A rich, smart city sidelines the battlers

John Thistleton 17 January 2019 30
Former ACT chief minister Jon Stanhope says the current government is abandoning low-income earners in the inner central suburbs. File photo.

Former ACT chief minister Jon Stanhope says the current Government is abandoning low-income earners in the inner central suburbs. File photo.

From undefeated ACT chief minister to passionate affordable housing advocate, Jon Stanhope takes aim at the big end of town.

Specifically, he is targeting the ACT Government for abandoning low-income earners in the inner central suburbs. He says developing the inner north is all about paying for the light rail project, which would not be viable under normal growth scenarios.

His latest broadside comes as researchers confirm that central Canberra is indeed the knowledgable city, but at the expense of social and economic diversity.

“People point to what a cool city we are becoming and point to Lonsdale Street and the New Acton precinct and Kingston Foreshore,” Mr Stanhope says.

“Those are enclaves of privilege. Whenever I visit Lonsdale Street or New Acton or Kingston Foreshore. I don’t see people that I know or recognise from the bottom two income quintiles in any of those places.

“Yes, we are into some fantastic place-making, but it is for upwardly mobile professionals and the middle and upper-middle class and there is no regard for people in the bottom two income quintiles.

“We need diversified communities. But this is not what we are doing. The inner south and inner north, from Woden to Watson, we have effectively excluded people with, in blunt terms, a form of social cleansing. People on Centrelink benefits, people on disabilities, ‘out to the outer suburbs for you’.’’

Mr Stanhope supports a suggestion from two University of Canberra academics that central Canberra’s change has come at a cost.

Writing for independent commentary website, The Conversation, Professor Richard Hu and researcher Sajeda Tuli say Canberra’s compact centre is becoming more important in a globalised and networked society.

(Professor Hu is from the university’s Faculty of Arts and Design and Institute for Governance and Policy Analysis. Ms Sajeda is from the university’s Institute for Governance and Policy Analysis.)

“The city centre is more than a geographical or spatial centre,” the authors say. “Its ‘centrality’ is cultural, social, political and economical. Canberra’s city centre, a Modernist planning legacy, now exists in a setting of multiple global and local forces. These forces are intersecting with economic restructuring, ubiquitous information technology, knowledge diffusion and people movement.”

They note a growing presence and practice of smart work in Canberra’s city centre. Creative workers are sharing spaces and facilities.

As a result of managers and professionals moving into the increasingly desirable inner-city areas, rising housing and rental prices are pushing out existing inhabitants. According to Census 2016, nearly 1200 managers and professionals lived and worked in inner areas of Civic and Braddon, but only 170 technicians and labourers who worked there also lived there.

The researchers say Canberra’s urban renewal strategy should not embrace or celebrate a creative transformation only. It should also appropriately manage the social implications to genuinely make the city a place for everyone.

City Renewal Authority chief executive officer Malcolm Snow says his organisation understands the challenges of incorporating affordable housing options as the area undergoes renewal.

Mr Snow says low-income households across Canberra experience housing stress, and the inner city is no different. He says the authority has a strategy for social and economic vibrancy, including encouraging diverse and affordable housing choices.

“New inclusionary housing targets have been introduced on land released by government to the private sector, starting with the Macarthur House site in Lyneham, which will contain a minimum of 50 dwellings for purchase by low-income households,” Mr Snow says.

Future public land for development in the precinct will contain requirements for affordable, community and public housing, Mr Snow says.

What's Your Opinion?

Please login to post your comments, or connect with
30 Responses to A rich, smart city sidelines the battlers
Lucy Baker Lucy Baker 11:52 am 19 Jan 19

Wasn’t Jon Stanhope the Chief Minister when this debacle got under way? Where’s the record of his efforts on behalf of inner-city battlers when he was in power?

Mario Vozella Mario Vozella 9:04 am 19 Jan 19

Unfortunately one of the reasons is, it has become the most expensive city to live in Australia.

chewy14 chewy14 8:27 am 19 Jan 19

I find it more than a little ironic that most of the housing problems that Mr Stanhope now rails against were actually started and actively pushed during his tenure as chief minister.

Yes, there should be housing diversity but who is going to pay for people in the “bottom two quintiles” to live in inner city houses/apartments worth upwards of $1 million dollars?

And where is the equity for not only the other people who would pay for this “diversity” but for the other poorer people in those income quintiles who dont get lavished with such extravagance?

It’s time for Canberra to grow up, people with money are always going to have nice things than those who dont. And that’s exactly how it should be.

Paul Evans Paul Evans 4:37 am 19 Jan 19

Single , retired, renting is a no go in Canberra. After 15 years I will have to move somewhere else, Albury! Wagga!

