12 July 2024

Some people love Canberra's Brutalist buildings. We asked them why

| John Coleman
Join the conversation
37
High Court, Dickson library, Transact House.

Good lighting makes these Brutalist buildings look far more inviting. Photos: John Jovic.

It’s rarely love at first sight with Brutalist buildings, and for many Canberrans there’s still no romance. The style is an acquired taste that plenty of locals still spit out.

Many find it foreboding, cold, depressing, totalitarian. As a chap on The Canberra Page said of Campbell Park Offices: “Always thought that [they’d] feature in one of those movies where the Nazis won WWII”.

But to be clear, what is Brutalism? All post-war concrete buildings that look like a pistol-whipping is going down inside?

There are frontiers where scholars skirmish but, at its essence, it’s a Modernist architectural style where heavy, geometric form results from chasing function. Brutalism’s raw concrete, glass, and brick. It’s the opposite of leering gargoyles or porticos trying to hide something.

It doesn’t hide anything. The term ‘Brutalism’ derives from the French term beton brut, meaning raw concrete, and not from the dystopian regimes we suspect it represents.

It fell out of fashion globally in the 1980s, but not before it visited Canberra.

Russell Offices.

Russell Offices: raw concrete on show. Photo: John Jovic.

When it did, David Bate was working at the National Capital Development Commission. A project manager who helped plan the High Court and National Gallery of Australia, he told us the commission was keen to have “Australian architecture of different styles”.

Unsurprisingly, he’s a fan of our Brutalist landmarks. He finds it’s ironic we sometimes view them as grim and oppressive, when they actually facilitate welcoming open spaces.

“With the gallery, one of the requirements was to have big open spaces with no columns, and when you’re building multi-storey buildings that becomes difficult,” he explains.

“They had a geodesic-type ceiling, so if you ever go there and look up, you’ll see this sort of triangulation in the ceiling. That’s designed so it’ll take the weight without the columns.”

National Gallery of Australia interior.

Inside the National Gallery of Australia: make sure you look up. Photo: John Jovic.

He says a gallery’s function precludes too many windows, but if you go to the corner where the cafe is located, “you’ve got glass overlooking the sculpture garden. It gets the sunlight throughout the day and it’s a very pleasant space to be”.

It’s the same with the High Court.

“On the lake side of the High Court, your first reaction is to this huge structural wall of concrete.”

High Court building.

This side of the High Court building is the definition of transparent justice. Photo: John Jovic.

“But when you get into the building, what will hit you is the openness. It’s a huge ceiling height.”

John Jovic is an interstate fan of Canberra’s Brutalism. He enjoys our Brutalist buildings more than we do. In fact, when I suggested a lot of Canberrans didn’t like the buildings, he replied many Parisians also hate the Eiffel Tower.

While he finds the buildings “works of art” in their own way, he acknowledges they’re not conventionally beautiful. “They’re fascinating,” he says.

READ ALSO Waterhouse prizewinners draw on Indigenous past and climate crisis future for their art

“I can look at a Brutalist building seemingly forever and learn something new about it almost every time.”

He wonders if this is half our problem.

“An interesting line of thought says that our perception of ugliness often comes from a fight-or-flight response. Those things that you don’t understand, threaten you.

“You can rarely look at a Brutalist building and understand it immediately: you often need to figure out ‘why does this bit jut out here? What is that doing?’”

He says if you stand in front of a building with someone who dislikes Brutalism, you can explain “that’s actually the service lifts that’ve been hidden through this external structure; it’s part of the function of the building”.

John also reckons we’re coming round to them, possibly with the help of Instagram.

“With any architectural style, there’s always decades where pretty much everyone hates it, or it’s ignored and that’s the time it’s most vulnerable because it gets knocked down.

“But there comes a point where people look back and go ‘sh*t this was actually pretty amazing’. It happened with deco. It happened with Victorian style.”

Fine. We should look deeper at Dickson Library then. But what if we still find it irrefutably grim?

Australian War Memorial Annex.

The Australian War Memorial Annex. Photo: John Jovic.

One commentator wrote that Brutalist buildings could “engender feelings of unknowing, of mystery, and sometimes, especially when said Brutalist building is in disrepair or photographed at a particularly menacing angle, of fear …”. Perhaps, as something different, we can relish those responses too.

The fact it’s something different is ultimately the point. You wouldn’t want a whole city of Brutalism, David says. Fortunately, we don’t have one.

“In Canberra, you don’t get Brutalist buildings in isolation. You see them in terms of the landscape they sit in, and in relation to other buildings. If you compare them to say, the Treasury building or Old Parliament House and East and West Block; it’s a different style but they all represent the style of the day.”

One of Oscar Wilde’s characters said “architecture tells us a lot about our nation”.

Whatever indictment that has for the uninspiring homogeneity of Gungahlin aside, if it’s true that a drive through Canberra’s leafy centre will show some art deco, a smattering of Stripped Classical, and a few chunks of Brutalism, then we can say one thing for the nation’s capital.

We’re at least diverse.

Join the conversation

37
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
Macquariephil9:40 pm 12 Jul 24

Maybe fine the for the Gallery or Court. Actually quite impressive. But has John Jovic ever been into Cameron Offices, or Campbell Park? Someone should do a study on the impact of brutalist office spaces on the occupants’ mental health. Talk about dark satanic mills …

liveandletlive1:49 pm 14 Jul 24

Really!! Have you ever worked or even set foot inside Campbell Park? Pretty ugly from the outside, sure, but pretty light and airy (is that a word…) inside. My last desk there looked out over Mt Ainslie and it was anything but ‘dark satantic mills’.

HiddenDragon7:27 pm 12 Jul 24

Some of these buildings may have interesting technical aspects and features, and some may create surprising and/or pleasant spaces, but the overall look and feel is generally not so much brutal as it is dull and uninspiring.

Individually and collectively these buildings have strong echoes of dreary specimens from Britain’s post-War New Town movement, which is apt, in that the urban development of Canberra clearly took inspiration from that movement – but a look which might have been OK for people seeking new provincial lives away from blitzed old cities may not have been the very best choice for the national capital of a young nation on the other side of the world.

Check out Queanbeyan courthouse. That is architecture making a statement. A pity they removed the older police station as it complemented the courthouse.

Peter Graves12:38 pm 11 Jul 24

I note that both the quoted comments about the National Gallery and the High Court relate to being inside each of them. Not so much of the experiences of being outside them and experiencing the unadorned concrete of their construction and their “in yer face” sharp corners and styling. Much less the impacts of those sharp corners on the skylines.

Thery may all “all represent the style of the day”. But become so out of date, so quickly. Buildings in Canberra are much, more more than just being plonked on the ground to serve a very limited purpose.

As just one – much better – example: The National Library. Always a pleasure to look at, especially when it’s lit up at night. Like The Mint, too.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.