20 October 2022

It's time to bring Frank and Fearless back to the APS

| Ross Solly
Join the conversation
Senator Katy Gallagher

Senator Katy Gallagher has her work cut out for her. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

Ever had the disappointment of buying or acquiring something which you thought would be pretty special, only to find out your new possession is a major disappointment?

ACT Senator Katy Gallagher did last week: the Australian Public Service.

Paraphrasing the minister, she took delivery of a shiny new Cadillac, only to find it was a run-down old rust bucket with missing hubcaps, exhaust dragging on the ground and a radio that only played Backstreet Boys.

To put it frankly, the Cadillac was definitely not pre-loved and had obviously been used for far more than trips to the local shops for milk.

So faced with the choice of sticking some plaster on the broken bits and learning to love the Backstreet Boys (not sure if that’s possible) or returning the jalopy to its place of purchase for a complete do-over, Minister Gallagher has chosen the latter.

READ MORE Public service reform needed, but getting it right will be tricky

Katy Gallagher says the Australian Public Service has been run into the ground by previous governments and is no longer fit for purpose.

Government departments have turned readily to outside consultants to do the work that diligent and hard-working public servants would usually carry out, and Senator Gallagher wants that to stop.

“I was pretty shocked,” she said last week (she really did say this – no paraphrasing required).

“It was far worse than I thought insofar as the fragmentation of pay and conditions across the public service. The differences are pretty stark.”

Public servants, of whom a lot call Canberra and the surrounding districts home, will be thrilled to hear the new Labor Government wants to return the APS to its former glory. But if Minister Gallagher and the PM believe throwing a truckload of money at the problem will solve the crisis, they’ve got a big surprise waiting for them.

READ MORE Ambitious and enduring reform agenda for APS

There’s a general feeling that years of neglect and a lack of trust from previous governments have cowered public servants. Once revered and respected for their ability to give frank and fearless advice, both frank and fearless departed the scene long ago.

Ministers, having applied a cap on the amount of money government departments could spend to show they were saving money, then spent millions of dollars on consultants and contractors, who are also a big part of the Canberra community.

And outside consultants and contractors often are much happier to provide advice that the minister wants to hear than, say, old Frank and Fearless at the APS.

READ ALSO How to invest around the bulls and bears of the Australian market cycle

Senator Gallagher is aware of the problem.

“People’s trust in institutions is falling,” she said last week in something of an understatement.

“We need to make the APS as strong and as well-resourced as it needs to be. We’ve seen an eroding down of the public service. It needs to be independent and be able to give frank and fearless advice.”

She’s also told the previously thriving consultancy and contractor community to prepare to have less taxpayer money flowing their way.

In one interview last week, Senator Gallagher claimed all the big consulting firms were happy not to have to do this work anymore. This may be true, but show me someone who doesn’t like earning lots of money and I’ll show you a wombat who plays Beethoven.

So, for now, Senator Gallagher is asking everyone to watch this space. She’s set up an audit of the backfiring old banger, which she hopes will illuminate a path to a shiny new model with chrome hubcaps, individual climate settings and digital radio with Dolby surround sound.

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
HiddenDragon9:41 pm 24 Oct 22

“…both frank and fearless departed the scene long ago.”

Indeed – Katy Gallagher would have been a 12 year old, presumably more interested in pushbikes than Cadillacs, when John Stone famously complained about the “meretricious players” on the Canberra stage.

William Newby6:40 pm 23 Oct 22

This is a tree that needs a massive pruning, too many above EL1 have got there simply by turning up and though not making any mistakes along the way (never mind they have never produced anything at all, we are only assessed on failures).
The APS needs to reacquaint itself with performance management and have the confidence to show our non performing members the exit door.
With no gold plated superannuation to hold newcomers to the APS I frequently see the performers leave inside 5 years and the cruisers choosing the easy road, to stay, deliver little, and hold out for a promotion or payout.
Good on Gallagher for calling it out but my god this is no easy mess to sort out. The ACT public servants she left behind are in even a worse state, the lack of productivity, nepotism, waste, and general “it’s not my department” are just the tip of the ice berg. The least productive office I’ve ever known.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.