Catholic Church will not break seal of confession on child abuse

Genevieve Jacobs 28 March 2019 100

Archbishop Prowse says he welcomes new reporting legislation in the ACT. File photo.

Catholic Archbishop Christopher Prowse has welcomed and endorsed new ACT legislation requiring all adults to report child sexual abuse, but will not direct priests to break the seal of confession regarding the crime.

The Crimes Act (ACT) will now require any person over 18 who identifies or believes that a child is being abused to report the matter to police. Attorney-General Gordon Ramsay has made it clear that the new legislation applies to all adults without exception and that while religious practices should be treated with respect, they are specifically not an exception to the law.

Instead, Archbishop Prowse will direct priests who hear a confession from an abuser to “do all they can to bring the matter outside the confessional” to report it. He believed this could be negotiated without breaking the seal of confession.

In a media briefing, Archbishop Prowse said he believed that it would be difficult for priests to know who had made the confession of abuse since it frequently takes place behind a grille without names or identifying details being exchanged.

However several rites of confession exist, including face-to-face sacraments. A priest who heard a confession of abuse in these circumstances and could not induce the person to repeat the confession would, therefore, be in direct breach of the law.

Church officials argued at the briefing that such confessions would be rare and more likely to take place in jail after an offence has been proved. They believed that anyone making a genuine confession would have a sincere resolve to confess their crime without requiring a priest to make the report.

Children disclosing abuse in the confessional would be told clearly that they had not committed any sin, and all possible attempts would be made to help and support them. Archbishop Prowse said that children needed “compassionate reassurance”, and spoke about the Church’s “heightened awareness” of how to handle such disclosures.

This includes a diocesan-wide education program focused on reporting abuse to the proper authorities rather than in confession. Archbishop Prowse said the ten principles for child-safe institutions formulated by the Royal Commission were now completely embedded in Church practices.

The Archdiocese has established an Institute for Professional Standards and Safeguarding and complaints are managed by a panel of four women including two lawyers, a psychologist and an experienced school counsellor. The panel’s role is to investigate and manage allegations including reporting to police.

Archbishop Prowse said that he believed it would be rare for a case of child abuse to be reported for the first time in a confessional setting, adding that all other adults working in the Catholic education and health care systems would be under an equal obligation to report the abuse.

In that context, he believed that “confessional conundrums” were a red herring, and that the commitment to a culture of child safety should be first and foremost in all Church dealings. The Archbishop has also written to all parishioners, noting that the abuse of children and vulnerable people is both a crime and a sin and therefore requires both a civil and church response.

Archbishop Prowse said the Catholic Church has been through “great shame and humiliation” in the community with regard to child abuse, but that the legislative changes created an opportunity to show leadership that had been absent in the past.

“This has been like a bushfire that burns but also regenerates,” he said.”I want to be a part of that. I have hope in my heart about this. It’s a journey and it will take time because we have a long way to go. Given low credibility many feel about the Church, here is an opportunity to create a turning point. That would be my hope. You might say it’s futile and naive but I do live in that hope.”

What's Your Opinion?

Please login to post your comments, or connect with
100 Responses to Catholic Church will not break seal of confession on child abuse
Craig Stobbs Craig Stobbs 5:25 pm 29 Mar 19

Give unto Caesar that which is due to Caesar

BlowMeDown BlowMeDown 9:20 am 29 Mar 19

Why not extend this law to all crimes?

Wayne Moyle Wayne Moyle 4:37 am 29 Mar 19

ridiculous if you tell sinners that their priest will dob the sinners in, THEY WILL SAY NOTHING, at least as it stands now they can do something to remove those from danger, even if that means we don't find out directly who did the sinning.

indirectly if priests save kids being molested, the parents can work out who the culprit is, and CONVINCE their kids to tell!

Now lots watch everyone take this the wrong way!?

Ian Ian 10:56 pm 28 Mar 19

Compliance should be very easy for Government to secure. Just tell the Church that unless they co-operate 100% they will lose all government funding for their activities, including schools and hospitals, any concessions on taxes and the government will simply refuse to deal with them.

Anthony Gordo Anthony Gordo 8:35 pm 28 Mar 19

Refusing to report abuse is not a child safety culture.

Dan Grallelis Dan Grallelis 4:37 pm 28 Mar 19

The church is wrong. Ids.

Kathy Lester Kathy Lester 3:43 pm 28 Mar 19

It's a crime report it. No institution is above the law.

Russell Nankervis Russell Nankervis 2:36 pm 28 Mar 19

You are not above the law

Spiral Spiral 2:05 pm 28 Mar 19

I agree it would not always be easy for a priest to identify a culprit, but when they can they should follow the law and act.

And while we are reviewing the law and religious organisations, it is well past the time when we should be allowing them to discriminate on the basis of gender.

Since many religious organisations seem to be unable to willingly recruit women into their “clergy” it seems to be time to enforce a quota on them, as is being pushed on many other organisations.

It is amazing how many people who claim to be disgusted at the Liberal Party’s problem with women will suddenly become blind once they step through the doors into their place of worship.

Hold these organisations to the same standards as the rest of us.

They claim to be our moral leaders and guides. Surely they should be leading the movement towards equality, not trying to block it.

Jim Culbertson Jim Culbertson 9:43 am 28 Mar 19

Then cut their public funding. Immediately. And arrest the first clergy who seeks to conceal the confession of ANY criminal offender. They are neither judge nor jury and are not above the law.

Duncan Hinton Duncan Hinton 7:27 am 28 Mar 19

so he would rather be an enabler, protect a child abuser over a child.. Certainly not following the Christian ethic. The seal of Confessional is a Catholic church thing.. not the Law of the land which is secular.. People constantly bleat about the muslim faith breaking the law.. so hypocritical. There is no logical reason for Confession

Elizabeth Ann Thurbon Elizabeth Ann Thurbon 5:56 am 28 Mar 19

Above the law - that’s the basis of the problem

Suzanne Garnett Suzanne Garnett 2:24 am 28 Mar 19

Oh so it’s all ok in his eyes so long as you support the victims. Bloody ridiculous

Gilavon Gilavon 11:19 pm 27 Mar 19

So, the Roman church putting itself above the law, learning nothing from the drama of the last few years and drifting to further irrelevance. The late Professor Stephen Hawking said it best when describing religion: “For people scared of the dark”.

Sarelle Woodward Sarelle Woodward 9:57 pm 27 Mar 19

That’s okay - you can just go to jail like everyone else who breaks the law.

Bill Thompson Bill Thompson 9:43 pm 27 Mar 19

Didn’t Thoreau write an essay on civil disobedience?

Greg Stix Greg Stix 9:41 pm 27 Mar 19

To know about it and doing nothing is condoning those actions. Disgusting

Andre Poidomani Andre Poidomani 9:31 pm 27 Mar 19

This is very disheartening. No one is saying to get rid of the confessional.

What the church doesn’t have a right is to protect perpetrators of abuse (then again they are very good at covering their own and move them on to other parishes)

Medics, teachers etc have a responsibility to report any abuses to authorities.

Priest MUST be able to report as well. Otherwise I say to them, How can you sleep at night knowing you failed to protect a persons life.

The church has a responsibility to it’s congregation and the wider community.

Boweavil Kat Boweavil Kat 9:27 pm 27 Mar 19

Shut them down

Ираида Воскресение Ираида Воскресение 9:22 pm 27 Mar 19

I can't see myself working in a job that allows me to conceal such information.

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site