Skip to content Skip to main navigation

Community

Buying or selling? Get the right advice

How to ruin a chugger’s day!

By joingler 15 August 2012 41

Well there has been a drop in the number of chuggers recently but they are still around. I have discovered the best way to get back of them when they take things too far.

About 6 weeks ago I was stopped in Garema Place by a guy representing UNICEF. We had a bit of a chat about charities I already support etc. He then tried to sign me up for a monthly donation. I told him I couldn’t afford to support another charity as I have an unstable income but I was in a position to give a one off donation. He said that UNICEF don’t offer that option. I then advised him I would go support a charity that does let me do this. He then accused me of all sorts of things, swore at me and told me if I actually cared about anyone in the world apart from myself I would give to him. Wanting to show him how much of a douchebag he was being, I gave in. I signed up but deliberately put the wrong expiry date on my debit card.

Fast forward to last week and I got a phone call from UNICEF saying the payment didn’t go through. I told them about the chugger and how he abused me in public for not being in a position to give a regular amount. The operator was horrified at this and apologised on behalf of UNICEF. I said it was fine, it was not her fault.

Today in the mail, I got a letter from the manager of the chugger apologising for the incident and thanking me for bringing it to her attention. The letter also said that the chugger (who travels NSW and ACT for his ‘job’) will be spoken to about etiquette and acceptance of other peoples circumstances. She made no excuses and offered me her direct phone number if I wanted to discuss further. She also advised me that I can make a one off donation but only by using their website. She also said she understood if I did not want to give to UNICEF again.

So there you go guys. If chuggers continually go too far, simply do a fake sign up, put the wrong date on your card and watch things happen. I have made formal complaints about chuggers before but never heard anything from them. This seems to be an effective way to deal with them.

NOTE: I do not have anything against people who ask for donations to charities. My problem is when I am abused because I am unable to give. Thumbs up to the Salvos and RSPCA. They are always friendly and never try to bully anyone into anything (perhaps too nice??)

What’s Your opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
41 Responses to
How to ruin a chugger’s day!
Filter
Showing only Website comments
Order
Newest to Oldest
Oldest to Newst
VYBerlinaV8_is_back 6:46 pm 16 Aug 12

DarkLadyWolfMother said :

Eyeball In A Quart Jar Of Snot said :

It doesn’t cost the charities anything, and in return they get some money, but I don’t think it’s worth tarnishing their image employing this company who from what I hear train their staff (students, international students) to be purposely be aggressive in their approach.

Absolutely their image should be tarnished. You can’t remove responsibility just because you contract out…

Damn right. They’re tarnished in my eyes.

DarkLadyWolfMother 5:31 pm 16 Aug 12

Eyeball In A Quart Jar Of Snot said :

It doesn’t cost the charities anything, and in return they get some money, but I don’t think it’s worth tarnishing their image employing this company who from what I hear train their staff (students, international students) to be purposely be aggressive in their approach.

Absolutely their image should be tarnished. You can’t remove responsibility just because you contract out…

Eyeball In A Quart Jar Of Snot 5:26 pm 16 Aug 12

1337Hax0r said :

My son was walking through Civic one day near the start of the year and was approached by a chugger who had a beard and dreadlocks who said he was from World Vision. He asked my son to sign up. My son explained he was a uni student and could not afford to donate. The chugger said “You still have money for beer and smokes.” My son replied that no, he didn’t drink or smoke and that he didn’t have money for that. The chugger then said “But you can still afford to donate.” My son started to walk off. The chugger yelled after him “You’re pathetic man.”

The following day when I went to ask for his ID, the chugger refused to show it to me. He did ask me to sign up for World Vision and Amnesty International first though. I already donated to Amnesty, and was very tempted to cancel my donation on the spot but believe in the work they do. However, a few weeks later, I moved my subscription from Amnesty to Medicines San Frontiers due to the actions of that chugger.

The message to charities, some times your hard sell techniques fail. Rethink chuggers.

Unfortunately you’ll find that Amnesty, World Vision, Medicines San Frontiers, and several other international charities all employ Cornucopia to do chugging for them.

