27 August 2024

Barr's 'utterly' failed Tuggeranong: Independents for Canberra candidate takes the long handle to Chief Minister

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
43

Dr Vanessa Picker wants to hit Chief Minister Andrew Barr for six. Photo: Independents for Canberra.

Independents for Canberra candidate for Brindabella Vanessa Picker won’t have a bar of the Chief Minister, but she won’t say what party she would support to form government if elected in October.

The former Labor Party member and campaigner for gender equality in cricket is hardly on the right of politics, but she says the people of Tuggeranong have spoken, and Andrew Barr should go.

“I wish to make it unequivocally clear: I do not, and will not, support Andrew Barr as Chief Minister of the ACT,” she said at the weekend.

“It’s also time for broader change after 23 years of the same government.”

Ms Picker said Mr Barr had failed Tuggeranong “utterly” and had turned a blind eye to the stories of neglect and harm in the community.

She described the recent $20 million package of promises for Brindabella as “last-minute, hollow gestures”.

He had “brazenly” admitted that it was motivated by his desire for Labor to reclaim the seat narrowly lost in the last election.

“This is not the conduct of a leader who genuinely cares about the people he serves; it’s the behaviour of someone clinging to power,” she said.

Ms Picker accused Mr Barr of blatant disregard for accountability, breaking a 2020 promise to step down as Treasurer.

She also resurrected rumours that Mr Barr would not last the full four years and was looking at federal politics, something he has denied.

“Labor must explain why they continue to back Mr Barr, despite the strong public sentiment against his leadership,” Ms Picker said.

“I urge my fellow independent candidates to join me in making this public commitment.

“We have a unique and critical opportunity to bring real accountability and meaningful change to the ACT. Let’s stand united in putting our communities first, above the vested interests and the influence of entrenched politicians.”

But she won’t commit to supporting any party before the election, saying that would “severely compromise my independence and my ability to respond to the evolving needs and views of our community”.

READ ALSO Shorten urges public to have confidence in NDIS changes

Mr Barr said on Monday that at least Dr Picker had been honest, and now Brindabella voters would know that a vote for her was a vote for a Liberal Government.

“That is the only way the Liberals have ever governed in the ACT, through the support of independents,” he said.

“So that risk is clearly there.”

Mr Barr said that people running for the crossbench who had no intention of seeking to actually form a government needed to be clear about which side of politics they were going to support.

“That’s the honest thing to do,” he said. “That’s the thing that independents with integrity would do, just indicate what they would do in that circumstance.

“Voters deserve to know where candidates stand on policy issues, and also on that pretty fundamental question because in our parliament, unlike any other in Australia, every single member on that first sitting day votes who the Chief Minister will be.”

Dr Picker’s comments come after the Canberra Liberals confirmed they were seeking a Barr lookalike to feature in campaign ads targeting the Chief Minister, adding to the perception that Labor’s opponents believe Mr Barr is on the nose with voters.

Join the conversation

43
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
Bennett Bennett8:42 am 28 Aug 24

What the ACT council-election needs less of are former public service staff, academics, major party rejects and socially progressive virtue signaling activists looking for a job in politics.

Most of the Labor party aren’t even aware that there are people living on the south side of the lake.

HiddenDragon8:54 pm 27 Aug 24

Aside from not being named Andrew Barr, and not wanting to be Treasurer as well, Vanessa Picker presumably has some ideas about what she wants from a new Chief Minister.

To the extent that those ideas are specific to Tuggeranong they may relate more to the municipal responsibilities of the ACT government than to the state-level responsibilities, with the former being an area of little evident interest on the part of the Barr government – except in the months before an election, and/or as a vehicle for engaging in virtue-signalling intrusions into domestic and community life in the Canberra suburbs.

Some ideas (preferably of a relatively specific nature) about municipal issues would be a useful addition to this webpage –

https://www.independentsforcanberra.com/policy

You can spin Dr Picker’s comments all you like Thomas Emerson but the fact is she has been out there and quite clear in the media during the past week exposing your party’s hostility towards the CM and his government. She has also highlighted your party’s anti-government agenda by refusing to support Andrew Barr as leader should you win balance of power.

You do not demand who should be party leader, the party decides!

Again you are revealing your naivety and lack of understanding of democracy and our parliament’s decision-making processes. You are also disregarding the clear will of the people who have voted for Labor should the party win government.

Dr Picker has revealed that a vote for IFC is a vote for the Liberals, with your party justly earning the title “Stooge independents”!

Thomas Emerson9:38 pm 27 Aug 24

That’s not true; all MLAs vote on who will be Chief Minister. I haven’t come out in support of Dr Picker’s position so what you are attributing to me is inaccurate – she issued this statement independently in response to the scale of disappointment with the current Chief Minister among people in Tuggeranong.

Your perception of the CM’s unpopularity in Tuggeranong will be tested in 53 days Thomas Emerson.

Labor came within 83 votes of winning a third seat in Brindabella last election. Brindabella was one of the Liberals strongest strongholds in the ACT at the time with the party holding three seats, going on to lose one of its most high-profile members.

The Liberals current line-up of candidates are the most socially conservative the party has ever put forward in an election.

Your perceptions might be a little premature!

Jack D,
You mistake dislike of the Liberals for support of Labor.

