Magistrate Burns – listen to your own

Special G 18 October 2008 4

Magistrate Burns has slammed prosecutors over the lenient treatment of a driver, high as a kite who drove deliberately into oncoming traffic in an effort to kill himself and seriously maiming the other driver. CT story is here.

Burns goes on to say how he should have been charged with the more serious offence which carries a 5 year penalty as opposed to only 12 months.

CT followed up the next day with this on the sentencing of the individual. The driver being sentenced to 7 months with the last 4 suspended. Leaving him only 3 months to serve. Makes you wonder what he was on about the day before.

Does anyone else see a problem with this?

What's Your Opinion?

Please login to post your comments, or connect with
4 Responses to Magistrate Burns – listen to your own
mdme workalot mdme workalot 8:27 am 20 Oct 08

I think the sentence will probably have more to do with precedent than the Magistrate changing his opinion of the offender…

And look on the bright side – 7 months (when the maximum penalty is 12 months) is a pretty damn good result for ACT Courts! It passes the magical 50% barrier…

BerraBoy68 BerraBoy68 3:36 pm 18 Oct 08

I regard the guy who was hit in this accident – his name was in the CT this week for those who were interested – as a good friend and workmate. He’s not been back to work since the accident and most likely won’t ever be coming back. He’s a sad loss to his workplace and we miss his company.

The guy that did this to him deserves nothing short of a very long term custodial sentence.

Swaggie Swaggie 12:54 pm 18 Oct 08

It seems to neatly sum up what’s wrong with the judicial system in this town but the Pollies seem determined to wave the flag of judicial independence and do nothing. Strange when Government gets its hooks into every other facet of our lives…

Gobbo Gobbo 11:37 am 18 Oct 08

Magistrate Burns is technically correct that the driver should have been charged under Section 29 of the Crimes Act (which actually imposes a maximum penalty of 5 years) as opposed to Section 6 of the Road Transport (Safety and Traffic Management) Act 199, which carries a maximum sentence of one year.

However, as Magistrate Burns was faced with a charge under a lesser offence, he should have considered using the maximum penalties applicable

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site