It doesn’t cost the charities anything, and in return they get some money, but I don’t think it’s worth tarnishing their image employing this company who from what I hear train their staff (students, international students) to be purposely be aggressive in their approach.

And of course there’s the issue of them being misleading because they don’t inform you that most of your donation is not actually going to the charity itself.

Overheard 4:37 pm 16 Aug 12

Nightshade said :

Overheard said :

After a previous story here, and having seen one of my fave charities was going down the chugger route, I called the fundraising manager and had a long chat about the rationale, the practice, the policies, etc.

I won’t relay it all here. Dot points: bust your balls and spend hours of time and thousands of dollars to raise tens of thousands OR employ others to raise $1mil+.

[…]

Suspend disbelief, and consider that maybe, just maybe, the charity is doing the best it can with the available resources.

I understand what you’re saying here, and can see the attraction of this fundraising method. However, when charities refuse one-off donations and decide they only want regular donors, they need to remember that no one is obliged to give them money. If their preferred type of donation doesn’t suit their donor-base, they have to accept that people have every right to say no.

Presumably chuggers are still with us because enough people say yes.

Yep, totally agree. If a charity won’t take a one-off donation, then they deserve the three-fifths of f-all someone offers them in return.

I had this last year sometime when a well-meaning mob had card tables set up at many shopping centres raising funds for the paralympics (if I rightly recall). I had a great old chat with the card-tablers (as I don’t mind a chat) but ultimately they had no facility other than to sign me up for amounts that were beyond my reach. They were not pushy or rude or abusive, but I had to politely decline the offer.

As for others getting badly abused (like the poster with the Amnesty International experience (‘You’re pathetic, man’) then yes, I’d be very tempted to withdraw my support, and that would usefully, if sadly, send a pretty strong message to the organisation that they’ve got it badly wrong and should review their recruiting techniques.

I’m prepared to bet that whatever the commissions are they’re hardly substantial. And if you pay peanuts….

watto23 10:35 am 16 Aug 12

in this day and age of social media and the internet I find it hard to believe that charities could not collect donations far easier online, without wasting so much money giving it to collection companies. I personally don’t give to charities that use chuggers.

The salvos guy always gets money from me, even if its just silver coins. If the chuggers were so passionate about their charity, they’d donate a couple of hours a week to collect at lunchtimes.

Deref 7:39 am 16 Aug 12

pikiran_keruh said :

ask the chugger how much of their commission they are donating …

+1

Excellent!

1337Hax0r 7:23 am 16 Aug 12

My son was walking through Civic one day near the start of the year and was approached by a chugger who had a beard and dreadlocks who said he was from World Vision. He asked my son to sign up. My son explained he was a uni student and could not afford to donate. The chugger said “You still have money for beer and smokes.” My son replied that no, he didn’t drink or smoke and that he didn’t have money for that. The chugger then said “But you can still afford to donate.” My son started to walk off. The chugger yelled after him “You’re pathetic man.”

The following day when I went to ask for his ID, the chugger refused to show it to me. He did ask me to sign up for World Vision and Amnesty International first though. I already donated to Amnesty, and was very tempted to cancel my donation on the spot but believe in the work they do. However, a few weeks later, I moved my subscription from Amnesty to Medicines San Frontiers due to the actions of that chugger.

The message to charities, some times your hard sell techniques fail. Rethink chuggers.

Henry82 12:12 am 16 Aug 12

Nightshade said :

Fair enough for potential donors to want that information. However, I personally wouldn’t expect people to be charity collectors for free – even asking for one-off donations is not a fun job. Sure, high profile charities can recruit armies of volunteer collectors for their annual fundraising drives, but there are so many charities I doubt they could all find volunteers to collect for them all the time. I have nothing against them paying people to do it..

And that’s fine, you can donate to whoever you like. I’m not saying Chuggers should be banned (well if i had my way they would be), but the compromise is open collection standards. At least people would know where their money is going (on the spot). I do wonder how many people are pissed off because they’re harassed by chuggers, and subsequently avoid charities (or unpaid collectors) all together. I certainly don’t think they’ve done any favours for store owners around Garema Place.

