30 October 2023

Global issues, skills shortage blamed for further delays to promised diesel bus replacements

| Claire Fenwicke
Join the conversation
6
Orange Renault bus in Canberra

Some Renault diesel buses will now be on Canberra’s roads until early 2024, more than 18 months after the fleet was meant to be retired. Photo: ACT Bus.

The full fleet of promised leased low-emission diesel buses – which were meant to replace the Territory’s ageing Renault diesel buses by the end of 2022 – now aren’t expected to be on Canberra’s roads until 2024.

Public transport advocates have warned excuses are “wearing very thin”, however, the Government has signalled even further delays aren’t off the table.

Transport Minister Chris Steel informed the Legislative Assembly that while 12 promised low-floor electric buses have been delivered, international supply chain issues have resulted in yet another delay on the promised buses from Scania Australia.

“In undertaking due diligence in its management of the contract with Scania Australia, Transport Canberra came to the realisation that changing suppliers at this stage would not result in the delivery of buses in a shorter time,” Mr Steel said.

“Although the delays are unfortunate, they were not deemed unreasonable under the circumstances being experienced by the sector.

“In addition to the supply chain challenges, the industry is now also experiencing a nationwide skills shortage which could result in further delays.”

The Government had entered into this contract in March 2022 and all low-emission diesel buses were meant to have arrived by the end of last year.

The leasing of the buses had been a short-term solution to replace the 34 Renault buses, which aren’t compliant under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992, in an attempt to make Transport Canberra’s fleet fully accessible. The chassis would have been imported from Sweden and the bodies manufactured in South Australia.

The contract was varied to reflect expected delays notified in July 2022, with all 26 promised buses to be delivered by February 2023 under the amended schedule.

While nine of the promised leased buses are on Canberra’s roads, a further nine are now expected to arrive by the end of the year.

The eight other buses should arrive in early 2024, allowing the remaining Renault buses to be retired at that time.

READ ALSO Seven years in the making, MyWay+ set to debut in 2024 (and there’ll be a demo bus to practise on)

Mr Steel said the Government had come up with a new solution to support the retirement of the non-compliant buses in the interim.

“The ACT Government entered into a contract with Custom Denning for a further four battery electric buses. These buses will be based at the Belconnen Bus Depot, where charging equipment is being installed,” he said.

One bus has already arrived, with three others expected to be delivered and commissioned over the coming weeks. This would increase the total fleet of battery electric buses to 16.

Mr Steel said these arrangements had been made to ensure Canberrans could still be provided with reliable bus services.

“Continuing to delay the retirement of older fleet, while limiting their usage, until new replacement buses arrive will ensure Transport Canberra can continue to maintain service reliability,” he said.

“I am confident that the actions we are taking will support improved public transport services for Canberrans.”

READ ALSO What do you think about Canberra’s buses? ANU researcher wants to know

The repeated delays have left many unimpressed, with some suggesting the Government could be doing even more to get a compliant bus fleet on our roads sooner.

The Public Transport Association of Canberra described the delay as a “profoundly disappointing” development.

“They’ve had 20 years to prepare for these requirements, and the excuses are wearing very thin indeed,” chair Ryan Hemsley said.

“The Minister should be looking at all options to provide Canberrans with a fully accessible, DDA-compliant bus fleet sooner than what is currently planned by Transport Canberra.”

The Council on the Ageing ACT branch said it shared the “same disappointment” as the Government about the delays in the replacement buses.

“We will continue to work with Transport Canberra to promote accessible options for older people who may need them, such as the Flexible Bus Service and option to request an accessible bus on a particular route,” a spokesperson said.

Shadow Transport Minister Mark Parton took it a step further, saying he was “astounded” the non-accessibility-compliant Renault buses were still allowed to operate on Canberra’s roads.

“They are nearly a year past being legal on our roads … it is not good enough and once again the Transport Minister Chris Steel has failed in this space,” he said.

“The ACT Labor-Greens Government is absolutely dragging the chain when it comes to the transition of the bus fleet to EV.”

Join the conversation

6
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
William Newby11:30 pm 31 Oct 23

Funny how there has been zero mention of cost, how much do these magic busses cost?
In the interim why do we continue to drive these empty busses all around Canberra 24/7. If the services aren’t supported then drop them.

So they removed the bus services from many routes and now replacing buses they do have to be more ‘accessable’.

The accessability component was due years back and this change was only just recently done, after sitting on it for years.

6 accessible buses were deployed in 1995/96. Since then 477 accessible buses have been progressively deployed, with the non-accessible fleet now only 15 due to late deliveries. What was ‘just recently done’ and sat on for years? Are you suggesting that the whole fleet including near new buses should have been scrapped en masse and replaced with accessible buses around 25 years ago? Somewhat impractical wouldn’t you think?

The buses contracted for delivery last year have been appearing at the rate of about one per month this year. Other customers are reportedly in the same boat. Reliance was placed in the private sector which has failed badly. Yet we are soften assured by one political sector that the private sector is just so much better. Really?
The bus image is of a bus retired over 10 years ago, is a different model, and different configuration to the non-compliant type still in service. A common media problem – any old file image will do.

ChrisinTurner4:11 pm 31 Oct 23

When you have an ACT government that can’t even repair our potholes some 12 months after the rain, what do you expect? Any repair work is also done so poorly it falls apart in weeks. Is this another skills shortage?

GrumpyGrandpa12:19 pm 31 Oct 23

These old orange buses are great buses; as far as reliabilty goes.

Interestly, the younger “more modern” version of these Renaults; the model 3, was taken out of service years ago. It had no steps and at one stage an automatic ramp to assist passengers access. The problem was they weren’t reliable; continually breaking down. TC made a call at the time to retire these buses early and keep the older Renaults, despite the non-compliance issues etc.

It’s better to have a reliable bus on the road, than an unreliable one in the workshop!

Toyota isn’t convinced about full EVs. Their view is that due to the shortage of rare minerals required to build EVs, better environmental outcomes can be acheived through pumping out more Hybrids, for the same Lithium equivalent.

With access to rare minerals a concern that won’t go away, I’m not convinced that EV powered buses are the best option. How many Hybrid cars could be built with the same amount of rare materials used to power one EV bus?

The ACT Government (and even the Opposition) seem obsessed with EV buses. (Ok, the Government is a lot more obsessed with LR than buses of any sort 😄). My view is Yes, get these old Orange eco disasterous buses off the road, but replace them with new diesels; modern diesels are incredibly efficient and clean, meeting tough Euro standards, not to mention significantly cheaper to buy.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.