Bronwyn Meredith Bronwyn Meredith 9:11 pm 18 Jan 19

I think Stanhope has a point. In response to the haters, I would like to mention the arboretum which Canberra is so fortunate to have. It's unusual for a politician to instigate a long-term project that won't come to fruition until after his/her term in office. Stanhope endured monumental criticism for this project but had the guts and vision to insist on going ahead.

    Margaret Freemantle Margaret Freemantle 9:29 pm 18 Jan 19

    Bronwyn Clarke his greatest gift to Canberra! He is a caring man- we need such people in this city

    Bronwyn Meredith Bronwyn Meredith 11:02 pm 18 Jan 19

    Margaret Freemantle Agree with you entirely. He definitely does care about people.

Jill Lyall Jill Lyall 7:23 pm 18 Jan 19

The unemployed are invisible here - you cannot access any pathways into employment and no one cares. You cannot get a job without some kind of personal contact. Everyone suffers in silence.

Nick Stone Nick Stone 4:46 pm 18 Jan 19

Thank you for this embarrassment!⬇️

Stephen Finnegan Stephen Finnegan 4:33 pm 18 Jan 19

Hold on didn't the ACT have record price rises under his watch?

    Nick Stone Nick Stone 4:48 pm 18 Jan 19

    Stephen Finnegan Oh no. Your comment will incur the warth of the Labor/Green apologists!

Linda Gillespie Linda Gillespie 3:26 pm 18 Jan 19

Absolutely positively has !!!!!

Janet Ilchef Janet Ilchef 3:17 pm 18 Jan 19

Now all the low income people are shafted out to the edge of the burbs and probably can’t afford transport to find a job. Let alone the social isolation

    Jane Kim Jane Kim 3:37 pm 18 Jan 19

    They've kicked all the tenants out of Strathgordon in Woden now too. It's sitting there all blocked off ready to be sold off to a developer, if it hasn't been already.

    Nick Stone Nick Stone 4:51 pm 18 Jan 19

    Jane Kim In fairness, they haven't been kicked out, just relocated to Coombs, Wright, Moncrieff....Just to name a few!

    Shannon Keith Shannon Keith 7:54 pm 18 Jan 19

    Sorry, I don’t accept the ‘suffering social isolation’ on the edges of the earth argument. Canberra is not that big, and there are decentralised job seeker resources in the town centres. And public transport is much more affordable than other major cities. The bus from Palmerston to Civic return cost me less than a cup of coffee. Plus, the libraries offer free internet use and affordable printing for preparing and sending job applications.

    Amanda Evans Amanda Evans 11:11 pm 18 Jan 19

    Nick Stone that's a hell of a long way from Woden's community connections and amenity.

    Janet Ilchef Janet Ilchef 11:17 pm 18 Jan 19

    Shannon Keith then you get into an unemployed persons shoes, have yourself living in the wilds of suburbia, no other fellow unemployed around - and see if you find it pleasant. The low income and the unemployed have a right to some pleasant things, even if it’s the support of someone else in the same situation. Go read “Down and Out in Paris and London” by Orwell just to get an idea of what being poor or unemployed might be like

    Jane Kim Jane Kim 6:42 pm 19 Jan 19

    Nick Stone yes, that may be, however where they were was much better in terms of location for people who may not drive etc. Across the road from shops and services, moved to suburbs that have none of those facilities yet.

    Jane Kim Jane Kim 6:44 pm 19 Jan 19

    Amanda Evans it sure is. Same as they did in Civic. It's all about the money.

Vanessa Jones Vanessa Jones 1:28 pm 18 Jan 19

Which Labor leader closed so, so many public ACT schools?

    Stephen Page-Murray Stephen Page-Murray 4:20 pm 18 Jan 19

    Vanessa Jones

    For very good reasons

    Nick Stone Nick Stone 4:44 pm 18 Jan 19

    Stephen Page-Murray She asking which, not why. Your reply still doesn't mean much either way!😒

    Bronwyn Meredith Bronwyn Meredith 9:04 pm 18 Jan 19

    Nick Stone The question was obviously loaded.

    Vanessa Jones Vanessa Jones 6:33 am 19 Jan 19

    It was a huge loss of beautiful public schools and school land, including my local Higgins school, now sold off to a developer.

Veronika Sain Veronika Sain 10:31 am 18 Jan 19

On the other hand, for the longest time the large amounts of old decrepit public flats in civic made civic drug user central and the city still is the place where users congregate and deal.

I do also wonder if the organised group of heroin user/dealers who washed car windows at the lights along northbourne will return after light rail works are completed.

    Soo Jay Soo Jay 2:27 pm 18 Jan 19

    Veronika, *all cities* have drug users/dealers. What is your point? That all low-income earners are drug users? That a city the size of Canberra can survive without low-income workers?

    Luke Ashe Luke Ashe 6:27 pm 18 Jan 19

    Haven't you heard? Young kids around 8 to 15, are the drug users now

    Luke Ashe Luke Ashe 6:30 pm 18 Jan 19


CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site