25 May 2022

Is Ricky Stuart's job under pressure at the Raiders?

| Tim Gavel
Join the conversation
Ricky Stuart. Photo: File.

Ricky Stuart on the side-line showing his passion for the team. Photo: File.

During the 2013 NRL season, in the midst of the Canberra Raiders’ worst run of losses in the club’s history, coach David Furner’s position was publicly guaranteed by a board member.

Towards the back end of Furner’s tenure, after eight losses in a row and with just six wins for the entire season, it was obvious change was required. His position wasn’t helped by the off-field behaviour of Josh Dugan and Blake Ferguson, who were sacked during the 2013 season.

David Furner was informed of the board’s decision three rounds before the end of the 2013 season. Don, his brother and CEO of the club, drove with a heavy heart to a team training camp on the South Coast to inform him of his sacking. The impromptu camp had been scheduled in a bid to turn things around on the field.

In the context of the Raiders history, it was a momentous decision. The club had never sacked a first grade coach.

Wayne Bennet, co-coach of the Canberra Raiders in 1987. Photo: Raiders.

Wayne Bennet, co-coach of the Canberra Raiders in 1987. Photo: Raiders.

A succession plan was in place for Wayne Bennett to take over from Don Furner (Snr), who coached the Raiders from 1982 to 1987. But then Bennett left to coach the Broncos after co-coaching with Don Furner in 1987. Tim Sheens coached the side to three premierships before heading to the Cowboys.

Mal Meninga. Photo: Adam McGrath.

Green Machine legend Mal Meninga coached the Raiders for five seasons. Photo: Adam McGrath.

There was also succession plan during Mal Meninga’s reign as coach from 1997 to 2001, with Matthew Elliott taking over before heading to the Panthers after the 2006 season. Neil Henry took over until 2008 before heading to the Cowboys with David Furner installed as the coach in 2009.

In terms of winning percentages, Tim Sheens, as you would expect with three premierships, is on top with 67 per cent. Mal Meninga had a 53 per cent winning percentage as coach, and Ricky Stuart is next best with around 50 per cent.

Canberra Raiders players celebrating 1989 grand final victory

The Canberra Raiders celebrating after their grand final victory over Balmain Tigers in the 1989 grand final. Photo: File.

Which brings us to the present day, with the critics out of hibernation calling for Stuart to be sacked after the side’s third loss in a row.

The same critics appear to have short memories and a lack of understanding of Raiders’ history.

Stuart took the side to the grand final in 2019 and the preliminary final in 2020. Injuries have created havoc with a third of the anticipated spine missing. Josh Hodgson is out for the season and half, Jamal Fogarty, is also out for an extended period.

A number of clubs have a history of sacking coaches in a manner akin to the English Premier League. The Raiders are not one of those clubs.

READ ALSO Canberra United’s Kelly Stirton brings a love of football to players of all abilities

The David Furner decision was particularly painful for the board as they have a ‘pick and stick mentality’ that has served the club well.

So painful was the decision to sack Furner that Raiders chairman John McIntyre stepped down as he dealt with the angst and emotional toll.

This is why there is zero pressure on Stuart from the board.

It is not an acceptance of mediocrity. In part, it’s an understanding of the pressure that a coach would be putting on himself. And with Ricky, he has demonstrated that he is one of the NRL’s most competitive individuals.

Significantly, it’s also a stance the board has long taken to avoid making knee-jerk decisions to satisfy the media and the critics.

So save your breath, Ricky Stuart isn’t going anywhere.

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments

Last night’s match – Time to go Ricky

Capital Retro11:29 am 25 Apr 22

Also time for the “bunker” to go.

The Raiders had a slim chance up until half-time but blunders by the bunker overruling the on-field referee soon changed that.

Once they start winning youll all be jumping on the bandwagon like every year. bag bag bag, oh they are winning, my Raiders what a great team. pathetic fair weather supporters…………

Ricky is a damn good coach and the Raiders will come good this season.

Only one thing I’m not liking about him is what seems to be him publicly criticising the team and it’s players after a loss.

He’s the coach so part of his job is to motivate the players not tear them down is it not?

The Faders would have to be the most boring team to watch. Add the fact that they can only play for 40 minutes before running out of puff (exception being the game against the Titans). Ricky Stuart has had his time. He was hopeless at Parramatta and the one premiership he did win with the Roosters was on autopilot, thanks to a team of talent. Time to go

I’d question how well the “pick and stick” mentality has served the club given no premiership for the past 28 years, and not too many serious challenges for one in that time.

Capital Retro8:13 am 20 Apr 22

The Raiders desperately need a playmaker and someone to run off them.

Also, Stuart seems unable to teach winning skills to his kickers. For example, the Storm and Manly have players who regularly kick 40/20s and generally score a try form the ensuing play.

It’s a long time since I’ve seen the Raiders pull off a 40/20.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.