31 January 2023

Greens Minister's toxic workplace: Review finds conflict drove staff out

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
Emma Davidson, MLA.

The report investigated poor working conditions in the office of Greens Minister Emma Davidson. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

A review of the office of Greens Minister Emma Davidson has revealed a toxic and dysfunctional workplace marked by high staff turnover, backbiting, complaints being ignored and communication breakdowns.

Greens Leader Shane Rattenbury and Chief Minister Andrew Barr initiated the review, conducted by consultancy Proximity after complaints were made about the working conditions and conduct of the office.

Proximity was engaged in July last year and submitted its report in October, but it has only just been made public.

Reports began emerging last year that all was not well in Ms Davidson’s office, but details were sketchy and could not be confirmed.

The Proximity report found the office suffered from a lack of leadership and had been poorly established but refrained from outright criticism of the Minister.

READ ALSO Big Four accountancy firms on notice following PwC integrity breach

Inappropriate behaviour and statements, often in front of people, went unchecked, staff were resentful about how people were hired and how much they were paid. For some, the conflict became unbearable and they left.

One former employee was branded as disloyal and another was said to have been fired when they had actually resigned.

“Ineffective communication (and sometimes the lack of consultation) had generated misinformation and uncertainty about roles, reasons for staff changes and reluctance to clarify information and actions taken by decision-makers,” the report said.

There was no effective complaints process, but when concerns were raised about inappropriate behaviours, the complainants felt there was no effective organisational response.

“A more transparent and supported approach (eg what to do, where to go and knowing the outcome of any complaint or incident reported) is considered necessary to address complaints and manage disputes,” the report said.

“Some of the Review respondents said this could have alleviated the stresses experienced in the early days in the office.”

READ ALSO Another rate rise will just inflict pain and risk crashing the economy

The report said that when it came to health and safety at the Assembly, there was little emphasis on mental health and psychological stress, which for Ms Davidson’s staff is ironic given she is the Minister for Mental Health, and some of the subject material can be challenging.

The report attributed many of the problems to inexperience, a lack of guidance about how the office should run and no processes and mechanisms to establish clear work expectations and procedures in a high-pressure environment.

It found the office was established in a piecemeal and hurried way.

“In the first 18 months, the office experienced high levels of staff turnover and a lack of clarity around performance expectations, processes and accountabilities,” the report said.

“Feedback indicated some staff felt unsupported and vulnerable – working in what was a newly formed, high-pressure and new parliamentary environment.”

READ ALSO PODCAST: The Hoot returns to reflect on Australia Day, the Voice and how to erect cabanas

Staff who made the move from campaign mode to government found limited education, induction and training about the nature and expectations of their new ‘ministerial adviser’ roles.

“Importantly, there was little clarity of their accountabilities through, for example, performance agreements to support the Minister,” the report said.

“The professional development of the Minister’s staff does not appear to have been encouraged or formally supported: former staff described the pace of work and lack of direction and constructive feedback as not allowing time for on-the-job training or other development opportunities.”

The report said changes had been made within the office to strengthen leadership, build team performance and support the well-being of staff.

READ ALSO Petition launched over traffic safety fears at Harrison education precinct

These included regular team meetings, improved diary and meeting management for the Minister, and a Minister’s office planning session to clarify and allocate portfolio responsibilities to ministerial advisers.

Also in train were a complaints escalation process, exit interviews and more transparent recruitment processes.

The report made six recommendations that it believed should also be extended to Ministerial offices generally at the Assembly.

These covered the need for contemporary workplace materials, greater clarity of roles and expectations, strengthening team approaches, an effective complaints process, workplace safety and regular progress reviews.

Ms Davidson said the Chief Minister and Mr Rattenbury had accepted the six recommendations and were jointly implementing a response that was being progressively rolled out across all Labor and Greens’ Ministerial offices.

Ms Davidson further noted the challenge of establishing her office and ministerial functions during the pandemic.

“I was a newly elected MLA holding responsibility for multiple health-related and essential portfolios that were particularly impacted by the spread of COVID and lockdowns,” she said.

“We all worked very hard to support our community. As you can imagine, it was quite a stressful time for all of us and I acknowledge that this, combined with a lack of established processes, led to some teething issues.

“As an organisation that has been through rapid growth, setting up multiple new offices, it would be expected that there are structures and processes that needed to change. ACT Greens in the Assembly have already put in place some of those changes and are working on others, and working with the Assembly on better processes for all Assembly staff.”

The Proximity report draws on similar reviews of parliamentary workplaces across Australia, including Sex Discrimination Commissioner Kate Jenkins’ Set the Standard report and Elizabeth Broderick’s Independent Review into bullying, harassment and sexual misconduct at the Parliament of NSW.

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments

she’s meant to be my local member, never seen her out doing mobile offices unlike davis, parton and steel

Greens told us 2 years ago they had sorted out their internal problems, looks like they haven’t.
“I do believe that the changes we made – in governance, complaints processes, health and safety initiatives and culture – have made our political party a much safer place.”

Seems no one is held responsible for this toxic workplace and interesting that the review specifically targeted this Minister’s office. A failure of leadership and I bet the Minister will take no responsibility just a list of well worn excuses. A busy office with ‘advisers’ out of their depth is no excuse for treating staff like rubbish.

The Greens – dysfunction junction

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.