11 February 2025

Dutton likes what he sees Trump doing to the public service

| Chris Johnson
Join the conversation
14
Hon Peter Dutton MP

Opposition Leader Peter Dutton is closely watching how US President Donald Trump is unravelling the public service. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

Donald Trump is systematically and very deliberately implementing his grand scheme to decimate the United States federal bureaucracy.

Does Peter Dutton have similar plans for the Australian Public Service?

Not even a month into his term, the US president has established a faux agency, the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE). At best, DOGE is a temporary organisation, but the President has given it enormous powers.

DOGE isn’t a cabinet-level department, but with billionaire tech boss Elon Musk at the helm, it is riding roughshod over procedure and wielding power against legislated government agencies.

It was created by executive order the day Trump began his second stint as President and is scheduled to expire on 4 July 2026.

Its sole purpose, at the express wishes of the President, is to reduce “wasteful and fraudulent federal spending” and eliminate “excessive regulations”.

DOGE has already embedded teams of employees in a number of federal agencies and is going about deleting some.

It has accessed highly sensitive information from the Treasury Department, is crippling USAID and now has its sights on the Department of Education.

READ ALSO The National Press Club is not for the faint-hearted, Mr Dutton – just ask the PM

If Trump gets his way with the Education Department, the distribution of federal financial aid will be drastically reformed; education data will crumble; non-discrimination policies in schools will be a thing of the past; disadvantaged children will become more so; and loans and grants programs will be upended.

That’s just for starters.

Trump is pushing public servants to resign en masse.

He doesn’t like them – probably because most of them don’t like him – and he wants them out of the way.

While some US legislators and commentators are describing Trump’s assault on the bureaucracy as “stunning”, “alarming” and even “unlawful” – and even “a takeover”, “a freeze”, or “a coup” – Australia’s Federal Opposition Leader thinks the so-called “leader of the free world” is visionary and forward-thinking.

And we already know what Mr Dutton thinks about public servants in Australia.

The Opposition Leader, like the last Coalition PM Scott Morrison, derides the public service as wasteful and out of touch.

“Some public servant in Canberra” is a phrase often bandied about when trying to explain policy rollout the Opposition doesn’t like.

Dutton has promised to slash public service employment numbers if he becomes PM in this year’s election.

And, surprise, surprise, just days after Trump created DOGE, Dutton mirrored him by announcing a new Shadow Minister for the Government Efficiency portfolio, which NT Senator Jacinta Nampijinpa Price will oversee.

In doing so, Mr Dutton repeated his mantra that Australians are “sick of wasteful spending that is out of control” and said the employment of 36,000 new public servants was an example of such waste.

“In this new role, Jacinta will be looking closely at how we can achieve a more efficient use of taxpayers’ money, where possible, at a time when a major cause of homegrown inflation is rapid and unrestrained government spending,” Mr Dutton said about the new portfolio.

Just like DOGE, the new entity would not be a full-blown department but be rolled into the Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet if the Coalition wins office.

READ ALSO Time to review working from home – your office needs you

There’s no mention of mining billionaire Gina Rinehart, but she is certainly Australia’s equivalent to Elon Musk when it comes to influencing conservative politics.

Musk spent $200 million to help Trump get elected and now has control of the public service.

Will a similar scenario play out with Rinehart?

US Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer used Musk’s own social media platform X to express outrage at what the new administration is inflicting on the American public sector.

“Whatever DOGE is doing, it is certainly not — not — what democracy looks like or has ever looked like in the grand history of this country,” he tweeted.

“An unelected shadow government is conducting a hostile takeover of the federal government.”

But Musk replied, via the same medium: “Hysterical reactions like this is how you know that DOGE is doing work that really matters.”

It is all quite a spectacle to watch what is unfolding in America from so far away.

Yet it also seems too close for comfort.

Join the conversation

14
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

when Dutton looks in the mirror to shave (his head) does he see Donald?

Only the terminally thick think the US sends aid to other countries out of the goodness of their hearts.

They do it for soft power. The result of cuts to USAID will be that the USA’s adversaries will fill the void diminishing the USA’s power, prestige, security and economy. China must be rubbing their hands.

Impacts on the local economy will be immediately felt as the US farmers who were being paid to produce that food are left high and dry.

Meanwhile, in Australia, Dodgy Dutton if elected is promising to make the Australian taxpayer pay more for less when he replaces public servants with expensive consultants. Putting the dim Jacinta Price with her word salad answers in charge of this planned disaster will at least mix some comedy in with the tragedy.

Dutton is incapable of coming up with his own ideas. Lazy politics. And when they get rid of public servants, get ready for Robodebt version 2.

A bit like Albanese running the country like his mate Jeremy Corbyn would have, if elected

Lol funny stuff futureproof. Albo is closer to Turnbull than he is to Corbyn but go ahead please back up this nonsense and point to some examples…always good for a laugh mate.

I don’t see an issue with what is happening to USAID. How is billions of dollars being spent on promoting perversion and degeneracy in other countries a wise use of US taxpayers money?

If they stuck to the business of foreign aid, they probably wouldn’t be in the firing line.

26,000 new public servants since Labor were elected in May 2022. Over 16% growth. Have any services improved ?

It’s a big NO to that one Penfold.

They replaced consultants. Have any services deteriorated?

Fake news unfortunately. They converted a lot of contractors to full time Public Servants. Dutton will sack this lot and they will become contractors again. They would be employed because there was a need for them.

How many consultants did the 26,000 replace – half that ?

Heywood Smith3:41 pm 11 Feb 25

Exactly, and cost the tax payer double. These id7ots who think sacking APS staff saves money have no fricken idea!

devils_advocate3:50 pm 11 Feb 25

“How many consultants did the 26,000 replace – half that ?”

That’s not how consulting works. They bill by the hour, they are not FTEs allocated to a position.

The question is what was the dollar cost of employees versus consultants for a given output.

d_a – there’s no mention of FTEs in the article. The real question is whether the taxpayer is getting better value for the 26,000 extra people than any reduction in services provided by consultants and contractors. Frankly the likelihood is no, especially with wasteful unions being Labor’s preference.

Heywood – reducing APS staff means saving money by definition. Better outcomes ? Well that’s harder to judge. But name a department which has improved services …. Many of the extra people are in the NDIS / NDIA, probably the most wasteful agency around.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.