Andrew Barr’s name also wasn’t on the ballot in Tuggeranong.

The CM ran in Kurrajong as I am well aware chewy. He received the highest vote in the territory, the only candidate to reach a quota. Elizabeth Lee, now Liberal leader and the most high-profile candidate to run in the electorate couldn’t even reach a quota with preferences. Her belligerent and high-profile running mate Candice Burch was defeated humiliatingly, leaving the party with only Elizabeth who was rewarded with the leadership!

The Canberra Liberals refuse to treat Canberrans with respect, again running on a campaign of negativity against the CM and his government in every electorate. The party relies on gimmicky policy announcements and one-off payments and voucher schemes in their attempts to win elections. It is becoming very boring as we see this same practice being played out, time and time again, with the party relying on mud-slinging and silly stunts and slogans because they have no policy substance.

I think Labor’s success has something to do with its progressive social policies and the party’s commitment to extend light rail to Tuggeranong. Committed to providing southside residents with the same benefits that northside residents are now enjoying from light rail and which the Liberals refuse to commit to.

Maybe you should get on board chewy!

Jack D,
Why would I get on board with the ALP/Greens and their woeful incompetentce?

A government who treat the ACT voters with disdain and promote unaffordable and inequitable projects as you have freely admitted yourself.

Thankfully chewy the majority of Canberrans have a more broadminded sense of progress in this city than you!

Liberal supporters such as you will continue to snarl and snicker from the sidelines while the party continues its backward march and fades into the future!

Hack D,
Seeing as im not a Liberal party supporter and regularly denigrate them on these pages, you seem confused.

Which makes a whole lot of sense when considering your inability to argue the merits of the projects you support nor the government that you fawn over.

Disappointingly, there are far too many Hacks in Canberra, who are willing to accept mediocrity and incompetence in their government. Indeed some ever try to tell others that down is up and bad is good.

Barr is totally on the nose. He hasn’t delivered jack sh** in tuggeranong. We’re still waiting for Athllon drive to be duplicated and that $20 million is more of an insult than anything. Fix the roads mate. Kill the weeds growing out of the gutters, duplicate Athllon, fix the parks and water quality. Your integrity is shot and I do hope he goes into federal politics so he can take selfish with Albo and get voted into political oblivion.

Barr stoops so low as to attempt to smear a former Labor party member because she no longer supports him. Pretty gross! He claims that she is now a Liberal supporter when she’s made it clear that she’ll be supporting her constituents rather than a particular party. That’s how she’s able to be independent. Barr relies on his party, dominates it and drags them down with him. They’re all tainted as a result.

@psycho
Very fair observation

Interesting that Barr says “… the only way the Liberals have ever governed in the ACT, (is) through the support of independents”. Yet the only way Labor, under his stewardship, has governed is with the support of the Greens.

Too true and the Greens did not make the most of the situation, instead leaving all the power with Barr despite the number of seats they won. Really stupid.

Do we have to keep carping on about Tuggeranong all the time? There’s a lot of other areas in Canberra but there seems to be a squeaky wheel thing going on here and TBH the whining is getting a bit tedious.

It’s pretty much the opposite of a squeaky wheel, in that the government has knowingly disregarded the area for years because it’s not where ACT elections are won and the government knows they can rely on getting at least 2 seats regardless of what they do. Throwing a few scraps and repeated project announcements in the leadup to each election and then forgetting those promises afterwards.

It’s almightily ironic that you call this “whinging” whilst on these very pages you promote the exact projects that highlight the differences in funding and services provided across Canberra.

That’s the key point Chewy. When Tuggeranong Labor MLA’s leave politics, they are suddenly open to commenting about how hard it was to get any funding or support out of Barr for Tuggeranong and Woden.
There’s a strategic political approach to winning the key electorates that helps keep Labor in power (directly or with a Greens coalition).

It will be interesting to hear Joy Burch’s comments a year after the October election.

That’s the key point Chewy. When Tuggeranong Labor MLA’s leave politics, they are suddenly open to commenting about how hard it was to get any funding or support out of Barr for Tuggeranong and Woden.
There’s a strategic political approach to winning the key Canberra electorates that helps keep Labor in power (directly or with a Greens coalition).

It will be interesting to hear Joy Burch’s comments a year after the October election.

Thomas Emerson10:59 am 27 Aug 24

Dr Picker quite clearly stated that she wanted to see a change of Chief Minister but was not committing to supporting either prospective governing party at this point in time. Mr Barr’s comments in response, suggesting anyone unwilling to support him as Chief Minister must be intent on supporting a Liberal government, indicate that he can’t conceive of Labor being in power without him at the helm. In other words, he IS the Labor Party. If Mr Barr believes he and ACT Labor are one and the same, that only gives credence to the concerns we’ve voiced about there being too much power concentrated in Mr Barr’s office.

No Mr Barr, it is you who needs to be clear with the people before the election.

Will you form another alliance with the Greens to get the votes required to continue as Chief Minister?

How are you going to fix the budget you broke? The Pegasus Economics review of the ACT budget projects interest payments will be $832 million in 2027-28, which is $2.3 million every single day.

Barr talking about integrity is hilarious. He wouldn’t know what it was.

Agreed! And evidence based.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.