For example: I’m much less likely to use/click a referral link if it’s been deliberately hidden or misrepresented. If someone said ‘this is my referral link, i get x for every subscriber’ i’d be far more likely to click it on the basis that they’ve declared their affiliation/potential bias with the company.

Nightshade 10:59 pm 15 Aug 12

Overheard said :

After a previous story here, and having seen one of my fave charities was going down the chugger route, I called the fundraising manager and had a long chat about the rationale, the practice, the policies, etc.

I won’t relay it all here. Dot points: bust your balls and spend hours of time and thousands of dollars to raise tens of thousands OR employ others to raise $1mil+.

[…]

Suspend disbelief, and consider that maybe, just maybe, the charity is doing the best it can with the available resources.

I understand what you’re saying here, and can see the attraction of this fundraising method. However, when charities refuse one-off donations and decide they only want regular donors, they need to remember that no one is obliged to give them money. If their preferred type of donation doesn’t suit their donor-base, they have to accept that people have every right to say no.

Presumably chuggers are still with us because enough people say yes.

Nightshade 10:37 pm 15 Aug 12

Henry82 said :

Really what they need is a compulsory badge for all charity collectors. One that advises people if they’re paid or volunteer. How much commission they get, and what % of the money goes to the actual charity. Kind of like the nutrition labels on food.

Fair enough for potential donors to want that information. However, I personally wouldn’t expect people to be charity collectors for free – even asking for one-off donations is not a fun job. Sure, high profile charities can recruit armies of volunteer collectors for their annual fundraising drives, but there are so many charities I doubt they could all find volunteers to collect for them all the time. I have nothing against them paying people to do it.

I’m less enthused about the chugger model where, as others have observed, most of your first year or two of donations goes to the collection company, not the charity. That’s way too much of my donation. If I wanted to sign up as a regular donor, I’d rather do it on the charity’s website so they could have all of my donation.

That said, I *haven’t* signed up on anyone’s website of my own free will, and I can see from a charity’s perspective that hiring a chugger to prod me into it would be to their advantage … provided I’m persuaded by their chugger and not someone elses, and stick with them for a few years.

Comic_and_Gamer_Nerd 9:55 pm 15 Aug 12

String them along and waste their time. Thats what I do. They are no better than telephone scammers. The charity gets fuck all, the rest goes to to multinational companies.

If you want to donate do it via website.

Mordd 9:48 pm 15 Aug 12

I just tell them I don’t use credit cards or bank accounts anymore, but if they can bill me in Bitcoins I will happily donate… for some reason they always walk away at that point, rude buggers! 😛

schmeah 8:42 pm 15 Aug 12

I got hit up by a Greenpeace chugger once. Rude little shite.

I stated how I already gave to 3 charities, one of which is an environmental body. He asked me to name them, which I did, so he could argue how Greenpeace was a better ‘sort’ of organisation. I went onto list the environmentally conscientious activities I make time for in my every day life; having my own vegetable garden, composting and bike riding to name a few. With every claim I made this little feral cut in saying “so do I” or “me too” .. I walked away but had him chasing me half way through Garema Court saying .. “I haven’t finished talking to you vest girl” (as I was wearing a vest .. big surprise) .. seriously, some of them need to be taken down a peg. It’s best to choose what charities you want to give to and commit to them, others who approach you will have to find someone else.

00davist 7:58 pm 15 Aug 12

HenryBG said :

p1 said :

Henry82 said :

Really what they need is a compulsory badge for all charity collectors. One that advises people if they’re paid or volunteer. How much commission they get, and what % of the money goes to the actual charity. Kind of like the nutrition labels on food.

For a second then I though HenryBG had said something I agreed with.

I agree anyway, for what it’s worth.

How come these Chuggers never pester me when I walk through Civic?

Wait, You leave your house?

Kinda thought someone who trolls as consistently as you would be somewhat more reclusive than all that ‘outside’ business!

