Skip to content Skip to main navigation

Mantis or stick?

NH 14 April 2008 15

My friends is studying Entomology and would like a Praying mantis or a Stick insect to freeze for her collection. If anyone can find and capture one for her it would be most appreciated! Unusual request I know 😉

What's Your Opinion?

Please login to post your comments, or connect with
15 Responses to Mantis or stick?
NH 3:32 pm 15 Apr 08

Thanks again! I have learnt something new today. I thought that earwigs and silverfish had more legs than 6, thats why my own reasoning for her wanting just insects and not arachnids (or another imagined category of my own) didn't make sense anymore.

I don't like earwigs and assumed they had more that 6 legs (I must have demonised them in my head or something). After mosquitos and flies for annoying factor earwigs are next on my list of unlikeables. I don't mind spiders though and scorpians are novel enough not to be higher on the list. I think the whole twitching pinsir thing is what does it. Silverfish stink because they eat papers and thats just not cool!

Praying mantis are so cool, like little aliens. And slaters are fun. And ladybeetles. And many others!

Meconium 2:39 pm 15 Apr 08

Leave Britney Alone! After all she's been through!

Hey NH, "8 is too many" for an entomology project because entomology is the study of insects, and all insects have no more than six legs. Arachnology is for eight-legged freaks like spiders, mites, ticks and scorpions.

Thumper 1:26 pm 15 Apr 08

yeah, leave the cute little mantis alone...

Timberwolf65 1:23 pm 15 Apr 08

Save the stick insects, leave them alone.

NH 10:58 am 15 Apr 08

Thanks for the thought Meconium too bad those microorganisms sucked those dried corpses apart...*barf*. I believe she already has a collection going so I'm not sure what she has so far but I will suggest that. She seemed particularly interested in 6 legged as "8 was too many".

stonedwookie: its for an assignment so she is required to do this. Valid point about the camera and pictures though.

s-s-a: thats a good sign :) It's still a little bit warm sometimes!

andy pandy: Thanks! Poor scarab beetle!

andy pandy 8:13 am 15 Apr 08

I will keep my eye out, but tell her to make sure she freezes them good.

I remember when doing horticulture 15 or 16 years ago a certain person collected a scarab beetle of some description.

When our collections had been submitted there was a strange scraping sound in the room and on inspection it was the said beetle trying to get away while pinned to the display board, it hadn't been frozen long enough and the poor bugger was only temporarily knocked out, coming too skewered to a styrofoam board.

He was quickly despached with ether.

s-s-a 10:50 pm 14 Apr 08

I've had a big green one and smaller brown one in my garden in the last week or so.

stonedwookie 9:55 pm 14 Apr 08

NH theres no way this will help future generations of insects.

many species have been endangered or sent extinct by over collection

infact you friend may even help send them extinct.

Study with a camera not by killing

Meconium 7:09 pm 14 Apr 08

I feel your pain NH! It's a bit cold to find good insects in Canberra, but your friend can't say her lecturers didn't warn her to collect them before summer finished! I got a couple from the family Mantidae near BoZo late in the season, one green and one brown.

I was going to offer you the ones I found, because I pinned and dried them well, and I had two to choose from. Unfortunately I just had a look at my collection, which has been sitting in my wardrobe since I finished the course, and found that every last insect (apart from one of the flies) had been reduced to dust, presumably by microorganisms and insects breaking the dried corpses apart to suck every last piece of nutrient from them!

Sorry I can't help. When I did it, you had to find representatives from ten orders (there's 23 orders of insects all up as far as I can remember). Might I suggest that silverfish (order Thysanura) or earwigs (Dermaptera) might be easier to find than mantids or phasmids? Look in wood piles or inside old books stacked in people's sheds.

Good luck to your friend.

Ari 5:50 pm 14 Apr 08

Why does she have to kill them?

Couldn't she just dart and translocate them?

NH 5:39 pm 14 Apr 08

I wasnt asking for them to be mailed >_>

We are all Canberrans right? I'm sure me or her could organise to meet with the cool person who finds one somehow :)

eye_see_ewe[at] if anyone wants to contact me.

Now see, I understand that Ant. I caught a cockroach and she asked me to stick it in the freezer and I couldn't do it. I'd grown attached to the thing. It had 4 legs and curled up in a little ball and I looked into its eyes and its little feelers wobbled. She really, really wants those 2 particular specimens. It would really help her study and perhaps future generations of insects.

Yay bugs!

ant 5:26 pm 14 Apr 08, if they wanted some excess Huntsman spiders, or in fact any large fat spiders, I'm sure there'd be no problem. I have plenty of spare ones.

RuffnReady 5:24 pm 14 Apr 08

As an ant, wouldn't you be a bit outsized if you tried it on? You'd want to be one of those big, nasty bull ants to even have a hope...

ant 5:14 pm 14 Apr 08

I'm not murdering my stick insects for anyone.

Skidbladnir 5:12 pm 14 Apr 08


Problem 1) Nobody knows where to send things to.

Problem 2) Isn't mailing living things and organic matter through the post a quick and easy way to spread soilborne disease and violate biocontrol measures?

(EG: I mail you a specimen of my citrus leaves covered in Wonder DeathFungus, you go out and touch your lemon tree after opening the mail, and now we have two cases of Wonder DeathFungus. Worst case scenario, it spreads like a powder and suddenly everyone's mail is covered in DeathFungus)

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Copyright © 2019 Region Group Pty Ltd. All rights reserved. | | |

Search across the site