5 January 2024

BoM needs to be supported as warming makes weather more unpredictable

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
15
dark clouds in the city

The storms have kept coming in Canberra this summer. Photo: Claire Fenwicke.

As the rain continues to tumble down across eastern Australia, including on the ACT, many are wondering what happened to the hot, dry summer we were told to expect.

The summer may yet dry out for a late flush of heat but, at present, the storm clouds keep building, defying the climate modellers.

In Queensland, the surprising floods in the north and south had residents and local councils up in arms about the Bureau of Meteorology’s weather warnings, prompting the Federal Government to order a review of its systems.

READ ALSO Crews mobilise as stormy summer feeds grass and potholes

Weather forecasting has always been a fraught and inexact science.

Everybody talks about – and complains about – the weather, and the BoM as the messenger is the whipping boy, ranging from people put out by rain that ruins a washing day to communities hammered by a storm that appears out of nowhere.

Farmers also rely on long-term forecasts for planting and stock management, so when it seems like the BoM has got it wrong there are incomes at stake and economic consequences for the nation.

Throw in the politics of climate change and there are more than just calls for a look at how and when warnings are issued.

In fact, the BoM has been under siege for years, as far back as when a climate-change-denying Prime Minister Tony Abbott considered asking a taskforce to investigate whether it was exaggerating temperature data records.

Leading the charge then, and now, is the Murdoch press, keen to pounce on every supposed misstep the BoM makes and whose columnists regularly attack its climate modelling.

The fact is the climate is changing and the weather is becoming more unpredictable, just as was foreseen, especially to do with the rapid development of severe and intense systems.

Back in September, the BoM declared an El Niño, the driver for hotter, drier summers, but it has been at pains to explain in recent times that doesn’t necessarily mean it won’t rain, particularly in the form of storms, which have dominated the summer so far.

Other factors have also been at play, such as warmer seas off the east coast and increased east-west winds blowing off the Tasman Sea to Australia, which generate more rain.

People also forget that the spring was dry and experienced above-average temperatures.

READ ALSO In praise of Test cricket and the long lazy days of summer

It’s always been complicated and it is getting more complex every year, and that is something the BoM is working with as it adjusts its climate models.

The government is right to see if there are any gaps in the emergency warning system, and like any other agency the BoM should be accountable.

But it is important that it continues to retain faith in the BoM and support it as an institution, and not succumb to the baying of commentators and right-wing media outlets with an agenda to discredit climate science and undermine efforts to decarbonise the economy.

Join the conversation

15
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Reading Mr. Bushnell’s last paragraph and then reading the comments… enough said.

The old decarbonising the economy chestnut – the truth revealed through climate zealotry

Once upon a time, faith based religion dominated our thoughts.
It was based on books written in obscure language, interpreted by a hierarchy of priests, who spend their lives studying the signs, well subsidised by the people,
A gullible populace was awed by the edicts of those who claimed exclusive authority to interpret the will of God and who threatened non-believers with fire and brimstone, eternal damnation and punishment for imagined sins.
The populace was deceived and cowed into submission, afraid of being called heretics.
But over time people grew sceptical of this belief system and its many unfulfilled doomsday predictions.
Mocked and ridiculed the priests lost influence and power. The world survived.

Then a new faith based belief system arose called Climate Change.
It was based on climate models written in obscure language and interpreted by a hierarchy of climatologists, who spend their lives studying the signs, well subsidised by the people.
A gullible populace was kept awed by the edicts of those who claimed exclusive authority to interpret the will of nature and who threatened non-believers with global warming, oceans level rises, mass extinctions, eternal damnation and punishment for imagined sins.
The populace was deceived and cowed into submission, afraid of being called climate change deniers and down voted on social media.
But then over time people grew sceptical of this belief system and its many unfulfilled doomsday predictions.
Mocked and ridiculed the priests lost influence and power. The world survived.

@Acton
Nice fairy tale. Acton.
Unfortunately for you, the only people being mocked and ridiculed are the gullible populace who accept the deception and false idols of the fossil fuel zealots.
Far from losing influence and power, the “priests” of climate change, which to the informed majority are known as scientists, are being proven correct as we experience the predicted extreme weather events.

BOM gets the forecast right. They just get the days wrong.

Stephen Saunders3:03 pm 08 Jan 24

Everybody knows that global “climate change” is the only problem that matters, but fortunately, UN “net zero” emissions will bring on a golden age.

In the meantime, who better qualified than the weather bureau, to hide behind “climate change” as the all-purpose excuse for getting it wrong?

Thanks for your sane and sensible article Ian. There seems to be general agreement amongst those who actually have knowledge and understanding of this area of science – that it is becoming increasingly difficult to give precise info about the weather. I am surprised at some of the comments that have been made here. It demonstrates a very shallow understanding of how complex this area is. Having said that – I am very pleased that the Fed Govt is going to undertake a review of the models that are apparently currently being used by BOM.

Capital Retro1:34 pm 08 Jan 24

The ant activity in my backyard indicates what the weather is going to do better than the BOM can do.

All this rain, when it was supposed to be dry. The BoM just loves egging on extremes:
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2023-09-19/bom-officially-declares-el-nino-underway-2023/102495394

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.