21 June 2013

Trouble at the markets?

| johnboy
Join the conversation
36

The ABC has a strange complaint about the Saturday Farmers Market getting too many punters in which is somehow bad for business:

Beef and lamb producer Phil McCormack, from Crookwell on the NSW Southern Tablelands, says his market sales have fallen by 25 per cent in the last 18 months.

Mr McCormack says the weekly event is no longer a traditional farmers market and management needs to rethink its approach.

“People are sitting around and it’s getting in the road of people who want to just come in and buy and go home,” he said.

“I think we need to get back to the roots of what a genuine farmers market is and it’s genuine farmers.

“They take the elements, they take drought, they take floods, they take fire, they take everything into account, where the people that cook in their houses and do whatever they do in their houses, they don’t take anything like that into account.”

Join the conversation

36
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

It won’t matter soon because there will not be many genuine farmers left. It will be for who ever what’s to pay for a stall. The people running this market have got to work with stallholders so this does not happen. Start listening. Before it’s all to late

Madam Cholet12:49 pm 24 Jun 13

damien haas said :

cbjcurtin said :

Madam Cholet said :

I’m always surprised by people’s capacity to believe that just because it comes from the farmers market that it is fresh, organic, better for us. From what I can see there is no requirement by the these markets for producers to demonstrate that their food is locally grown, not sprayed yesterday etc etc. I’ve certainly purchased stuff there, but I’m surprised that in the type of environment we live in these days in which we are regulated to within an inch of our lives concerning public health, that there is not more scrutiny.

There are some organic producers at the market, but it’s best to check, they have to have their certification displayed if they are selling organic produce. If its not certified organic, it’s grown conventionally using chemicals.

Low spray

Organic fertilizers used

And chemical free

Are marketing terms.

That said not everyone is looking for organic produce, and there are some great conventional growers at these markets, including Joe Vassello from Mowbray Park Produce and Others

All food is organic.

Well yes. But what most people don’t realise is that some chemicals are also organic and can be used in the production of ‘organic’ produce. Not all chemicals are synthetic. And with any chemical or item that you put on food during its production there needs to be time-frames that are adhered to before you can eat it – or in this case, send it to market. As far as I can see, the produce at the market undergoes no testing or QA process as the produce in the normal retail stream does. To get your produce into Woolies, for example, you need to be part of a QA program. Not saying it’s bullet-proof, just sayin.

It seems the world is filling with “In The Way People”. The malls, roads and carparks, now the markets. Those mindless wanderers with no spacial awareness who just plonk, or plod along totally oblivious of the carnage they cause around them.

And now here, it appears the markets are quickly becoming another haunt for the mindlessly ignorant.

Maybe the scope needs to be widened, maybe we, as a society need to start thinking about our impact on others, need to consider the inconvienances that mindless inaction causes others, or, at the very least, be mindful and apologetic when it’s unavoidable.

In the way people. Are you one of them?

Masquara said :

At least there’s some economic activity IN Canberra with the chocolate “reshaping”. Aforementioned Pilpel food importers don’t contribute a cent to the regional economy other than their stall fee. They combine their pre-processed ingredients in Sydney.

Yeah, thats at least 3 times you have mentioned Pilpel. Why dont you describe what your issue is

damien haas said :

All food is organic.

Unless you count salt as food.

pepmeup said :

What about local hand made chocolates? Grown in South America, processed in Europe, re shaped in Canberra and sold at the farmers markets.

At least there’s some economic activity IN Canberra with the chocolate “reshaping”. Aforementioned Pilpel food importers don’t contribute a cent to the regional economy other than their stall fee. They combine their pre-processed ingredients in Sydney.

damien haas said :

cbjcurtin said :

Madam Cholet said :

I’m always surprised by people’s capacity to believe that just because it comes from the farmers market that it is fresh, organic, better for us. From what I can see there is no requirement by the these markets for producers to demonstrate that their food is locally grown, not sprayed yesterday etc etc. I’ve certainly purchased stuff there, but I’m surprised that in the type of environment we live in these days in which we are regulated to within an inch of our lives concerning public health, that there is not more scrutiny.

