Confusion reigns over My Health: what do you need to know?

Genevieve Jacobs 15 November 2018 4

Despite an extended deadline, there’s still widespread confusion about what the My Health records will mean for you. File photo.

There’s been yet another last-minute change in the timeline for opting out of the My Health record, but it seems that many Canberrans and regional residents are still pretty confused about what they need to do and why.

You now have until January 31 to decide whether you want to to have a My Health record. Designed to enable ease of access across medical records, the plan has nevertheless been fraught with concerns over privacy and security.

Elizabeth Moss manages the digital health team for the Capital Health Network and says that after the opt-out was first announced mid-year, “People were very nervous about what it meant for them. We did a series of consumer seminars through the ACT Healthcare Consumers Association, and it seems all we’ve done for four months or more is talk to people about what options they have to manage the content.”

Moss says that after discussing which records could be uploaded and what controls patients have, most people are reassured that it’s a very limited set of documents. She believes the system can give people a level of health literacy and awareness about their own treatment that’s empowering, especially for people with complex chronic conditions who see many different healthcare providers.

But, she says, “I think there’s been a lack of any real nationwide publicity about the system and how it works. Beyond the launch in 2013, there really hasn’t been any national campaign to the public.”

Dr Emma Cunningham is the NSW president of the Rural Doctors Association of Australia and is based in Bombala. She says the concept of an easily accessible portal that could provide life-saving information is positive but agrees that the information about how My Health will work has been patchy at best.

“Anecdotally, we’re hearing that it’s quite difficult to navigate. There’s been a lack of community information about what it is and that it belongs to individuals, not their doctors or the government. The extra privacy steps have only been activated by a few people, and there’s a lack of knowledge about that too. We need to get the message out that people own their records, that they can look after them and they have control over their privacy.”

The RDAA made a submission mid-year to the government on the need for an urgent media campaign across the whole community about how the My Health record will operate. “Hopefully if there’s a delay now, there’s room for that to be done properly,” Dr Cunningham says. “We need to ensure there’s informed consent around the My Health records and a very clear outline of exactly what’s uploaded and who has access to that information.”

She’s concerned that people who don’t have computer access will have difficulties controlling their records, as will teenagers who have the right to access independent health care from the age of 14, but will still be on their parents’ Medicare cards which link to My Health records.

If you’re registered for a My Health record, you agree to allow your healthcare providers to upload health information about you on your record. You can choose to tell your healthcare provider not to upload specific information, or to remove information after it has been uploaded.

The record can also include PBS or Repatriation Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme claims; a Medicare Benefits Schedule or Department of Veterans Affairs claims; details from the Australian Immunisation Register and from the Australian Organ Donation Register.

You can also choose to record whether you are a veteran or indigenous, and the system allows you to create privacy access codes to restrict who can see your information. Parents can control their child’s My Health records if they are listed on the same Medicare card, and you can nominate a representative to access your record.

There have already been several key changes in the Federal government’s plans as a result of widespread concerns. Under a Bill going to the Senate this week, law enforcement agencies will need a court order to access the My Health records, and if someone cancels their record, the Australian Digital Health Agency must destroy it.

Further proposals to alleviate community concerns include increased penalties for improper use; preventing access to children’s records for people with family violence orders; preventing employers from requesting or using the records; and excluding insurers from accessing the information.

If you wish to opt out, you can visit, or call 1800 723 471.

Are you confused about how the My Health records will work and what your rights are?

What's Your Opinion?

Please login to post your comments, or connect with
4 Responses to Confusion reigns over My Health: what do you need to know?
Lucy Baker Lucy Baker 2:12 pm 18 Nov 18

So confusing. An interview on Radio National that was meant to make everything clear to everyone left me confused. Expert said that we will all have complete control over what is loaded – then admitted that a GP would be able to load information they think should be loaded for us. Then the expert said that we will all have to proactively manage our settings, keep an eye on what’s loaded, nominate who we do and don’t want to see which aspects and details of our records, it’s so granular. Without constant supervision and individual lockdowns on bits of data by each of us, there seems to be no limit on which hospital staff can see our records – wide open for abuse. The authorities know darn well that people will “set and forget”. I’m opting out.

Grant Tobias Grant Tobias 12:26 am 18 Nov 18

1. You're forced in with assumed consent unless you say otherwise. Imagine if society and sexual relationships operated in this manner - "sorry, I assumed it was OK to touch/grope/enter until you said no".

2. MyHR has been tried and abandoned in the UK where it was revealed the data being collected was being on-sold to big drug and insurance companies. People behind the failed UK program were brought to Australia set up MyHR here through the Australian Digital Health Agency, ADHA. The conclusion has to be that MyHR is a major misnomer that creates the illusion that it’s about patient care and control.

3. Researchers have default access to MyHR data for any study they wish to undertake. It is plausible that a study could find a certain geographical area drinks more than average or consumes more butter than others and suddenly these goods are taxed through the roof to manipulate a district into compliance, taking away your freedom.

4. If you don’t opt out by 15 November you are automatically in. They can do it without your informed consent.

5. When its up and running 900,000 health providers, including your podiatrist, will be able to legally access your entire MyHR – your medical history, results of all your tests, your medications and even things you may prefer to stay private eg episode of depression, an abortion etc.

6. GP’s will be paid to upload your private confidential medical records by up to $50,000 per year per medical practice. This is an incentive to GP’s to convince patients MyHR is a good idea for them. So bottom line GP’s are being financially encouraged to sell patient’s confidential data to the Government computer. This is clear a conflict of interest.

7. IT experts have raised serious concerns to the recent Senate Inquiry into the MyHR about the insecurity of the system and have pointed out the central computer system is using outdated technology.

8. The MyHR plan/initiative has been rolled out with bucket loads of money that could have been used by the cash-strapped Medicare budget. This money is being used to be win over doctors organisations, through dubiously informed seminars, to pay doctors to upload data and for a media blitz to put a positive spin on MyHR. If it’s so good why do we need to sell it to the medical profession?

9. Good health outcomes come from a properly funded Medicare that allows you to spend quality time with your doctor. Privacy and trust in the doctor is the most important element of the visit to your doctor – something that is being placed in jeopardy if we allow the Government to force our GP’s to create a mass medical database for the use of big pharma/big medical.

The MyHR is not about better health outcomes. It’s really about selling our confidential medical records down the line.

Richard Agent Richard Agent 11:55 am 16 Nov 18

No IT system is secure. It relies on people. And people make mistakes, are dishonest, and minimize their effort. When someone says ‘this is secure’ it generally means that they’ve stopped looking for problems.

The info in the Health record is worth billions to insurance companies, and the drug companies. Companies that can afford to hire the best hackers. Sorry, I mean people with previous experience working in the Australian Digital Health Agency MyHealth security area.

Grail Grail 2:56 pm 15 Nov 18

My Health Record is a carbon copy of the failed system trialled in the UK that was abandoned when customer records were “leaked” to private enterprise.

There are no data security measures baked into the design, the people who are building it only care about delivering the front end functionality on schedule. There is no way to stop someone with access to MHR records from giving your personal details to insurers, drug marketers or abusive ex-parters.

It’s a really bad idea, with the focus of discussion being on convenience for the user, rather than potential for abuse of the resource. We are heading into a Gattaca style future where people who have genetic predisposition to certain conditions will be paying more for health insurance (“preexisting conditions not covered”) or will be refused coverage outright.

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site