24 December 2024

It's time to crown Region's Car of the Year for 2024

| James Coleman
Join the conversation
13

Guess the cars… Photos: James Coleman.

Ladies and gentlemen, please put your hands together for Region‘s Car of the Year for 2024 – the MG 3.

Just kidding.

Not only was last year’s pick of the bunch its fully-electric sibling, the MG 4 – and it’d start to look very dodgy if MG won for a second year running – but I’ve also been banned from reviewing any more MG products after what I said about its latest little hybrid hatchback.

It turns out that “the interior smells like the inside of a balloon” gets you straight on the naughty list. My apologies.

So, moving on.

The Abarth 500e parked on the beach near Cronulla, NSW.

Other cars that won’t be winning the award include the electric Abarth 500e, which I loved deeply for its jelly-bean looks and raucous fake exhaust noise that was actually very well done, but less so its useless range of 253 km and price tag of $60K.

Nor will it be the Tesla Model 3, which was cool once but is now just annoying in its pursuit of minimalism (indicators belong on stalks, no argument). The Volvo EX30 also has a button on the touchscreen for the glovebox, which is an instant write-off in my books.

The Toyota LandCruiser 70 would be likeable in a old-school, hillbilly way, if it cost about $50K less.

And despite two attempts to love the Alfa Romeo Tonale PHEV over the course of the year, it still left me underwhelmed by its vague steering and crunchy drivetrain.

The puppy-eyed Suzuki Jimny XL had me similarly torn, but it really does need some extra oomph as a four-door. And even with a plug-in hybrid drivetrain, the Mercedes-AMG C63 S is still a mighty machine, but it’s no V8 (you press the start button and there’s no noise – that seems wrong).

Others were simpler decisions.

The Mazda 6 is just getting too old, perhaps not surprisingly after 12 years and four updates. The Toyota CH-R doesn’t deliver on the sporty promises its styling makes, but buy the ‘GR Sport’ version before the Lexus LBX. The Genesis G70 Shooting Brake also looked better than it drove. The Hyundai Kona performed on neither front remarkably. The Mercedes-Benz E300 just wasn’t polished enough.

The Mazda 6 wagon at the entrance to Kurri Kurri, near Newcastle.

And Toyota’s late entrance to the EV party, the bZ4X, doesn’t really have anything going for it apart from the fact it’s a … well, Toyota. People will also think you’ve bought a computer hard drive when you mention the name at parties and you’ll end up dying old and alone.

The easy pick for COTY would the Lotus Emira, which I unashamedly described as the “best car I’ve ever driven, hands down”. Or the Mazda MX-5, which – around town at least – is almost the same thing for nearly one-fifth of the price.

They’re hardly what the company’s founder would call a Lotus without feeling a bit faint, but the new EVs from Lotus – the Eletre SUV and Emeya sedan – would baffle even Isambard Brunel by how well they manage to cloak their immense weight behind pin-sharp handling.

The Lotus Eletre S in Ainslie Place, Civic.

The Ford Mustang Mach-E would be the same, if only they could have come up with another name. Please never call that thing a Mustang.

Or there’s the Audi RS6 Avant, which every car enthusiast must adore by law.

The Hyundai i30 N is in a similar boat. And I see Wheels magazine has just handed its COTY award to its electric sibling, the Hyundai IONIQ 5 N. Worthy, and I love it for all it has done for EVs. But it also costs $110,000, so you’d want it to.

The new electric MINI Cooper was also hilariously good fun, similar to the BMW iX2, but prettier. See also the MINI Countryman.

MINI Cooper

The MINI Cooper goes to Floriade.

And the Renault Megane E-Tech, while not looking like any other Megane we’ve ever seen up to this point, definitely cheered me up after what’d we’d seen from the French at the Olympics.

Then there was the Chevrolet Silverado, which was so needlessly excessive I loved it. I can still hear that V8 roar if I close my eyes.

