out

Roger Mungummary Roger Mungummary 2:37 pm 01 Aug 18

I plead guilty but their ability to lose from a seemingly winning position herald's a problem. Mind you after that horrific display of biased refereeing the other week you could just go watch AFL

David Pollard David Pollard 1:41 pm 01 Aug 18

Passion and commitment is great, and I’m a Ricky fan, but results are important too. I don’t know if Ricky is the coach to get us a premiership or not. He certainly came close, but we have not been finals contenders since then.

We do seem close, but with so many close losses, we have to figure out what is missing, and something is.

Tim Primmer Tim Primmer 1:33 pm 01 Aug 18

Great article, Ricky has the club at heart and is the best man for the job

Alanna Davis Alanna Davis 1:02 pm 01 Aug 18

I agree with you, Tim.

Jim9 Jim9 11:23 am 01 Aug 18

Just like Paul McGregor at the Dragons, I think Stuart gets off lightly with many because he is a former great player for the club. Frankly I’m far from convinced he really is that good a coach. He inherited a very good side at the Roosters in his first couple of seasons, and its been downhill ever since. His coaching stats as per below illustrate that (Not sure if the Raiders numbers are completely up to date – but close enough).

Years Team Gms W D L W%
2002–06 Sydney Roosters 130 79 1 50 61
2007–10 Cronulla Sharks 91 38 0 53 42
2013 Parramatta Eels 24 5 0 19 21
2014– Canberra Raiders 116 53 1 62 46

One can be as passionate, committed and whatever else as they like – but if at the end of the day they simply aren’t good enough, they simply aren’t good enough….. a 46% winning percentage isn’t going to win a Premiership in this day and age, which is ultimately what footy is about.

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter


Search across the site