There are some organic producers at the market, but it’s best to check, they have to have their certification displayed if they are selling organic produce. If its not certified organic, it’s grown conventionally using chemicals.

Low spray

Organic fertilizers used

And chemical free

Are marketing terms.

That said not everyone is looking for organic produce, and there are some great conventional growers at these markets, including Joe Vassello from Mowbray Park Produce and Others

All food is organic.

Including cheesy poofs?

http://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=cheesy+poofs

cbjcurtin said :

Madam Cholet said :

I’m always surprised by people’s capacity to believe that just because it comes from the farmers market that it is fresh, organic, better for us. From what I can see there is no requirement by the these markets for producers to demonstrate that their food is locally grown, not sprayed yesterday etc etc. I’ve certainly purchased stuff there, but I’m surprised that in the type of environment we live in these days in which we are regulated to within an inch of our lives concerning public health, that there is not more scrutiny.

There are some organic producers at the market, but it’s best to check, they have to have their certification displayed if they are selling organic produce. If its not certified organic, it’s grown conventionally using chemicals.

Low spray

Organic fertilizers used

And chemical free

Are marketing terms.

That said not everyone is looking for organic produce, and there are some great conventional growers at these markets, including Joe Vassello from Mowbray Park Produce and Others

All food is organic.

What about local hand made chocolates? Grown in South America, processed in Europe, re shaped in Canberra and sold at the farmers markets.

Re red caps, you can keep picking already ripe caps off a vine once winter starts but they stop producing new flowers, so yes you get one crop but not enough to sell each week at a market.

The farmers markets website has addresses for the farmers look them up on google earth/maps check it out and see if it looks like a commercial farm.

michcon said :

Food miles, and supporting the local economy is an important concept for some market goers and if they are going to be a bit relaxed about the geographical definition of the “capital region” then it should be stated nice and clear.

Two of the producers listed as legitimate marketeers are from 1100 and 1200 kilometres away … far northern NSW. I appreciate that if consumers want them, provision of tropical fruits has to be from far away, and if they are legitimate Australian producers I don’t personally care about the distance.

However, I do care about the Pilpel/Darikay company passing themselves off as producers of Australian food. The market rules should be applied, and the organisers should concentrate on kicking out folks like “Pilpel” who are making dips out of imported ingredients. The “Pilpel” case gives the impression that the “farmer’s” market is simply prepared to accommodate anyone who will turn a buck for them and pay for a space.

michcon said :

Masquara said :

Question was asked on 666 yesterday re the market: where are those ripe red capsicums on sale at this time of the season being grown? Not locally. Queensland was the commenter’s thesis. What IS the farmer’s market policy? I thought it was only for local growers?

Hmm, I was actually pulling capsicums off my backyard plants only a month ago, it really should be an impossible concept that they’d be grown in Sydney, or under a poly tunnel/hothouse. I have provided feedback to the market organisers before though – each stall holder should display a sign that states how far away the food is grown. Food miles, and supporting the local economy is an important concept for some market goers and if they are going to be a bit relaxed about the geographical definition of the “capital region” then it should be stated nice and clear.

Sorry – should NOT be an impossible concept.

michcon said :

Masquara said :

Question was asked on 666 yesterday re the market: where are those ripe red capsicums on sale at this time of the season being grown? Not locally. Queensland was the commenter’s thesis. What IS the farmer’s market policy? I thought it was only for local growers?

Hmm, I was actually pulling capsicums off my backyard plants only a month ago, it really should be an impossible concept that they’d be grown in Sydney, or under a poly tunnel/hothouse. I have provided feedback to the market organisers before though – each stall holder should display a sign that states how far away the food is grown. Food miles, and supporting the local economy is an important concept for some market goers and if they are going to be a bit relaxed about the geographical definition of the “capital region” then it should be stated nice and clear.

Masquara said :

Question was asked on 666 yesterday re the market: where are those ripe red capsicums on sale at this time of the season being grown? Not locally. Queensland was the commenter’s thesis. What IS the farmer’s market policy? I thought it was only for local growers?

