23 January 2022

RATs are rare, so how do we prioritise access for those most in need?

| Emma Davidson MLA
Join the conversation
Rapid Antigen Test (RAT)

Rapid Antigen Test (RAT) are hard to access across the community. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

We all want Canberra to be a healthy, safe place for everyone, a city where public health decisions are made based on scientific evidence and prioritise the needs of those most at risk.

But our Prime Minister is making decisions that encourage competition between state and territory governments, retailers like pharmacies and supermarkets and his own government to access rapid antigen tests (RATs). Accessing RATs right now is almost impossible, even for the ACT Government.

In Canberra, there are 80,000 people with a disability, 50,000 people aged 65 years or older and 50,000 unpaid carers supporting their loved ones who are elderly or have a disability. Our prison system houses hundreds of people, including the potential for children as young as 10 years old in our youth detention centre.

Thousands of Canberrans are in surgical, cancer, mental health, and other wards in our hospitals. They are at most risk of poor health outcomes from COVID-19.

People accessing disability or aged care support in the home face the very real risk of being hospitalised because their basic health needs cannot be met.

READ ALSO Canberra restaurateurs taking COVID-19 safety into their own hands

We’re facing extraordinary rates of community transmission, resulting in much-needed disability support providers losing up to 30 per cent of their workforce to quarantine. This extends to workers in aged care facilities and healthcare services. Waiting for test results means people are going without the support they need to live with dignity.

Think about how it would feel to lie in bed for hours, wondering if anyone is coming to help with toileting or showering or feeding you. Or what it means to be unable to continue therapies that keep your body and mind functional, knowing that without them you will need clinical inpatient care to get back to a state of health where you can live at home again.

Or needing to go to Canberra Hospital for chemotherapy and hoping that the nursing staff providing your health care are COVID-free.

RATs keep people safe, healthy and able to everyday support services. Trials in the Alexander Maconochie Centre have demonstrated we can prevent transmission of COVID-19 in places that have high exposure risk through routine testing.

In Canberra’s health services, RATs have got workers out of quarantine, back to work safely and reduced pressure on our healthcare workforce. One of the ACT’s largest disability support providers prevented the virus spreading from COVID positive workers to the people they support through RAT screening.

We can’t adopt the ‘personal responsibility’ approach our Prime Minister wants us to when we don’t have access to the resources. Instead, we need to look at our community responsibility and prioritise access to RATs for those most in need to keep Canberra safe and healthy.

Scott Morrison says the Commonwealth will provide RATs for residential aged care workers and disability support workers in Supported Independent Living. He’ll pay half the cost of RATs for school staff if the ACT Government wants to use them for surveillance testing, although there’s no public health evidence on which to base this decision.

But he will contribute nothing for disability or aged care workers who deliver high-risk personal care services to people at home. He won’t help the ACT Government access supplies, even for schools where the Commonwealth will meet half the cost. Paying half the bill is cheap when there’s none to buy.

READ ALSO How to care for children with COVID at home

While it’s great to have more time as a family, remote learning is no replacement for face-to-face teaching. Young people are experiencing more psychological distress and following the August lockdown, 80 per cent of young Canberrans said they felt socially isolated.

I want my kids to return to face-to-face school in February and be safe from COVID. But not at the expense of someone with a disability having access to support workers who help them function on a daily basis. Not if it means emergency services workers, nurses and intensive care unit specialists are working double shifts because of workforce impacts as more people enter quarantine.

I cannot support Commonwealth Government public health decisions that don’t put the needs of those who are most at risk at the top of the priority list. I will not support decisions made on a whim without expert advice and evidence. To do so would mean people we love pay the price with their lives.

If the Prime Minister wants to lead this country, it’s well past time for him to do his job. All I’m seeing right now is a marketing manager who couldn’t give a rat’s about any of us.

Emma Davidson is the ACT Minister for Mental Health, Minister for Disability, Minister for Justice Health, and Assistant Minister for Seniors and Veterans and Families and Community Services. Her responsibilities include carers, youth justice, and community recovery from COVID.

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments

I don’t entirely disagree with some of the points in this article, however, with
a Federal election due, when does an “Opinion” article written by a politician, cease to be a newsworthy “Opinion” article and become a political advertising statement?

It becomes political, when the author
implies that the Prime Minister is past his useby date and referred to him as a marketing manager, and we all know the cynical term she refers to.

The utility of RATs is summarised in this diagram drawn from a paper which is available within the link.

Note that there is an average window of about 36 hours where a RAT has a good chance of picking up COVID before symptoms appear yet at a time of peak infectivity. The time frame is not large, but enough that it will stop some people infecting others in close working/social conditions or vulnerable situations such as visiting older relatives or the immuno-compromised. That helps to keep more workforce available and fewer people dead, not outcomes I would complain about.

Once symptoms appear, it may still be useful to know whether you have highly infectious COVID-19 or “just” influenza, the latter being less infectious and thus changing the constraints on those around the patient (although relative isolation is still a great idea).

A caveat on the paper (Sep 2021) is that, while RAT’s pick up all variants of COVID-19, there is no specific data there on the available window prior to symptom onset from omicron. I will be interested to find referenced facts on that.

With all the whinging about access to RATs, you would think that they cured people from COVID.

The problem is that their value is being grossly overstated, mostly from people looking to score political mileage out of it.

Whilst they have their place, RATs are not accurate enough in the situations and usage you need them to be to provide the value that is being claimed.

For symptomatic people in their peak infectious period, they are very good.

But people in that situation should sensibly just assume they have COVID because the actual diagnosis doesn’t really change the management of the disease unless there are pre existing or complicating factors. And for those people, a PCR test should be done to confirm anyway.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.