26 March 2025

Budget shows more public servants but mostly at the expense of consultants

| Chris Johnson
Join the conversation
58
Jim Chalmers, Andrew Leigh and Katy Gallagher

Dr Jim Chalmers, Dr Andrew Leigh and Katy Gallagher fronting the media to sell the 2025 Federal Budget. Photo: Katy Gallagher Instagram.

Since Labor’s first budget in 2022, the Australian Public Service has added 11,802 new public service roles to replace work previously undertaken by external consultants and contractors, with 2986 included in this 2025-26 Federal Budget.

In general public service numbers, the budget allows for more than 3400 new employees in the next financial year, which will then sit at more than 41,000 extra APS employees since Labor came to office.

It sets the scene for the Coalition to further attack the government over what it says is an already overblown public service.

The Federal Government has delivered on its commitment to abolish the Average Staffing Level (ASL) cap.

Public Service Minister Katy Gallagher said under the previous Coalition government, the ASL cap placed arbitrary restrictions on the size of the public service and led to agencies outsourcing their work to a shadow workforce.

This was made up of contractors, consultants, outsourced service providers and labour hire to deliver public sector work.

READ ALSO Tax cuts for all in a Federal Budget that ignites election race

“This resulted in an artificially low headcount of the public service that came at a costly premium for taxpayers,” Senator Gallagher says in her preface to Budget Paper No.4.

“The 2021–22 Audit of Employment found that, in 2021–22, 112 agencies across the public service that employed staff under the Public Service Act 1999 had outsourced arrangements for 53,900 staff on a full-time equivalent basis at a cost of $20.8 billion.

“The Australian Government’s investment has rebalanced and rebuilt the capability of the public service, creating over 11,800 new public service roles to replace work previously undertaken by consultants and contractors.

“This accounts for more than a quarter of total ASL increases under the Australian Government, including 2986 additional roles in the 2025–26 Budget that are now being performed by public servants instead of through outsourced arrangements.

“This includes 2603 ASL in the National Disability Insurance Agency to improve outcomes for NDIS participants and ensure every dollar of NDIS funding goes to those who need it most.”

In dollar terms, this move has delivered $4.7 billion in savings since the 2022–23 October Budget, including an additional $718.8 million in this budget.

In 2025–26, APS agencies will be responsible for managing approximately $785.7 billion to deliver services for individuals, families and businesses.

Now very much a national institution, the APS operates from 583 locations around Australia, including in remote areas, regional towns and cities, and all state and territory capitals.

READ ALSO Labor and Coalition agree – hands off the PBS, Mr Trump!

The relative size of the public service has remained below historical levels when measured as a proportion of the total Australian population and the labour force.

Today, federal public servants make up 1.5 per cent of the labour force and 0.8 per cent of the total population of 27.7 million, while in 2006–07, they comprised 1.6 per cent of the labour force and 0.8 per cent of the population of 20.8 million (2007).

Machinery of Government changes (MoG changes) since last year’s budget have seen the APS undergo a number of administrative amendments affecting the APS’s budget bottom line.

These MoG changes have resulted in the:

  • establishment of the Administrative Review Tribunal as a non-corporate Commonwealth entity in the Attorney-General’s portfolio. The Administrative Review Tribunal replaces the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, formerly a non-corporate Commonwealth entity in the same portfolio, which was abolished
  • establishment of the National Commission for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Children and Young People as a non-corporate Commonwealth entity in the Social Services portfolio
  • establishment of the Net Zero Economy Authority as a non-corporate Commonwealth entity in the Prime Minister and Cabinet portfolio
  • abolishment of the National Mental Health Commission, a non-corporate Commonwealth entity in the Health and Aged Care portfolio. The Department of Health and Aged Care, in the same portfolio, adopted the functions of the National Mental Health Commission
  • transfer of the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation, a non-corporate Commonwealth entity, from the Home Affairs portfolio to the Attorney-General’s portfolio
  • transfer of responsibility for business registers from the Australian Taxation Office to the Australian Securities and Investment Commission, and
  • transfer of emergency management support functions of the Australian Climate Service from the Bureau of Meteorology to the National Emergency Management Agency.

Join the conversation

58
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Penfold: No. It’s the Coalition which believe public servants are not worthy humans and that contractors will somehow do a better job merely because they are not employed. Result is that many/most contractors are ex-public servants who don’t have to perform as well for as much as double the cost. It also removes expertise from the APS – making Coalition policy a self-fulfilling prophecy. Yes, most contractors do excellent work but usually lack the long-term view. They also work to rule, charge more for overtime and are not on call 24/7.

This mob makes you laugh. For a start it’s as if contractors and consultants aren’t human beings and the only valid human is a public servant. So now there’s 41,000 more public servants with 11,000 of them replacing contractors etc (probably a few thousand) with no demonstrable improvements in output or productivity. Sounds like the taxpayer is the loser and unions the winners. What a joke.

Labor governments feathering the nests of their union piggy banks is pretty standard.

Tubbsy Ringer12:08 pm 26 Mar 25

For sure, the human beings of KPMG sending inflated invoices to Defence, billing for hours never worked and PWC corruptly sharing confidential information to feather their nests and plump up their piggy banks is sooooo much better am I right

Indeed Ken, their removal af the ABCC was one of the lowest points in Australian industrial relations history. And what a shock, crime flourished.

Not to mention the Liberal party’s dumbing down of the public service by feathering the nests of those labour hire firms who contribute so much to the party’s coffers.

Then there was the swindle involving PwC and the other Big 4 corporate giants defrauding taxpayers over many years during the last terms of the Liberal government. Using and leaking privileged government secrets which they themselves helped write to major corporations including Google to avoid tax laws. Does this bring back memories Ken M?

Just the tip of the iceberg!

How has abolishing the ABCC and transferring its responsibilities to the Fair Work Ombudsman increased crime Penfold?

It is absoloutely the very tip of the iceberg, Jack D. The waste that goes on inside the public service makes anything PWC and the other 3 has done look like absolutely nothing in real terms. As we speak, at this time of year every year, literally billions is wasted in budget burning exercises within the APS for fear of having next years cut if this years isn’t all spent. I should know. I used to make a fortune in sales commission on crap they didn’t need between March and June every year.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.