12 September 2024

Candidates clash on regulation, the economy and a fast train to Sydney in a lively ACT election forum

| Oliver Jacques
Join the conversation
9
Region election forum

Professor Chris Wallace, Leanne Castley, Jillian Reid, Martin Greenwood, moderator Genevieve Jacobs, Leanne Foresti, Canberra Business Chamber’s Archie Tsirimokos and ACTCOSS CEO Dr Devin Bowles. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

Does Canberra have a booming economy that’s the envy of Australia or is it being choked by regulation that’s driving companies interstate?

Two contrasting portrayals of the capital were presented by candidates in the first of three Region election forums that took place at the Lonsdale St Studio on Wednesday (11 September).

ACT Labor Kurrajong candidate Martin Greenwood, Canberra Liberals Yerrabi MLA Leanne Castley, Greens’ Kurrajong candidate Jillian Reid and Independents for Canberra Ginninderra candidate Leanne Foresti were all given tough questions on the economy and business by moderator Genevieve Jacobs and a panel of experts – the Canberra Business Chamber’s Archie Tsirimokos, ACT Council of Social Services CEO Dr Devin Bowles and the University of Canberra’s Chris Wallace.

Two candidates at debate

Independents for Canberra’s Leanne Foresti and Labor’s Martin Greenwood were at odds over whether Canberra is a good place to do business. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

While it didn’t quite match the fire of the Donald Trump v Kamala Harris presidential debate earlier that day, the forum saw candidates clash on topics such as whether Canberra is over-regulated, housing, payroll tax, the ACT’s falling credit rating, labour shortages, the Greens’ proposal to replace Thoroughbred Park with a residential suburb and whether Canberra needs a fast train to Sydney.

Mr Greenwood talked up the local economy for most of the evening and said the capital remains a good place to do business.

“The ACT has seen 34 years of uninterrupted economic growth. We have consistently delivered the strongest labour market in Australia with the lowest rate of unemployment … we also have the lowest rate of income inequality,” he said.

READ ALSO Man dies after falling from moving vehicle on Anzac Parade

Ms Castley painted a very different picture.

“[Many] businesses … say If I could pick up my business and move it to Queanbeyan 20 minutes down the road, I would be much better off,” she said.

“The [ACT Government] set up a better regulation taskforce … but very little regulation has been eased across the ACT, that’s something we will certainly look at.

“There are over 100 pieces of regulation for the construction industry to get there head around, most of them only have one or two employees.”

Two women debating

The Greens Jillian Reid and the Liberals’ Leanne Castley. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

Ms Forresti said that as a small business owner herself, she felt her sector was struggling.

“I know subcontractors are not being currently supported in the ACT; we do not have stringent security of payment laws … the only way we can really grow is to concentrate on the biggest drivers of growth, small business and construction … we have an over-reliance on subcontractors.”

Ms Reid also said she wanted to help small businesses grow but was asked by moderator Genevieve Jacobs about perceptions her party were “economic terrorists” for wanting to turn Thoroughbred Park into a new residential suburb.

“The Greens have vision. [Thoroughbred Park] is a space that is used by a small number of people who can still go to Queanbeyan to watch horses, if they wish … to deliver a whole new community within that space is solving a problem [we need to solve],” she said.

“The Greens are a fan of sport; I went to watch the boy Matildas, sorry, the Socceroos, at the stadium … but we can’t be prioritising a stadium when we have people that don’t have a house.”

READ ALSO Government adjusts tree protection laws following feedback

Skill shortages came up repeatedly during the evening.

Professor Chris Wallace from the University of Canberra asked candidates if they would support the development of a very fast train from Canberra to Sydney to give the ACT easier access to labour from Australia’s biggest city.

“[Chief Minister] Andrew Barr committed a business case to the Morrison Government … but they decided Sydney to Newcastle was where the money should go – but absolutely [a fast train from Canberra] should be a focus of investment,” Mr Greenwood said.