Hmm, I was actually pulling capsicums off my backyard plants only a month ago, it really should be an impossible concept that they’d be grown in Sydney, or under a poly tunnel/hothouse. I have provided feedback to the market organisers before though – each stall holder should display a sign that states how far away the food is grown. Food miles, and supporting the local economy is an important concept for some market goers and if they are going to be a bit relaxed about the geographical definition of the “capital region” then it should be stated nice and clear.

moneypenny26127:48 pm 22 Jun 13

Madam Cholet said :

I’m always surprised by people’s capacity to believe that just because it comes from the farmers market that it is fresh, organic, better for us. From what I can see there is no requirement by the these markets for producers to demonstrate that their food is locally grown, not sprayed yesterday etc etc. I’ve certainly purchased stuff there, but I’m surprised that in the type of environment we live in these days in which we are regulated to within an inch of our lives concerning public health, that there is not more scrutiny.

Market rules are here: http://www.capitalregionfarmersmarket.com.au/downloads.html

While the managing committee does have some discretion about how large the ‘local’ region is (eg, there are pie makers and smallgoods stallholders who drive up from northern Victoria fortnightly), it is not unheard of for a stallholder to be ejected if they misrepresent the provenance of the products they sell.

I can think of at least two instances where stallholders were ejected because they claimed to be selling on behalf of regional growers when in fact they got their produce from a commercial wholesaler who supplies supermarkets.

Madam Cholet said :

I’m always surprised by people’s capacity to believe that just because it comes from the farmers market that it is fresh, organic, better for us. From what I can see there is no requirement by the these markets for producers to demonstrate that their food is locally grown, not sprayed yesterday etc etc. I’ve certainly purchased stuff there, but I’m surprised that in the type of environment we live in these days in which we are regulated to within an inch of our lives concerning public health, that there is not more scrutiny.

There are some organic producers at the market, but it’s best to check, they have to have their certification displayed if they are selling organic produce. If its not certified organic, it’s grown conventionally using chemicals.

Low spray

Organic fertilizers used

And chemical free

Are marketing terms.

That said not everyone is looking for organic produce, and there are some great conventional growers at these markets, including Joe Vassello from Mowbray Park Produce and Others

“Pilpel Fine Foods” are listed as a producer. They are NOT. Their products are marked “made in Australia” not “product of Australia”. Absolute lie.

shirty_bear said :

towerofsoup said :

So… I shouldn’t go to the markets?

I went to these markets once. *Once*.

The complaint centred around the markets having become more about coffee and cake, than about local fresh-to-market produce. Which, in my experience, is correct. And the coffee-and-cake brigade ain’t buying what produce is there, whilst making it relatively difficult for actual buyers to navigate the joint.

I thought his basic point was a fair one, even if (along with no help from the announcer/interviewer) clumsily put. No surprise, given that he’s a farmer; he only wants to see punters there for farm stuff.
They probably need two markets side by side – one for the farmers and and one for the crowd who want to kid themselves they’re shopping at a farmer’s market while they blankly slurp their coffee.

+1 billion…….that is exactly what needs to happen……..I want to go for the fresh produce (farm to us) and I resent having to navigate the blankly sipping latte crowd who are often totally unaware of their surroundings………..

Madam Cholet3:31 pm 22 Jun 13

I’m always surprised by people’s capacity to believe that just because it comes from the farmers market that it is fresh, organic, better for us. From what I can see there is no requirement by the these markets for producers to demonstrate that their food is locally grown, not sprayed yesterday etc etc. I’ve certainly purchased stuff there, but I’m surprised that in the type of environment we live in these days in which we are regulated to within an inch of our lives concerning public health, that there is not more scrutiny.

No problem at all beef and lamb producer Phil McCormack from Crookwell. I hear you loud and clear and will comply.

To ensure you have plenty of space around your stall, I will in future purchase my beef and/or lamb from one of the other producers.

Thanks for the heads-up and I am sorry to have previously been an inconvenience to you.