Others diligently fulfil their briefs like the quiet kid at the back of the class. The Kia Picanto. The Subaru Impreza. The Toyota Camry, once you ignore the dull interior. You could live happily ever after in any of these.

The Toyota Camry pretending to be an Uber outside Hotel Realm.

The Mitsubishi Triton is a serious contender, now that the company has issued a fix for the driver-monitoring system that would yell at you whenever you looked out the side window at an intersection for too long – you know, good driving things.

Or there’s the Land Rover Defender 130, once you get used to the enormous back end. And have the wallet to stomach the cost of options.

And honestly, while we’re on big things, GWM’s Tank 300 and Cannon Alpha showed how far the Chinese really have come. I mean, the latter has a clock in the dashboard – an actual analogue clock.

The GWM Cannon Alpha on a fire trail near the Cotter.

We could heap similar praise on the Chery Tiggo 8 Pro Max, and to a lesser extent, the LDV Mifa van (which looks like a cut-price Lexus).

I’m so close to handing the award to the Hyundai Sante Fe. Or even the Kia EV9, with the proviso you must buy it in matt blue. The CX-90, Mazda’s first serious attempt at going upmarket, is also enough to have a passer-by mistake it for a BMW.

Kia EV9

The Kia EV9 at the Kingston Foreshore.

But there is one that impressed me the most.

Try not to think about the name, and just look at it. Or close its doors, and listen to the solid thud they make. Or sit back in its quilted leather seats and admire the crystalline trimmings. And know it all cost you the same as a Tesla (with added indicator stalk).

Ladies and gentlemen, you really can put your hands together this time. The BYD Seal is Region‘s Car of the Year for 2024.

BYD Seal

A pre-production version of the BYD Seal in the Canberra Centre.

What cars should we try out next year? Let us know in the comments.

Join the conversation

13
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
Craig Applegate9:35 pm 03 Jan 25

The base model Seal is cheaper than a model 3. You wouldn’t think it from the outside, but 3 long legged adult passengers sitting in the back seat have heaps of space. Electric cars are also nicer to drive than petrol ones.

Capital Retro1:30 pm 04 Jan 25

Three longed legged adults in the back seat will add 300kg and halve the range.

100Kg each person?

It does not matter. You are wrong anyway.

Capital Retro6:51 pm 04 Jan 25

In 2021, 62.2% of adults in Canberra were overweight or obese, with 35.5% overweight and 26.7% obese.
People with long legs have large bones and bones weigh a lot.
And why am I wrong?

Exactly my point. I avoided further comment because I do not mean to be discourteous to the overweight and obese. It takes more than long legs and large bones. Ask me how I know.

You are wrong about range impact owing to facts.

You fail entirely to state context, and make no relevant comparison. There was no value in your post.

Capital Retro8:40 pm 05 Jan 25

You want a relevant comparison?
Well I am over 6′ tall and I have long legs. I am skinny but I still weigh 95kg.
If you studied maths at school (it seems you excelled only in political correctness) you would know that 3 x 95kg is 285kg.
Now tell me your facts about range impact.
This is an opinion blog by the way – we don’t get points for value.

Are you ever going to report on how various dealers & car makes treat the client when it comes to warranties & repairs ??
Surely that’s about the most important consideration.

A car of the year article clearly aimed at an audience who have no interest in cars.

So you reckon that a car has to have a thumping big V8 or diesel engine in it to be considered a good vehicle for the wider proportion of people? Hmm…

Yeah that’ll tow the van and have a long range

Not everyone needs to tow a van. Only 3% of the population has a recreational vehicle. The BYD Seal will easily do 500km against a rated range of 570km too.

Don’t know you James, never heard of you but I assume you are a nice fella with an eye for auto’s, pity you haven’t got a clue about it, specifically anything Aussie, Cheers.

You obviously don’t read car reviews here (almost all written by James). And you apparently know cars, so which Aussie cars should he have reviewed? I’ll wait…

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.