G.R.R 7:58 pm 15 Aug 12

joingler said :

What would that achieve? I reckon my actions may have actually done some good. The manager is aware of his actions. She will speak to him and maybe he will change his attitude and not do this anymore to anyone.

Or he’ll get fired and end up killing himself cause he couldn’t even hold down a chugger job. Kudos to you for not being able to say ‘f*ck off’ to someone abusing you =)

Thumper 7:52 pm 15 Aug 12

joingler said :

Henry82 said :

I’m not sure if it’s a win, they still got your details.

Really what they need is a compulsory badge for all charity collectors. One that advises people if they’re paid or volunteer. How much commission they get, and what % of the money goes to the actual charity. Kind of like the nutrition labels on food.

Fair point. But I can easily mark their emails as spam. I can also change my number if things get too bad. But since the letter, I have had no correspondence at all except for their monthly newsletter (which I said to the operator on the phone I was happy to keep receiving).

Thumper said :

He then accused me of all sorts of things, swore at me and told me if I actually cared about anyone in the world apart from myself I would give to him. Wanting to show him how much of a douchebag he was being, I gave in. I signed up but deliberately put the wrong expiry date on my debit card.

Geez man, why didn’t you simply tell him to go f*ck himself.

Pretty simple really.

What would that achieve? I reckon my actions may have actually done some good. The manager is aware of his actions. She will speak to him and maybe he will change his attitude and not do this anymore to anyone.

Man, if you’re happy to be abused by a charity collector then I have no problem with that.

Frankly, if someone is going to abuse me I’m happy to tell them where to go.

But, each to their own.

00davist 7:44 pm 15 Aug 12

There is not one person in Civic, or anywhere else for that matter who has approached me for money and received even the slightest response, let alone a single red cent.

However, the lovely gentleman who volunteers for the salvo’s, and sit’s quietly inside the centre, gets my lunch change pretty much daily, usually only a few gold coins, but when I only have silver or no change, he gets a note or two.

I will only ever give to those who do not harass me in the street!

LSWCHP 7:42 pm 15 Aug 12

joingler said :

What would that achieve? I reckon my actions may have actually done some good. The manager is aware of his actions. She will speak to him and maybe he will change his attitude and not do this anymore to anyone.

Or maybe not. Being appointed a manager doesn’t endow you with super powers. Most people, including managers of other people, are afraid of conflict, particularly with someone who may be an aggressive douchebag. I suspect that this is why life in the APS is such a misery.

Anyway, colour me cynical, but I wouldn’t be at all surprised if the manager-person feigned upsettageness in order to fob you off, and then went back to sipping her coffee while reading RA or the local equivalent. Conflict avoided, customer soothed, problem solved.

joingler 7:28 pm 15 Aug 12

Henry82 said :

I’m not sure if it’s a win, they still got your details.

Really what they need is a compulsory badge for all charity collectors. One that advises people if they’re paid or volunteer. How much commission they get, and what % of the money goes to the actual charity. Kind of like the nutrition labels on food.

Fair point. But I can easily mark their emails as spam. I can also change my number if things get too bad. But since the letter, I have had no correspondence at all except for their monthly newsletter (which I said to the operator on the phone I was happy to keep receiving).

Thumper said :

He then accused me of all sorts of things, swore at me and told me if I actually cared about anyone in the world apart from myself I would give to him. Wanting to show him how much of a douchebag he was being, I gave in. I signed up but deliberately put the wrong expiry date on my debit card.

Geez man, why didn’t you simply tell him to go f*ck himself.

Pretty simple really.

What would that achieve? I reckon my actions may have actually done some good. The manager is aware of his actions. She will speak to him and maybe he will change his attitude and not do this anymore to anyone.

Jethro 4:26 pm 15 Aug 12

HenryBG said :

How come these Chuggers never pester me when I walk through Civic?

Your reputation precedes you.

Related Articles

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top
Copyright © 2018 Riot ACT Holdings Pty Ltd. All rights reserved.
the-riotact.com | aboutregional.com.au | b2bmagazine.com.au | thisiscanberra.com

Search across the site