Other candidates weren’t as keen on the idea.

“That might be one of the solutions; I don’t know the specifics on that … but making sure that people have somewhere to live when they get here would be another driver,” Ms Reid said.

A second debate between the leaders of ACT Labor, the Canberra Liberals, the ACT Greens and Independents for Canberra will be broadcast live on the Riotact Facebook page at 6 pm on Thursday, 18 September.

Readers are invited to submit a short video question of 30 seconds or less to editor@region.com.au.

Join the conversation

9
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

I was also disappointed by the narrow focus of the debate and the questioning.
Those from the opposition parties did an awful lot of complaining about doing business in the ACT, providing no input into what policies they would bring to the table should they win government. Labor candidate Martin Greenwood provided good input and seemed to be across government policy.
All panelists agreed that Canberra should be open for business however, Ms Foresti a business owner running as an independent for IFC, in answering a panel question, was arguing for businesses in Canberra to be given more public handouts to protect them from outside competitors. What government would be silly enough to do that?
The government has been blamed for laws which they have introduced to control shoddy building practices. It was only recently in this publication that the opposition was complaining about the Security of Payment Act introduced by the government to protect workers and their families from unscrupulous behaviour by business, such as trading in the ACT while insolvent, going bankrupt owing customers and workers hundreds of thousands and sometimes millions of dollars and unlikely ever to be repaid. The opposition has been complaining about the government’s MOU which was introduced to protect worker’s rights, including health and safety promising to scrap it should they win government. These important topics were never raised during the debate.
This is the first debate in the media for this year’s election that I know of, and I am looking forward to the leaders debate next week.

I was disappointed in the limited subject focus and the questioning, with me wanting to know more about what the candidates and their parties had to offer on a variety of issues, rather than them focusing on negativity and Labor. Labor candidate Martin Greenwood did well all the same.

Leanne Castley, the Liberals deputy provided no policy ideas on what her party is offering. Ms Castley and the other candidates were allowed to get away with cherry picking, putting down Canberra by claiming that business activity is in ruin with businesses boarded up and being forced to close, despite statistics proving otherwise.

I was disappointed Ms Castley was not asked any questions on her health portfolio. The Canberra Liberals are the most conservative division of the party in the country and 35 days out from the election, they have not released any health policies. Ms Castley and the party’s voting record raises significant concerns for me. How will the Canberra Liberals’ values impact on policies the party has previously opposed? Drug law reforms, mental health, women’s health and reproductive choices, end of life decisions, LGBTQIA+ rights, safe schools to name a few? Do the Canberra Liberals intend to match the government’s plans to extend Canberra and North Canberra Hospitals?

The party has been hinting at getting rid of the nurse led walk in centres and were fervently against the government’s acquisition of the Catholic owned and publicly funded Calvary Hospital. Ms Castley confirmed that her party will remove payroll taxes introduced to encourage more bulk billing from our GP’s who currently have the highest payroll tax-free threshold in the nation of $2 million, but hazy on other tax reforms.

These are important questions for Canberra voters but were not asked!

Canberra’s economy IS being choked by regulation that’s driving companies interstate.

Canberra’s economy is being choked by regulation that’s driving companies interstate? A high-speed train between Canberra and Sydney should be pursued as it would be fantastic for the Canberra economy.

wildturkeycanoe8:22 am 13 Sep 24

“[Thoroughbred Park] is a space that is used by a small number of people who can still go to Queanbeyan to watch horses, if they wish ”
Pretty much sums up Green ideology. If it’s art or music there is no limit to the budget but anything that’s actually fun for most people is taboo. No wonder Canberra has become so stale. How can we be expected to attract visitors when they are shutting down everything?

As most interstate people I know describe the difference in the last 20+ years, dirty, unkempt, rename it Dullandboringville.

It’s much cheaper to do business in Queanbeyan. Watch that new Poplars development boom. Land tax is much cheaper over there too.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.