Question was asked on 666 yesterday re the market: where are those ripe red capsicums on sale at this time of the season being grown? Not locally. Queensland was the commenter’s thesis. What IS the farmer’s market policy? I thought it was only for local growers?

Crowds are a pain but it’s the only place to buy real fresh produce that lasts a week or longer.

Many of these suggestions are good though, it is a pain to shop when there are too many people for the venue to comfortably accommodate.

aidan said :

Translation: “Get off my markets!” ?

Farmer Palmer fan?

arescarti42 said :

I find the crowds at the farmers markets to be a total pain in the ass, and now go less frequently than I did previously.

Ditto, though I never go at all now.

I might suggest that he loses business because of his “buy your stuff and get out” attitude.

Good customer service goes a long way, bad customer service does too.

Maybe the punters are just getting confused between the Farmers’ Market and the Farmers’ Meerkat?

sepi said :

too many customers staying too long is a problem most venues would like to have.

they need to spread out a bit – they are at the showgrounds – how can it be too small.

or segregate a bit better – so the nutbag vegie hunters can get in, grab their southern highlands brussels sprouts and get out, without being shocked by the sight of someone in ironed clothing, and those who want to wander and smell the coffee and see what local produce is all about can do so at their leisure.

Or have the vegies start at 5am, and the coffee and cake and pies etc starting at 10.30, and going all day. I might even go to the markets if it was on in the afternoon….

Where does the insanity of mega early starts (5 am) come from? My goodness (or fcuk as others would say)…

too many customers staying too long is a problem most venues would like to have.

they need to spread out a bit – they are at the showgrounds – how can it be too small.

or segregate a bit better – so the nutbag vegie hunters can get in, grab their southern highlands brussels sprouts and get out, without being shocked by the sight of someone in ironed clothing, and those who want to wander and smell the coffee and see what local produce is all about can do so at their leisure.

Or have the vegies start at 5am, and the coffee and cake and pies etc starting at 10.30, and going all day. I might even go to the markets if it was on in the afternoon….

Comic_and_Gamer_Nerd5:48 pm 21 Jun 13

I go almost every week. It is no hassle to buy anything. Maybe his produce is not up to standards?

I’ve been shopping there regularly in the last 2+ years. We’re talking veggies, fruits, meats, breads, cheese, dips and the occasional sweet treat. So yeah, it’s not the hardcore market it used to be when you had to get up at 6am to do your shopping, but it’s still a very good market for fresh produce.

He has a beef.

Comic_and_Gamer_Nerd said :

Is he a half wit?

Not completely. I’m one of those people who want to get in, buy my stuff and GTFO and I know exactly the types of people he’s talking about. There are women dressed to the nines at 7:30am, an uncomfortably high number of posers or just gas baggers who clagg up the passages to the stalls doing nothing but exuding “look at moi, look at my organic bagel spinach”. It is, admittedly, part of the charm of the markets, but some people can overdo it.

towerofsoup said :

So… I shouldn’t go to the markets?

I went to these markets once. *Once*.

The complaint centred around the markets having become more about coffee and cake, than about local fresh-to-market produce. Which, in my experience, is correct. And the coffee-and-cake brigade ain’t buying what produce is there, whilst making it relatively difficult for actual buyers to navigate the joint.

I thought his basic point was a fair one, even if (along with no help from the announcer/interviewer) clumsily put. No surprise, given that he’s a farmer; he only wants to see punters there for farm stuff.
They probably need two markets side by side – one for the farmers and and one for the crowd who want to kid themselves they’re shopping at a farmer’s market while they blankly slurp their coffee.

Comic_and_Gamer_Nerd3:06 pm 21 Jun 13

Is he a half wit?

I thought that a market might have something to do with genuine customers, too. Why shouldn’t people ‘sit around’ if they want to?

Epic whinge.

So… I shouldn’t go to the markets?

I find the crowds at the farmers markets to be a total pain in the ass, and now go less frequently than I did previously.

I think what they need is to find a bigger venue where they can spread out a bit, or perhaps hold it on both Saturday and Sunday so they can split the crowd a bit.

Translation: “Get off my markets!” ?

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.